I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
The plain answer first: no Ontario law says anything about buyer letters as such, and receiving or reading one breaks no rule. The risk sits one step later — in the reason you actually choose one offer over another. If your deciding reason can be stated entirely in contract terms — price, deposit, conditions, closing date — you are on solid ground. If what truly tipped the decision was something a letter revealed about family status, creed, or place of origin, you have stepped onto ground the Ontario Human Rights Code covers.
1. The Code governs contracting on equal terms — not letters
The provision that speaks most directly to a private home sale is section 3 of the Human Rights Code: every person having legal capacity has a right to contract on equal terms without discrimination because of race, ancestry, place of origin, colour, ethnic origin, citizenship, creed, sex, sexual orientation, gender identity, gender expression, age, marital status, family status or disability.
Read the list carefully: "receipt of public assistance" is not in section 3. That ground appears in the section 2 list for occupancy of accommodation — a different provision for a different situation. In this area, citing the right section is basic workmanship.
As a registrant, I carry an additional layer: section 6 of the Code of Ethics under the Trust in Real Estate Services Act, 2002 (O. Reg. 365/22) requires a registrant, in carrying on business, not to treat any person in a manner that would contravene the Human Rights Code. So when a seller voices a selection criterion at the table that touches a protected ground, the agent cannot pretend not to have heard it — which is why a careful listing agent keeps pulling the conversation back to the terms of the offers.
2. The same decision, two kinds of reasons
Sort the usual deciding reasons into two columns and the line draws itself:
| Reasons that live in the contract terms | Reasons carried in from a letter |
|---|---|
| Highest price, largest deposit | "A young couple starting out — let's help them" — points to age and marital status |
| No financing or inspection condition; fewer moving parts | "The kids have already picked their rooms" — points to family status |
| Closing date lines up with your next purchase | "They attend our church" — points to creed |
| Signs quickly, paperwork complete | "They come from back home, like us" — points to place of origin and ethnic origin |
Every reason in the left column fits into an offer-comparison chart and can be repeated out loud without embarrassment. Every reason in the right column maps onto the section 3 list. Even where prices are close, if a right-column reason casts the deciding vote, that is where the problem begins.
3. "I never said it out loud" is not a defence
Three more sections of the Code close off the workarounds:
- Section 9: No person shall infringe a Part I right, or do anything directly or indirectly that infringes it. A reason that is never written down is still the reason.
- Section 11: A requirement or factor that is neutral on its face can still infringe the Code if its effect is to exclude, restrict, or prefer a group identified by a prohibited ground — unless it is reasonable and bona fide in the circumstances, or the Code provides an exception. A "neutral" screening habit that in practice filters out a protected group can land here.
- Section 12: Discrimination because of a person's relationship or association with someone identified by a prohibited ground is also an infringement. If the letter mentions a spouse, parent, or child, and that person's characteristic drives your choice, this section may be engaged.
Whether a complaint succeeds is for the Human Rights Tribunal of Ontario or a court to decide on the facts — not something I can pronounce on here. What a seller controls is simpler: keep the decision's reasons in contract language from start to finish.
Three common misunderstandings
"The buyer volunteered the letter, so using it is fair game." A voluntarily written letter does not license you to decide on protected characteristics it reveals. What is examined is your reason, not the letter's origin.
"I live in the home myself, so I may pick who lives here next." The Code does contain an owner-occupier exception (s.21(1)) about accommodation where occupants share a kitchen or bathroom with the owner — but it speaks to the section 2 occupancy right. A sale is a contract, governed by section 3, and that exception does not reach it.
"If I give no reason, no one can ever know." Section 9 covers indirect infringement, and if a complaint is filed, the comparison process, the brokerage's records, and what was said on offer night can all be examined. The real protection is a decision that withstands examination — not silence about it.
If you are choosing among offers tonight, do these in order
- Have your agent chart every offer on the same terms — price, deposit, conditions, closing date, certainty — and rank them from that chart alone.
- Before reading any letter, write down your ranking and your reasons in contract language. That page is your record of why you decided.
- If your ranking changes after reading a letter, stop and ask: which term changed? If you cannot name one, return to the earlier ranking.
- Do not ask buyers for letters, and do not signal in listing materials or conversations that you want to know about buyers' families, faith, or background.
- In replies to unsuccessful buyers, speak only about the terms outcome — never about the people.
Honest work, done properly. I am Ming Ren — on offer night, the steadiest practice is to compare offers as contracts, not buyers as households.
This article is general information, not legal advice. Whether discrimination occurred in a given case is decided by the Human Rights Tribunal of Ontario or a court on its facts; consult an Ontario lawyer if you are in doubt.
Primary sources: Human Rights Code, R.S.O. 1990, c. H.19, ss.3, 9, 11, 12, 21(1) (Ontario e-Laws) and O. Reg. 365/22, Code of Ethics, s.6, reviewed November 2026.
Frequently asked questions
The buyer volunteered the letter, so is using it fair game?
No. A voluntarily written letter does not license a seller to decide on protected characteristics it reveals; what is examined is the reason for the decision, not the letter's origin.
I live in the home myself, so may I pick who lives here next?
The owner-occupier exception in s.21(1) concerns accommodation sharing a kitchen or bathroom and speaks to the section 2 occupancy right; a sale is a contract governed by section 3, and that exception does not reach it.
If I give no reason, can anyone ever know?
Section 9 covers indirect infringement, and if a complaint is filed the comparison process, brokerage records and what was said on offer night can all be examined; the real protection is a decision that withstands examination.


