I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
The plain conclusion first: the penalty is not a number your lender invents. It follows a formula. On a closed fixed-rate mortgage, it is generally the greater of two calculations — three months' interest, or the interest rate differential (IRD). On a closed variable-rate mortgage, it is usually just three months' interest. On an open mortgage, you can generally pay the loan off at any time without this charge. Selling, switching lenders, or refinancing into a lower rate before your term ends will usually trigger it on a closed mortgage.
1. Start by identifying which mortgage you actually have
Do not start with the math. Start with your contract, and confirm three things: open or closed, fixed or variable, and how many months are left in the term.
An open mortgage usually carries a higher rate, and in exchange you can repay it in full at any time. A closed mortgage costs less in rate, but ending it early means paying the prepayment charge written into the contract. One thing that is not "breaking" the mortgage: paying extra within the prepayment privileges your contract allows — an annual lump-sum percentage, or higher regular payments, for example. Extra payments inside those limits carry no charge. The limits differ by lender and product, so your own contract is the only reliable source.
2. Two calculations, and you pay the higher one
According to the Financial Consumer Agency of Canada (FCAC), the charge on a closed fixed-rate mortgage is generally set this way:
- Three months' interest: roughly three months of interest on your current balance at your current rate. Simple, and relatively predictable.
- Interest rate differential (IRD): your lender compares your contract rate with the rate it can now offer on a term close to the time you have left, and applies that gap to your balance over the remaining time. It is meant to capture the interest the lender loses because you are leaving early.
Both figures are calculated, and the higher one is charged. When rates have fallen, the IRD is often far larger than three months' interest — that is how a fixed-rate penalty reaches five figures. When rates have barely moved, or little time is left, three months' interest can be the larger figure instead.
An invented example, using my own numbers purely to show the arithmetic — not any lender's quote: suppose a $400,000 balance at a fixed 5.00%, with three years left in the term. Three months' interest is about $400,000 × 5.00% × 3 ÷ 12 = $5,000. Suppose the lender's comparison rate for the remaining term is 3.50%. The gap is 1.50%, so a rough IRD is $400,000 × 1.50% × 3 = $18,000. The greater of the two is about $18,000. Treat this as a simplified illustration only: lenders do not all choose the comparison rate the same way — some work from a posted rate less the discount you originally received, which can push the result higher. Your own estimate is a starting point; the binding figure is the payout statement from your lender.
A variable rate is simpler: on a closed variable mortgage the charge is usually three months' interest, with no IRD comparison. That is one reason some borrowers accept a floating rate — the cost of leaving is far lower.
3. Whether breaking pays comes down to one comparison
A large penalty does not automatically mean breaking is wrong, and a small one does not mean breaking is smart. Compare two totals: the interest the new mortgage would actually save you over the time you will really hold it, against the full cost of breaking — the penalty, any administration fees, and the setup costs of the new loan.
Be honest about the holding period. If you expect to sell and move in two years, the saving only runs for two years, and the arithmetic changes completely. And if your term matures in a few months anyway, waiting for maturity — when no penalty applies — is often cheaper than breaking today. Check the maturity date before you fall in love with a new rate; many people do this in the wrong order.
Misunderstandings I hear most often
"The penalty is just three months' interest." That is the usual case for a variable rate. A fixed rate must also be compared against the IRD, and the further rates have fallen and the longer the time left, the bigger the IRD.
"An online calculator told me the amount, so that is what the bank will charge." A calculator can only estimate. Lenders use different comparison rates in the IRD, so the same mortgage can carry a very different penalty at different lenders.
"I am selling the house — charging me a penalty is unfair." If the mortgage cannot be ported to your next home and the term has not ended, paying it off in full triggers the charge under the contract you signed. Ask about porting when you take the mortgage, not when you list.
If you are thinking of breaking your mortgage, do these things in order
- Pull out your mortgage contract and confirm open/closed, fixed/variable, the maturity date, and your annual prepayment privileges.
- Call your lender and ask for both figures — the three months' interest amount and the IRD amount — plus a written payout statement.
- Ask whether the mortgage can be ported to your next property; if it can, the penalty question may disappear.
- Work out the interest the new mortgage would save over the years you realistically expect to hold it, and set it against the penalty plus fees.
- If maturity is only a few months away, price the "wait and renew" option too before you decide.
Trust Professional, Diligent Work. I am Ming Ren. Before breaking a mortgage, get the lender's numbers in writing and we will go through them line by line — no guessing.
This article is general information only, not financial or mortgage advice. Penalty methods vary by lender and contract; your mortgage contract and your lender's payout statement govern. Consult a licensed mortgage professional before deciding.
Primary source: Financial Consumer Agency of Canada (FCAC), Canada.ca guidance on prepayment charges and breaking a mortgage contract (consulted November 2026). The $400,000 balance and the 5.00% and 3.50% rates are illustrative only, not real quotes.


