Ming RenBroker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage
☎ 647-779-9186

Buying a Home

A Deal Fails to Close in Ontario: What Buyer and Seller Default Really Cost

By , Broker, RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc. (About Ming) · Published

Ming Ren · Broker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage

← All articles · Buying a Home · Category guide

I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.

Here is the plain conclusion first: once an agreement is firm — all conditions removed — failing to close on the completion date is a breach of contract, and the bill for that breach is almost never just the deposit. A defaulting buyer can face the resale shortfall plus carrying costs on top of the deposit. A defaulting seller can face a damages claim, and in the right case an order forcing the sale. Three things decide how it plays out.

1. Buyer default: the deposit is only the first layer

First, separate the stages. Walking away during a condition period, using the contract's own terms, is exercising a right — it is not a breach. Default begins when the deal is firm and the buyer cannot or will not close.

When a buyer defaults, the deposit is generally forfeited. In Azzarello v. Shawqi, 2019 ONCA 820, the Ontario Court of Appeal explained why: a deposit stands as security for the buyer's performance, and a seller may keep it even without proving actual loss, because its prospect of forfeiture is what gives the buyer an incentive to complete. Relief from forfeiture exists, but the test is demanding — the amount must be out of all proportion to the seller's damages, and it must be unconscionable for the seller to retain it. Do not treat it as a planned exit.

The real exposure sits beyond the deposit. A seller who relists and resells for less can sue the defaulting buyer for the difference between the contract price and the resale price, plus carrying costs in the meantime. Look at the numbers in Azzarello itself: the damages award was $308,688.31, of which $275,000 was the price difference alone, with the balance in consequential carrying costs. The buyer's $75,000 deposit was only one slice of that bill.

2. The deposit is never paid out automatically — and it must be credited, not collected twice

Two details are widely misunderstood.

First, the deposit is not sitting in the seller's pocket. It is held by the Deposit Holder named in the agreement — usually the listing brokerage — in a trust account under section 27 of the Trust in Real Estate Services Act, 2002 (TRESA), and it can be disbursed only in accordance with the terms of that trust. When a deal collapses, the brokerage must stay neutral: the money moves only on a mutual release signed by both buyer and seller, or on a court order. If the buyer refuses to sign, the deposit stays frozen in trust while a court decides; if entitlement is still unresolved after two years, the funds are paid over to RECO. So no, the seller does not receive the deposit on the day of default.

Second, there is no double recovery. At trial in Azzarello, the judge awarded the $308,688.31 in damages and also let the sellers keep the full $75,000 deposit without crediting it. The Court of Appeal corrected that: the standard agreement says only that the deposit is credited toward the purchase price on completion, so the parties must have intended it to count toward the buyer's payment obligation either way. The buyer therefore owed $308,688.31 minus the $75,000 deposit — $233,688.31. A seller cannot collect the same loss twice.

The seller also carries a duty to mitigate: relist promptly and sell reasonably, rather than letting the shortfall grow. But Azzarello drew a line — mitigation does not require a seller to accept the defaulting buyer's own discounted offer and then sue for the difference.

3. Seller default: two remedies, and a clock on both

Seller default typically means refusing to transfer on closing day, changing their mind, or being unable to deliver the title the contract requires. The buyer generally has two routes:

  • End the contract and claim damages: the deposit back, plus proven losses — for example, the extra cost of buying a comparable substitute property and reasonable expenses already incurred.
  • Specific performance: ask the court to order the seller to complete the sale on the original terms. But under Semelhago v. Paramadevan, [1996] 2 S.C.R. 415, the Supreme Court of Canada held that specific performance is no longer granted as a matter of course for land. The buyer must show evidence that the property is unique to the extent that a substitute is not readily available and damages would not do justice. An ordinary investment property will usually end in money, not the house.

Then there is the clock. Under sections 4 and 5 of Ontario's Limitations Act, 2002, the basic limitation period for a contract claim is two years from the day the claim was discovered or ought to have been discovered. In a failed closing, evidence and timelines decide cases — let the window close and even a strong claim is gone.

One more point buyers miss: when the seller defaults, decide quickly which route you want. If you want the house, act before the property is resold to a good-faith third party, and have your lawyer assess whether a caution should be registered to protect your claim. If you want compensation, keep every receipt — inspection fees, legal costs, temporary accommodation and rescheduling expenses are all material for calculating your loss. Wait a few months and both routes get narrower.

Three common misunderstandings

"Worst case, I lose my deposit and walk away." The deposit is the first layer only. The resale shortfall and carrying costs can be claimed on top of it — in Azzarello the total award was more than four times the deposit.

"If I default, the seller gets my deposit that same day." The deposit sits in a trust account. The brokerage can release it only on a mutual release signed by both sides or a court order; a disputed deposit can stay frozen for a long time.

"If the seller won't sell, the court will just give me the house." Not automatically. Since Semelhago, specific performance requires proof of uniqueness and proof that damages are inadequate. Without that proof, the court awards money instead.

If closing day is close and the deal looks like it will fail, do these in order

  1. Confirm the contract's status first: have all conditions actually been fulfilled or waived? Exiting properly inside a condition period and defaulting on a firm deal are entirely different situations.
  2. Do not negotiate "how much to settle" with the other side yourself. Route anything about the deposit or a settlement through your real estate lawyer — a verbal understanding protects no one.
  3. If you are the seller: relist promptly and keep everything — listing records, offers, and carrying-cost receipts. They are your evidence of both the shortfall and your mitigation.
  4. If you are the buyer: preserve the paper trail behind the funding failure (lender correspondence, approval documents) and ask a lawyer immediately whether relief from forfeiture is even arguable at your numbers.
  5. Watch the two-year limitation period. Have your lawyer calculate the key dates as soon as the default happens — do not let open-ended negotiation talk the window away.

Trust Professional, Diligent Work. I am Ming Ren. If a closing on either side of a deal feels shaky, bring the agreement and the timeline and we will go through the paperwork item by item — and where a default or a lawsuit is in play, I will get you in front of a real estate litigation lawyer first, not last.


This article is general information only, not legal advice. The contract wording, the history of the default, and the proportions of the amounts all affect the outcome. Consult an Ontario lawyer before acting.

Primary sources: Azzarello v. Shawqi, 2019 ONCA 820 (CanLII); Semelhago v. Paramadevan, [1996] 2 S.C.R. 415; Trust in Real Estate Services Act, 2002, s.27 and Limitations Act, 2002, ss.4-5 (Ontario e-Laws, consulted November 2026).

Frequently asked questions

Worst case, do I just lose my deposit and walk away?

The deposit is the first layer only. The resale shortfall and carrying costs can be claimed on top of it — in Azzarello the total award was more than four times the deposit.

If I default, does the seller get my deposit that same day?

The deposit sits in a trust account. The brokerage can release it only on a mutual release signed by both sides or a court order; a disputed deposit can stay frozen for a long time.

If the seller won't sell, will the court just give me the house?

Not automatically. Since Semelhago, specific performance requires proof of uniqueness and proof that damages are inadequate. Without that proof, the court awards money instead.

This article in other languages: 中文فارسی

Want to talk about your home?

You can also call directly, or scan the code to add Ming on WeChat.

Ming’s WeChat QR code
Scan to add on WeChat

Community guides by city

All cities →
☎ Call MingFree Evaluation