Ming RenBroker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage
☎ 647-779-9186

Selling a Home

Selling While an MPAC Reconsideration or Appeal Is Still Open: Who Ends Up With the Refund — or the Extra Tax Bill?

By , Broker, RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc. (About Ming) · Published

Ming Ren · Broker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage

← All articles · Selling a Home · Category guide

I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.

The plain conclusion: an open assessment dispute does not stop you from selling, but no law automatically splits the outcome between you and your buyer. The municipality refunds whoever is shown on the tax roll on the day it adjusts the bill. Between seller and buyer, only the agreement of purchase and sale decides. The standard OREA Form 100 prorates realty taxes once, to the day of completion, with no readjustment wording for a later assessment result. So the destination of this money must be written into the deal when you sign — not negotiated after the result arrives.

1. Know which track you are on: reconsideration or ARB appeal

The first step on an assessment you believe is too high is usually a Request for Reconsideration (RfR) to MPAC under section 39.1 of the Assessment Act; MPAC sends the reconsideration result to the person who made the request. If you still disagree, an appeal to the Assessment Review Board (ARB) under section 40 must be filed within the statutory deadline. Either process can outlast your closing date. The dispute follows the property's assessment — a change of ownership does not automatically kill it — but who receives notices, who can carry it forward, and which deadlines apply must be checked against your stage of the process and the current MPAC and ARB rules. Do not assume the buyer will chase it for you, and do not assume the seller walks away entirely on closing.

2. The municipality's ledger: refunds follow the roll, and arrears can follow the property

When the municipality adjusts a tax account under section 341 of the Municipal Act, 2001, an overpayment is refunded to the owner shown on the tax roll on the date of the adjustment, while an underpayment is billed again — and tax amounts can be collected from the original taxpayer or a later owner, and can form a lien on the property (see section 349). In plain terms: if the appeal succeeds after closing and the assessment drops, the refund cheque will most likely be made out to your buyer, because the buyer is on the roll by then. If the result goes the other way and more tax is owing, that bill can also land on the buyer — even though you were the one who paid tax in those years. That is how the system is built; the only way to change it between the two of you is by contract.

3. Between you and the buyer, one tool only: write it into the APS

Because the statutory default creates a surprise for one side or the other, deal with all three outcomes at signing: taxes already paid before closing stay under the Form 100 apportionment; any refund arising from the dispute after closing, net of the reasonable cost of carrying the dispute, goes back to the seller for the periods the seller actually paid (or is split as agreed); and any additional tax arising from the same dispute is allocated expressly. Add who is responsible for continuing the dispute, an obligation to forward MPAC and ARB correspondence, and an exchange of result documents. An illustrative example with invented numbers: a dispute covering two years at roughly $900 of tax per year produces a refund near $1,800 — not a fortune, but without a clause the cost of arguing over it dwarfs the money.

Common misunderstandings

"I paid the tax, so the refund is obviously mine." Not as far as the municipality is concerned. It refunds the owner on the roll on adjustment day and does not trace who paid in earlier years. Your claim, if any, is against the buyer under the APS.

"An undecided appeal means the house cannot be sold or closed." It can. An open dispute is not a legal bar to the transaction; it affects how money is divided, not whether title can transfer.

"The standard contract already covers this." It does not. Form 100's tax apportionment is a one-time calculation with no readjustment for a later appeal refund or extra tax — which is exactly why an added clause is needed.

Action checklist

  1. Before listing, map the dispute: RfR or ARB stage, file number, materials filed, next deadline — one page, in writing.
  2. Disclose the open dispute to the buyer's side honestly; the tax and assessment records will show it anyway.
  3. Add an APS clause covering all four points: refund allocation, extra-tax allocation, who carries the dispute forward, and document forwarding.
  4. At closing, have your lawyer verify the tax apportionment in the statement of adjustments and keep a copy of the dispute file for both sides.
  5. When the result arrives, follow the money the municipality actually paid, then settle between yourselves under the APS clause.

Trust Professional, Diligent Work. I am Ming Ren. A home with an open assessment dispute can still sell cleanly — as long as where the money goes is settled on signing day, not argued about a year later.


This article is general information only, not legal advice. The stage of the dispute, ARB deadlines and contract wording can change the conclusion; have your Ontario real estate lawyer review the clause before you sign.

Primary sources: Assessment Act, ss.39.1, 40; Municipal Act, 2001, ss.341, 349 (Ontario e-Laws, consulted November 2026). The $900-per-year tax figure is illustrative only, not a real case.

Frequently asked questions

I paid the tax, so is the MPAC appeal refund obviously mine?

Not as far as the municipality is concerned. It refunds the owner on the roll on adjustment day and does not trace who paid in earlier years; your claim, if any, is against the buyer under the APS.

Does an undecided MPAC appeal mean the house cannot be sold or closed?

No. An open dispute is not a legal bar to the transaction; it affects how money is divided, not whether title can transfer.

Does the standard contract already cover a later appeal refund or extra tax?

It does not. Form 100's tax apportionment is a one-time calculation with no readjustment for a later appeal refund or extra tax, which is exactly why an added clause is needed.

This article in other languages: 中文فارسی

Want to talk about your home?

You can also call directly, or scan the code to add Ming on WeChat.

Ming’s WeChat QR code
Scan to add on WeChat

Community guides by city

All cities →
☎ Call MingFree Evaluation