I'm Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
Here is the conclusion up front, so there is no guessing: once an offer is firm — all conditions waived, or unconditional from the start — a buyer who fails to close will, in practice, lose the deposit. And the deposit is usually only the first bill. If the seller resells for less, the price gap plus the seller's extra costs, minus the deposit already forfeited, can still be claimed from the buyer. What decides the final number is not how reasonable your excuse sounds. It is how far the resale price lands below your contract price.
Three things, in order.
First: Were You Still Inside the Condition Period, or Already Firm?
Where this line falls changes everything.
If your offer still carries conditions — financing, home inspection — and the condition period has not expired, and you let the conditions lapse properly within the deadline instead of waiving them, the deal simply ends and the deposit comes back under the contract. That is not a default. It is an exit the contract gave you on purpose.
But once you sign the waiver, or your offer never had conditions, the deal is locked. Ontario's standard Agreement of Purchase and Sale (OREA Form 100) makes time of the essence. Arriving at closing day without the money to complete is a breach by the buyer. Losing a job, being turned down for a mortgage, failing to sell your own home first — these are the buyer's hardships, not exits the contract recognizes.
Second: Why the Deposit Is, in Practice, Gone
The deposit you paid on signing is, under Form 100, delivered to the listing brokerage and held in a trust account. It does not go straight into the seller's pocket — and because it is trust money, the rules around it are strict:
| Question | How it actually works |
|---|---|
| Who gets the deposit after a buyer's default? | Under common-law principles, a deposit is security for the buyer's performance. If the buyer defaults, the seller is entitled to forfeit it without first having to prove an actual loss. |
| Can the buyer block the release by refusing to sign? | The money cannot be released on one side's say-so. Trust deposits are paid out on joint written direction from both parties or by court order; the brokerage cannot decide who gets it. |
| Can a court order the deposit returned to the buyer? | There is a narrow opening: section 98 of the Courts of Justice Act gives the court discretion to grant relief from forfeiture. The bar is high — the buyer must show the forfeiture would be unconscionable and the seller suffered no real loss. Ordinary buyers rarely clear it. |
So in real life, a defaulting buyer's first certain loss is the full deposit. How and when that money actually moves often waits on a settlement or a court result, which is one reason these disputes drag on.
Third: The Seller Can Often Claim More Than the Deposit
When a seller accepts the default, takes the property back and resells it, the law aims to put the seller in the position he would have been in had the contract been completed. The arithmetic runs in four steps: contract price minus resale price gives the shortfall; add the extra carrying and selling costs of the second sale — interest, property tax, insurance, a second round of commission and legal fees; then subtract the deposit already forfeited. The deposit is a credit, not a second penalty.
Here is the arithmetic with numbers I made up for illustration only — this is not a real transaction:
| Item | Illustrative figures |
|---|---|
| Original contract price | $900,000 |
| Deposit paid on signing | $45,000 |
| Seller's resale price | $820,000 |
| Price shortfall | $80,000 |
| Extra costs of reselling | $12,000 |
| Less: forfeited deposit credited | −$45,000 |
| Owed by the buyer beyond the deposit | $47,000 |
In this example the buyer's total loss is the $45,000 deposit plus $47,000 in additional damages — $92,000 altogether. The harder the market falls and the longer the property sits, the bigger that number gets. Run it the other way: if the seller resells at close to the original price, or above it, the additional claim can shrink toward zero and the deposit is most of the story.
One rule does work in the buyer's favour: the seller has a duty to mitigate. He must take reasonable steps to resell promptly at a reasonable price; he cannot sit on the property, or list it at a fantasy price, and let the loss grow at your expense. The portion of the loss caused by a genuine failure to mitigate can be disallowed. But the buyer who alleges it carries the burden of proof, and in practice that is not an easy argument to win.
Three Misunderstandings I Hear All the Time
"Worst case, I lose the deposit and walk away." The deposit is the starting point, not the ceiling. The resale shortfall and costs beyond it can be sued for, and a judgment is a real, enforceable debt.
"The bank turned down my mortgage — that's not my fault, so I should be released." If you signed an unconditional offer, financing is your problem to solve. A refusal does not excuse performance. That is exactly what the condition period is worth: while conditions are alive, the exit is open.
"If I refuse to sign the deposit release, the whole thing stalls out." All that stalls is the release of that one pot of trust money. The seller can apply to court over the deposit and sue for the shortfall at the same time — and the longer it runs, the less clear it is who ends up carrying the interest and legal costs.
If You Genuinely Cannot Close, Do These in Order
- Do not go silent, and do not wait until closing day to speak up. Tell your agent and your lawyer immediately — many of these situations are negotiated, and negotiation needs time.
- Have an Ontario real estate lawyer cost out the three numbers: the deposit, the likely resale shortfall at today's market, and your overall exposure. Know your position before anyone comes asking.
- Through your lawyer, test three routes: an extension of closing (usually in exchange for more money and a larger deposit), assigning the contract to another buyer (depends on the contract terms and the seller's consent), or a mutual release that settles everything for a fixed sum. A known number, even a painful one, beats open-ended litigation.
- Pull together whatever funds you honestly can — bridge financing, family loans, other assets. Closing cures everything: if the contract is completed, none of the other bills exist.
- Keep every communication in writing. While the seller resells, note whether his pricing and marketing look reasonable — that record matters if mitigation is ever argued. Do this under your lawyer's direction only; never interfere with the seller's sale yourself.
Honest work, done properly, is the whole foundation. I'm Ming Ren. Thinking through your conditions and your money before you sign is far cheaper than repairing things afterwards. If you are unsure about an offer, bring me the contract and we will go through it clause by clause.
This article is general information, not legal advice. How a deposit is handled and what damages amount to depend on the contract wording and the facts of each case. Consult an Ontario lawyer before acting.
Primary sources: OREA Form 100, Agreement of Purchase and Sale, deposit and closing provisions; Courts of Justice Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. C.43, s.98 (relief from forfeiture); Ontario common-law principles on damages for breach of contract and the duty to mitigate. The figures $900,000, $45,000, $820,000, $12,000 and $47,000 are illustrative only, not a real transaction.
Frequently asked questions
If I walk away from a firm deal, do I just lose the deposit?
The deposit is the starting point, not the ceiling. The resale shortfall and costs beyond it can be sued for, and a judgment is a real, enforceable debt.
The bank turned down my mortgage — surely I can be released?
If you signed an unconditional offer, financing is your problem to solve. A refusal does not excuse performance. While conditions are alive, the exit is open — that is exactly what the condition period is worth.
If I refuse to sign the deposit release, does the whole thing stall?
All that stalls is the release of that one pot of trust money. The seller can apply to court over the deposit and sue for the shortfall at the same time, and the longer it runs, the less clear it is who carries the interest and legal costs.


