I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
Here is the conclusion first: the agreement is signed, the conditions are waived, but closing day has not arrived — and in that gap the house is damaged by fire or water. Do not assume it is simply your bad luck. If you signed on Ontario's standard Agreement of Purchase and Sale (OREA Form 100), the Insurance clause is clear: until the transaction is completed, the property is at the seller's risk, and the seller must hold the insurance policies and proceeds in trust for both parties. If the damage is substantial, the choice belongs to the buyer — terminate the agreement and get back all the money you paid, or complete the purchase and take the insurance proceeds. Let me walk through that main line.
What the Insurance clause actually says
The Insurance clause of the standard form comes down to three points, in plain language.
First, the risk before closing sits with the seller. The clause provides that the buildings on the property, and the other things being purchased with it, remain at the risk of the seller until completion. So for damage that happens between acceptance and closing, the first responsibility is the seller's, not the buyer's. Fire is the classic case; the clause is about damage to the buildings themselves and is not limited to fire.
Second, the insurance proceeds are held in trust. The seller must hold all insurance policies and the proceeds of any claim in trust for the buyer and the seller, as their interests may appear. In plain terms, the insurer's payout is not money the seller simply pockets — it is tied to this transaction.
Third, if the damage is substantial, the buyer elects. Where the buildings or the other things being purchased are substantially damaged, the buyer may choose either: (a) to terminate the agreement and have all monies paid returned, without interest or deduction; or (b) to complete the transaction and receive all of the insurance proceeds. Both options come straight from the contract — the buyer does not need the seller's permission to walk away in that situation.
An illustrative example, with numbers I made up: purchase price $1,000,000 (illustrative); before closing, a fire damages the kitchen and roof, with an estimated repair cost of $180,000 (illustrative). If that damage is properly characterized as substantial, the buyer can terminate and recover the deposit, or close as agreed and take the proceeds payable under the seller's insurance for that damage and arrange the repairs. Which road is better depends on whether the proceeds will cover the repair and whether the house is still worth owning — a judgment to make together with your lawyer.
If you elect to complete, how do the proceeds actually reach you?
Many buyers assume the insurer will simply write them a cheque. That is not how it works. The seller is the insured under the policy, so the claim is the seller's to make. The contract's job is to require the seller to hold the proceeds in trust and to deliver the benefit of that money to the buyer when the transaction completes. Exactly how — a credit on closing, an assignment of the claim, or funds held back until the claim is settled — is for the two lawyers to spell out in the closing documents. If the claim is still unresolved at closing, the parties especially need to settle in writing: who gets the proceeds when they are eventually paid, what assignment documents the seller will sign, and who bears any shortfall if the payout is less than the repair bill. Leave it unwritten, and chasing it after closing puts you on the back foot.
A buyer who elects to terminate has homework too. Termination means the agreement ends and the monies paid are returned under the clause, without interest or deduction. The refund flows through the lawyers and the brokerage in the ordinary way, so allow it a reasonable time — and remember to notify your lender and your insurance broker so the arrangements you made for this purchase are cancelled and you are not billed for a policy you no longer need.
Who decides what is "substantial" — and what if the damage is not?
This is where disputes live. The clause uses the word "substantial" but sets no percentage and no dollar threshold. Whether damage qualifies depends on the facts — whether the structure is affected, whether the home can still be lived in, and the scale of the repair — assessed by the two lawyers on the evidence, and if they cannot agree, it can end up in a dispute process or in court. So my advice to buyers is firm: do not declare on your own that "this is obviously substantial," and do not accept the seller's "it's minor" at face value either. Put the assessment in your lawyer's hands right away, and bring in an independent professional to document the damage if needed.
If the damage does not reach the substantial level, the buyer generally cannot walk away on the strength of the Insurance clause alone — the deal is still to be completed. Who does the repair, who pays, and whether closing arrangements change are matters the contract does not decide for the parties; the lawyers negotiate them, and whatever is agreed must be put in writing. A verbal "don't worry, I'll fix it before closing" is not something to rely on.
