I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
The plain version first: if you think MPAC has assessed your home too high, step one is not hiring anyone and not launching an appeal. It is filing a Request for Reconsideration (RfR) with MPAC yourself — it is free, and for residential property it is a mandatory first step in law. Skip it, and the door to an appeal never opens. Just as important: Ontario assessments are still anchored to market value as of January 1, 2016, not to what your home would sell for today. Compare against today's prices and you are arguing the wrong question from the start.
First: ask yourself the 2016 question
MPAC is the body that sets the assessed value of every property in Ontario; your municipality multiplies that value by its tax rates to produce your tax bill. The value is not set as of today. It is set as of a legislated valuation date, which remains January 1, 2016, because the province has repeatedly postponed the next reassessment. The 2026 tax year still runs on fully phased-in 2016 values.
So the first question, the one MPAC itself puts to owners, is this: could you have sold your property on January 1, 2016, for the assessed value on your notice? If yes, the number is broadly right. If no, you have something to work with. The right comparisons are the assessments and sales of similar homes around that 2016 date — not what your neighbour's house sold for last month. Market moves since 2016 do not prove an assessment wrong.
Keep two things separate: value and tax. MPAC sets values only. It does not set tax rates and does not send tax bills. A higher assessment does not automatically mean proportionally higher tax, because your share also depends on how the whole municipal assessment base moved. Arguing value with your city, or tax rates with MPAC, is knocking on the wrong door.
Second: how the RfR works, and its two deadlines
Under section 39.1 of the Assessment Act, an owner (or a person entitled to receive the assessment notice) can ask MPAC to review the value or classification, setting out the reasons and the relevant facts. The mechanics:
| Stage | Rule | Cost |
|---|---|---|
| File the RfR | Annual notice: by March 31 of the tax year. Supplementary or omitted-assessment notice: within 120 days of the issue date on the notice. The date printed on your own notice governs | Free |
| MPAC's reply | Written decision generally within 180 days; MPAC may extend by up to 60 more days if it notifies you within the first 180 | — |
| Appeal if you still disagree | Within 90 days of MPAC's RfR decision, to the Assessment Review Board (ARB) | ARB filing fee applies |
For residential, farm and managed-forest property, the RfR must come first; other property classes may appeal directly. Before filing, check MPAC's own record of your property on AboutMyProperty — living area, age, structure, lot size. A factual error in that record (an overstated floor area, an improvement that does not exist) is the easiest kind of case to win, because there is nothing to argue about. A value argument needs evidence tied to the 2016 valuation date: assessments and sales of comparable properties from around that time.
If MPAC agrees to change the value, it issues a new notice and asks you to sign Minutes of Settlement. Read the new value and the years it covers before signing — your signature accepts that result.
Third: what missing a deadline actually costs
The RfR deadline is a hard line. For residential property, missing it generally takes away your right to appeal to the ARB for that year too, because appeal eligibility is built on having filed the RfR first. The Act leaves a narrow escape hatch — the ARB may extend the RfR deadline for extenuating circumstances, on application within the tax year — but that is an exception, not a plan.
Do not confuse this with two neighbouring procedures. Applications about the tax itself — for example after a demolition, fire or change of use, under the Municipal Act — go to the municipality, on different forms and deadlines. And an RfR is year-specific: it challenges one tax year's assessment. You cannot use this year's filing to reopen earlier years.
A made-up example, in round numbers: suppose your assessed value is $800,000 on the 2016 basis and a near-identical house on your street sits at $720,000. That $80,000 gap, multiplied by the combined municipal and education rate, is hundreds to over a thousand dollars of tax every year, repeating until the next province-wide reassessment. The RfR costs nothing but an evening of assembling evidence. That arithmetic is not close.
Three common misunderstandings
"I renovated recently, so my assessment must be going up — better not to poke it." The anchor date is January 1, 2016. Work done after that date does not enter this valuation date's account. What matters is whether MPAC recorded the property's pre-2016 condition correctly.
"My neighbour just sold for a huge price, so my assessment must be wrong." A sale today proves today's market, not 2016 value. MPAC will not engage on that basis, and neither will the ARB.
"If my assessment drops, my tax drops by the same percentage." Not necessarily. Your bill also depends on the municipal rate and the overall base. The real problem is being assessed high relative to comparable homes on your street, because property tax is essentially a sharing of a total by relative value.
If an assessment notice lands today, do it in this order
- Find the RfR deadline printed on the notice and put it in your calendar — March 31 or 120 days, the notice governs.
- Ask the 2016 question: could this home have sold for the assessed value on January 1, 2016?
- Go through MPAC's record of your property on AboutMyProperty line by line and flag factual errors first.
- Pull the assessed values of similar homes on your street from around the 2016 date and build a short evidence list where the gap is clear.
- File the RfR before the deadline and keep the confirmation. If the decision disappoints, you have 90 days from it to decide on an ARB appeal — get advice from an assessment professional or lawyer if the amounts justify it.
Ming Ren, Broker, RE/MAX Realtron. Assessments are worth challenging — just mind the date, and compare against the right year.
This article is general information, not legal advice. Reconsideration and appeal deadlines follow your notice and the law in force; check MPAC and ARB requirements before acting, and consult an assessment professional or lawyer for complex cases.
Primary sources: Assessment Act, R.S.O. 1990, ss.39.1 and 40 (Ontario e-Laws); MPAC's official guidance on Requests for Reconsideration and AboutMyProperty (mpac.ca, checked November 2026). The $800,000 and $720,000 values are illustrative only, not a real case.


