I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
The plain conclusion first: for a commercial property, the real question is not whether you can challenge the assessment — it is which step you take first. Homeowners must run MPAC's free Request for Reconsideration (RfR) and receive a decision before they can appeal. Commercial, industrial and multi-residential owners carry no such requirement: you may use the free RfR, or skip it and file a paid appeal directly with the Assessment Review Board (ARB). With plenty of time and a clear case, try the free RfR first. Close to the deadline, do not wait — file with the ARB and keep the date in your own hands.
1. Two routes — first check whether the first one is forced on you
MPAC sets the current value and property class of every property in Ontario; your municipality then multiplies the value by its tax rates to produce the tax bill. If the value or the class is wrong, there are two correction routes:
| Route | Who decides | Fee | Who must use it |
|---|---|---|---|
| RfR reconsideration | MPAC | Free | Residential, farm, managed forest and conservation land properties must take this step first and receive a decision before appealing |
| ARB appeal | Assessment Review Board (an independent tribunal) | $318 per roll number for commercial, industrial, multi-residential and other properties, with a $10 discount to e-File | Commercial and other non-residential properties may come here directly, with no RfR decision first |
Mixed-use buildings are the trap: if part of a building is classed residential, that part sits on the mandatory-RfR side, while only the purely commercial part keeps the direct-to-ARB choice. So check the property class on every roll number before choosing a route — never assume the building's main use settles it.
2. Three deadlines — miss one and you wait a year
This fight is lost on the calendar before it is lost on value. Section 39.1 of the Assessment Act governs the RfR and section 40 governs appeals, and the dates are distinct:
- Annual RfR: due by March 31 of the taxation year, and in all cases by the deadline printed on your notice.
- Supplementary, omitted and other notices: for notices of that kind (including omitted assessments under section 33), the window is 120 days from the date the notice was issued — do not confuse it with the annual March 31 date.
- Filing directly with the ARB: annual appeals are likewise due March 31; other notices carry the 120-day window from issuance.
- Appealing after an RfR: if you disagree with MPAC's RfR decision, the ARB appeal is due within 90 days of the mailing date of that decision.
Two more timing points matter. MPAC is generally to respond to an RfR within 180 days, extendable to 240 days if it notifies you within the first period that it needs more time. And an ARB appeal still open on March 31 is deemed to continue into the next taxation year within the same assessment cycle. In plain terms, choosing the RfR hands the start of your appeal clock to MPAC's mailing speed — anyone starting near the end of March should not gamble on it.
3. What you must prove is value on January 1, 2016
Many owners argue from today's market, which aims at the wrong target. Under the current section 19.1 framework, province-wide reassessment has been postponed repeatedly, and assessments for the 2026 tax year still rest on a January 1, 2016 valuation date. Your case is that the property's current value as of that date was set too high, or its class is wrong — not that prices have moved since.
Evidence that actually works is comparable data tied back to that valuation date:
- Sales of comparable properties around the valuation date, and whether MPAC assessed comparable properties noticeably lower than yours — assessments of similar properties should be consistent, which is the equity comparison;
- For commercial property, the income record above all: actual rents, vacancy, operating expenses and the capitalization rates the market was using at the time, because these properties are commonly valued on the income approach;
- Factual errors about the property itself — area, use, condition, functional obsolescence. One wrong fact in MPAC's record can lift the whole value.
An illustrative example, with numbers I have invented purely to show the arithmetic, not a real case: suppose a small commercial plaza is assessed at $8 million and your comparable sales and income data support a 2016 value of $6.8 million — a $1.2 million difference. At an assumed combined tax rate of 2%, a corrected assessment saves roughly $24,000 a year, and the lower value carries through the remaining years of the cycle. That is why a $318 filing fee is rarely the real cost of a long-held property's appeal; the real cost is evidence that is not solid enough. Note also that the ARB will not waive or refund a filing fee absent appropriate circumstances, so do not count on getting it back even if you win — and if you hold several roll numbers, total the fees before deciding how much to appeal.
Three misunderstandings I hear most often
"The free RfR is a homeowner thing — commercial owners can't use it." It is the other way around. The RfR is free and open to every property class. The difference is only that residential and certain other classes are forced to use it first; commercial owners may choose — they are not excluded.
"Values are high because the market ran up — I'll argue from recent sales." The valuation date is still January 1, 2016. A 2025 sale price does not answer a 2016 value question; comparable evidence has to be read back to the valuation date.
"Once the RfR is in, I can relax — deadlines stop mattering." After the RfR, your appeal window is only 90 days from the mailing date of MPAC's decision, and that decision can take up to 240 days to arrive. Record the decision date and count backwards from it; that matters more than anything else in the file.
If you are acting this year, do these six things in order
- Pull out the Property Assessment Notice and check, roll number by roll number, the property class, the assessed value and the deadline printed on the notice — splitting mixed-use properties part by part.
- Ask MPAC's own question: could this property have sold on January 1, 2016 for the assessed value on the notice? If the honest answer is clearly no, the case is worth pursuing.
- Choose the route by the clock: well before March 31, file the free RfR; close to it, e-File directly with the ARB and protect the deadline first.
- Build the evidence to the valuation date: comparable sales, MPAC's values on comparable properties, rent and vacancy records, expense accounts and capitalization-rate support, with every factual error listed and documented.
- Put three dates on the calendar — March 31 (or 120 days from the notice), 90 days from the mailing of any RfR decision, and the point at which an open appeal is deemed into the next year — and trust none of them to memory.
- On a property of any size, have an Ontario assessment-appeal lawyer or licensed representative review the evidence before a hearing. The ARB is a formal tribunal process with disclosure requirements a broker cannot handle for you.
Trust Professional, Diligent Work. I am Ming Ren. An assessment appeal is won on dates and evidence, not on frustration: do not miss the dates, tie the evidence to that 2016 valuation date, and then we can talk about what the property is really worth.
This article is general information only, not legal advice. Property class, notice type and the facts of your timeline affect deadlines and routes. Consult an Ontario lawyer or a licensed assessment-appeal representative before acting.
Primary sources: Assessment Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. A.31, ss.19.1, 33, 39.1, 40 (Ontario e-Laws, consulted November 2026); MPAC guidance on the Request for Reconsideration; Tribunals Ontario — Assessment Review Board, Filing an Appeal and fee chart (consulted November 2026). The $8 million, $6.8 million and 2% figures are illustrative only, not a real case.