Sellers should hear this too: if the property is damaged before closing, notify the buyer through your lawyer promptly. Do not quietly repair it and say nothing. The risk allocation and the buyer's election are right there in the contract, and concealing damage only turns a manageable situation into a future dispute. What the seller should be doing in the meantime is clear: protect the property, report the loss to their insurer promptly, cooperate with the assessment, and keep their insurance in force. If a seller lets the policy lapse before closing, or a loss goes unpaid because coverage was allowed to fail, the problem is no longer "which option does the buyer pick" — it becomes the seller's own liability for breach, which is a different and much worse conversation.
Your own insurance: do not leave it to closing day
The Insurance clause protects the position on the seller's proceeds; it does not mean the buyer has nothing to arrange. A buyer's own home insurance normally takes effect on closing, and lenders generally require coverage to be in place at closing. So once your deal is firm, tell your insurance broker about the purchase and confirm the timing lines up — do not discover the day before closing that no policy has been arranged and the lender cannot fund. A buyer does not control the property before closing, so the useful preparation is on your own side: insurance and financing confirmed and connected. And if damage does occur, notify your lawyer immediately; your lawyer will press the seller's lawyer for the policy, the status of the claim, and the expected proceeds — the very information the terminate-or-complete decision depends on.
Common misunderstandings
Misunderstanding 1: "The house hasn't closed, so if it burns, that's the buyer's bad luck." It is the opposite. The standard form puts the pre-closing risk on the seller, and the proceeds are held in trust for both parties. The buyer is not the unprotected side of this deal.
Misunderstanding 2: "Any damage at all lets me cancel and get my deposit back." No. The right to terminate arises only where the damage is substantial. Minor damage generally means the purchase still completes, with repairs and costs sorted out by negotiation.
Misunderstanding 3: "If I elect to complete, the seller has to repair the house first." The clause gives the buyer the insurance proceeds plus completion — not a seller obligation to restore the property to its prior condition. Repair arrangements and any change to the closing date have to be separately agreed in writing; they do not happen automatically.
If it happens to you, work through this checklist
- Contact your own lawyer immediately, explain when and how the damage happened and what you know, and let all further communication run through the lawyers.
- Do not negotiate with the seller yourself and do not sign anything; every notice and every election must be given in writing through your lawyer.
- Have your lawyer request from the seller's lawyer: the seller's insurance policy, the status of the claim and its assessment, and the expected amount of the proceeds — this is the basis for your decision.
- Have your lawyer assess whether the damage is substantial; if needed, arrange for an independent professional to inspect and document the damage, and keep photographs and reports.
- Make your election within the time your lawyer advises: terminate and recover all monies paid, or complete and take the insurance proceeds — and deliver that election by written notice.
- If you elect to complete, get the repair arrangements, how the proceeds will be handled, and any change to the closing date written into signed documents.
- Notify your own insurance broker and your lender, and confirm that your policy arrangements and financing are not thrown off by what happened.
Honest in conduct, diligent in work. I am Ming Ren, Broker, RE/MAX Realtron — damage before closing is frightening, but the contract has already mapped the road: get your lawyer involved, follow the clause, and put every step in writing.
This article is general information, not legal advice. The extent of the damage, any special clauses in your agreement, and the timing of notices can all change the outcome; consult an Ontario real estate lawyer before acting.
Primary source: the Insurance clause of the standard Ontario Agreement of Purchase and Sale, OREA Form 100 — buildings and other things being purchased remain at the seller's risk until completion; policies and proceeds are held in trust for the parties as their interests may appear; on substantial damage the buyer may terminate and recover all monies paid without interest or deduction, or take the proceeds and complete. The $1,000,000 price and $180,000 repair figure are illustrative numbers, not a real transaction.
Frequently asked questions
The house hasn't closed yet, so if it burns is that the buyer's bad luck?
It is the opposite. The standard form puts the pre-closing risk on the seller, and the insurance proceeds are held in trust for both parties, so the buyer is not the unprotected side of the deal.
Does any damage at all let me cancel and get my deposit back?
No. The right to terminate arises only where the damage is substantial; minor damage generally means the purchase still completes, with repairs and costs sorted out by negotiation.
If I elect to complete, does the seller have to repair the house first?
No. The clause gives the buyer the insurance proceeds plus completion, not a seller obligation to restore the property to its prior condition; repair arrangements and any change to the closing date have to be separately agreed in writing.


