Ming RenBroker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage
☎ 647-779-9186

Mortgages & Finance

Think MPAC Valued Your Home Too High? Don't Compare It to Today's Market — Do This First

By , Broker, RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc. (About Ming) · Published

Ming Ren · Broker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage

← All articles · Mortgages & Finance · Category guide

I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.

The plain answer first: yes, you can challenge an Ontario property assessment, and the first step is free — a Request for Reconsideration (RfR) filed with MPAC. But most people start by comparing the wrong thing. Your assessment is not based on today's market. It is based on a legislated valuation date of January 1, 2016. So the question is not "is this number below what my home would sell for now?" It is "on that same 2016 basis, is my home assessed higher than comparable homes?" Compare correctly and you have a case. Compare against today's prices and no amount of paperwork will help.

First, understand how your tax bill is built

In broad terms, your municipal property tax is MPAC's assessed value multiplied by the municipal and education tax rates. You cannot appeal the tax rate. What you can challenge is the assessed value itself, and whether your property's classification is correct.

MPAC states that assessments for the 2026 tax year are still based on January 1, 2016 values — the province-wide reassessment has been postponed repeatedly and has not resumed. That is why the number on your notice sits far below today's market price. It does for every property in Ontario; it does not mean you are getting a bargain, and it does not mean you have no case. The comparison that matters is sideways: if similar homes on your street are assessed lower than yours on the same 2016 basis, you are paying tax on a higher number than your neighbours — and that is a proper ground to act on.

Two levels of challenge — and the first cannot be skipped

Level one: the RfR — free, and mandatory first for residential property. Under section 39.1 of Ontario's Assessment Act and MPAC's process, owners of residential, farm and managed-forest property must file an RfR with MPAC and receive MPAC's decision before they can appeal further. Filing online through AboutMyProperty is the most convenient route; MPAC's notice explains the options. MPAC generally responds in writing within 180 days, and may take up to 60 additional days if it notifies you within the initial period that it needs more time.

Level two: an appeal to the Assessment Review Board (ARB). If you disagree with the RfR outcome, you may appeal to the independent ARB within 90 days of the date MPAC issued the RfR result. An ARB appeal carries a filing fee — check the current fee schedule on Tribunals Ontario before you file, as amounts change.

The deadline discipline is the hard part. Your RfR deadline is printed on your Property Assessment Notice — for a regular tax year it is typically March 31 of that year, but the date on your own notice governs. Miss it, and the road beyond it is effectively closed. When a notice arrives, read the date before you read the number.

Building the evidence: check for errors first, then compare

Work in this order — the earlier items are the strongest:

  • Check your own property record for factual errors. Log in to AboutMyProperty and verify, item by item: building area, lot dimensions, room and bathroom counts, year built, whether a basement is recorded as finished. If MPAC's record does not match the actual property, that is the cleanest ground for a reduction there is.
  • Then compare assessed values of genuinely similar properties. AboutMyProperty lets you view assessed values of comparable homes nearby — same area, similar size, age and lot. If they are assessed noticeably lower than you, record those figures.
  • Use sales evidence from the right era. To support value, sales near the January 1, 2016 valuation date match the basis of the assessment. This year's sale prices measure a different market and muddy the comparison.
  • Document major defects with quotes and photos. A significant repair issue that existed at the valuation date can help explain why your home was not worth the assessed figure then.

Special notices run on a different clock

The March 31 date described above is the usual case for a regular tax year. If what you received is a supplementary or omitted assessment notice, the Assessment Act sets the RfR deadline at 120 days from the date that notice was issued — not the following March 31. The first year of a resumed province-wide reassessment uses a similar special calculation. Whatever arrives, the routine is the same: read the deadline printed on the notice first, and the assessed value second. Get the date wrong and even a perfect file cannot be submitted.

An RfR can also challenge classification, not only value. If your property's class is wrong, the basis of the tax calculation is wrong with it, and correcting the class is sometimes more direct than arguing the number. State the class you believe is correct, and your grounds, in the same filing.

Finally, manage expectations. A successful RfR corrects your assessed value or classification, and the municipality adjusts your tax bill accordingly. It does not reduce your tax to zero and it does not change the rate. Whether the effort is worthwhile depends on the size of the gap between your assessment and comparable properties: a clear gap backed by a factual error or comparable evidence is the strongest case; a marginal gap deserves a quick estimate of the dollars at stake before you carry it to the ARB.

Three misunderstandings I hear most often

"My assessment is way below market value, so there's no point." A below-market assessment is the product of the frozen 2016 basis — it is true for everyone. The point is the sideways comparison: if you are assessed high relative to comparable homes, you are overpaying relative to your neighbours, and that is worth an RfR.

"My tax bill is too high — I'll appeal the tax rate." The rate cannot be appealed. Only the assessed value and the classification can be challenged. Start in the wrong place and the process cannot take your complaint at all.

"I'll skip straight to the ARB and save a step." For residential property, you cannot. Without a completed RfR and an MPAC decision, there is no right of appeal to the ARB. The sequence is set by law.

If you plan to act this year, do these things in order

  1. Find your assessment notice and circle the RfR deadline printed on it. Plan backwards from that date.
  2. Log in to AboutMyProperty (your notice carries the roll number and access information) and verify your property details line by line. Save screenshots of anything that does not match.
  3. In the same system, find three to five genuinely comparable properties and build a small comparison table of their assessed values against yours.
  4. File the RfR before the deadline. State plainly whether your ground is a factual error or a comparable-property gap, and attach the evidence in one package — not a bare statement that the value "feels high."
  5. When MPAC's decision arrives, note the date it was issued. If you accept it, you are done. If not, mark the 90-day appeal window on your calendar before deciding on the ARB.

Trust Professional, Diligent Work. I am Ming Ren. With assessments, get the valuation date and the deadline right first, and we will go through the numbers item by item.


This article is general information only, not legal or tax advice. Your notice dates, property class and individual facts affect the process and the outcome. Rely on MPAC's and the ARB's current guidance, and consult an Ontario lawyer or assessment professional where needed.

Primary sources: MPAC official guidance (mpac.ca: January 1, 2016 valuation date for the 2026 tax year, RfR is free, deadline printed on the assessment notice, MPAC generally responds within 180 days with up to 60 more, ARB appeal within 90 days of the RfR result) and Ontario Assessment Act s.39.1, consulted November 2026. The ARB filing fee is deliberately not stated as a fixed figure here; check the current schedule at Tribunals Ontario.

This article in other languages: 中文فارسی

Want to talk about your home?

You can also call directly, or scan the code to add Ming on WeChat.

Ming’s WeChat QR code
Scan to add on WeChat

Community guides by city

All cities →
☎ Call MingFree Evaluation