Ming RenBroker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage
☎ 647-779-9186

Commercial Real Estate & Leasing

Paying Off a Commercial Mortgage Early in Ontario: Why Yield Maintenance and Defeasance Are Not Just a Bigger IRD

By , Broker, RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc. (About Ming) · Published

Ming Ren · Broker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage

← All articles · Commercial Real Estate & Leasing · Category guide

I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.

The plain conclusion first: the guardrail that protects a homeowner who prepays does not, in substance, protect a commercial borrower. Section 10 of the federal Interest Act does say that on a mortgage with a term over five years, after five years the borrower can prepay with no more than three months' further interest in lieu of notice. But subsection 10(2) expressly carves out mortgages given by a joint stock company or any other corporation — and commercial property is usually held in a corporation. So from day one, the penalty is not capped by statute. It is whatever your loan contract says, and the two mechanisms contracts most often use are yield maintenance and defeasance.

Three things follow: why the guardrail stops at the commercial door, what each mechanism is actually calculating, and what to ask before you sign.

1. Where the residential guardrail ends

Section 10(1) of the Interest Act protects individual borrowers: where principal is not payable until more than five years after the mortgage date, once five years have passed the borrower may pay the amount due plus three months' further interest in lieu of notice, and no further interest is chargeable. Subsection 10(2) then draws the exception: it does not apply to a mortgage given by a joint stock company or any other corporation. The policy assumption is that commercial parties can negotiate their own terms, so Parliament does not cap them.

In practice, the same owner can have a predictable ceiling on the mortgage on their home and no ceiling at all on a plaza, an industrial unit or an apartment building held in their company. A lockout period with no prepayment at all, a formula penalty after the lockout, and an open window near maturity are all negotiated terms, not statutory rights. The first step in assessing any commercial loan is therefore not "how many months' interest is the penalty?" — it is reading the prepayment clause itself.

Item Individual residential mortgage Corporate commercial mortgage
Interest Act s.10 three-month cap Applies after year five on terms over five years Expressly excluded by s.10(2)
What sets the penalty Statutory ceiling alongside the contract The loan contract alone
Common mechanisms Three months' interest or an IRD-type charge Yield maintenance or defeasance
Right to prepay Statutory route after five years Depends on lockout and open-window wording

2. Yield maintenance: making the lender's yield whole

Yield maintenance starts from a simple idea. The lender priced the loan expecting a defined stream of payments over the full term. Prepayment takes that stream away, and the returned principal can only be reinvested at the lower, risk-free rates then available. The borrower makes up the shortfall.

The mechanics are present-value mechanics. The remaining scheduled payments are listed out, each is discounted back to today at a benchmark rate tied to the Government of Canada bond yield for the matching remaining term, and the penalty is broadly the amount needed to leave the lender whole on that present-value basis. The exact formula — including how the benchmark and any spread are written — varies from contract to contract. Your own document governs; there is no single market formula to quote here.

One counterintuitive point must be understood early: the further rates fall, the larger this penalty tends to grow. A lower reinvestment yield means a bigger shortfall to make up. Owners who rush to refinance into a lower rate often discover that the same rate drop has been quietly inflating their exit cost. The interest saved and the penalty owed belong on the same page of arithmetic.

3. Defeasance: the loan is not repaid — its collateral is replaced

Defeasance is the more misunderstood mechanism, because it is not a repayment at all. The loan stays in place and its payment schedule continues. What changes is the collateral: the borrower buys a portfolio of high-grade securities — Government of Canada bonds are the standard example — matched in amount and timing to the remaining loan payments, and that portfolio is held to service the loan. The real property is then released from the mortgage, so the owner can sell or refinance it.

Why use such a roundabout structure? The typical case is a property that needs to be sold, or newly financed, while the existing loan cannot — or should not — be prepaid. The securities portfolio holds the old loan up while the property steps out. The cost is not a single penalty figure: it includes the actual cost of buying the securities, trustee and legal costs, and a full document process. And not every contract permits it. Whether defeasance is available, which securities qualify, and who must consent all come from the loan wording and the lender.

Put side by side, the two mechanisms share one idea — the lender is kept economically whole — and differ in everything else. One pays a present-value amount and discharges the loan. The other leaves the loan running, swaps its collateral for securities, and releases the land.

Three common misunderstandings

"A commercial penalty is just a residential IRD, only bigger." It is not the same rulebook. The statutory ceiling does not apply to a corporate borrower, and the commercial figure comes from a contractual present-value formula, with a different logic and potentially a different scale.

"Rates dropped, so breaking the loan must be worth it." Only half of that is true. The new loan may be cheaper, but a yield maintenance penalty grows precisely when rates fall. Both sides have to be calculated together — never judge by the new rate alone.

"Defeasance is just prepayment under another name." No. Nothing is repaid. The collateral is replaced by a securities portfolio and the property is released. The process, the cost components and the consents required are all different from an outright payout.

If you are thinking of selling or refinancing, do these five things in order

  1. Pull the actual prepayment clause from your loan documents: is there a lockout, which mechanism applies, and is there an open window before maturity? Confirm it line by line, not from memory.
  2. Ask the lender for a formal, dated prepayment calculation. Benchmark yields move daily, so an old estimate is not a number you can rely on.
  3. Put exit cost and benefit on one page: interest saved by refinancing, or the timing value of a sale, against the full cost of the penalty or of defeasance, including legal and trustee fees.
  4. If defeasance is on the table, confirm first that the contract allows it and the lender consents, and have your lawyer map the security-substitution and release documents.
  5. If you have not signed the loan yet, negotiate the prepayment terms as core business terms — lockout length, mechanism and open window will affect your flexibility years later more than a small difference in rate.

Trust Professional, Diligent Work. I am Ming Ren. Before you sell or refinance, bring the loan contract and a current payout calculation, and we will work through the exit cost, number by number.


This article is general information only, not legal or financial advice. Your lockout, formula and open window are governed by your loan contract. Consult an Ontario lawyer and a licensed mortgage professional before acting.

Primary source: Interest Act, R.S.C. 1985, c. I-15, s.10(1) and (2) (Justice Laws, consulted November 2026). The precise yield maintenance formula and whether defeasance is available depend on each loan contract; no market rates or penalty statistics are relied on here.

This article in other languages: 中文فارسی

Want to talk about your home?

You can also call directly, or scan the code to add Ming on WeChat.

Ming’s WeChat QR code
Scan to add on WeChat

Community guides by city

All cities →
☎ Call MingFree Evaluation