Ming RenBroker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage
☎ 647-779-9186

Buying a Home

Why Don't You Buy a Lot and Rebuild It Yourself? Answer Five Questions First

By , Broker, RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc. (About Ming) · Published

Ming Ren · Broker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage

← All articles · Buying a Home · Category guide

I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.

Clients ask me this from time to time: you understand rebuilds so well, why don't you buy a lot and rebuild one yourself? My answer is plain. A rebuild is not a bad idea — but whether it works out depends on a handful of questions you answer before you buy the land, not after. Most people price the lot and the construction and stop there. They leave out planning, permits, tax, and financing — and those four are exactly where rebuilds go sideways.

Here is the conclusion up front: when you buy an existing home, you are buying a house that already legally exists. When you buy land to rebuild, you are buying a chain of approvals that each have to come through. Those are not the same risk.

Gate one: what does this lot actually let you build?

Municipal zoning by-laws in Ontario are passed under section 34 of the Planning Act, and they govern the things you care about most: what land and buildings can be used for, where a building can sit on the lot, lot coverage, height, setbacks, floor area, and parking standards. In other words, the house in your head has to pass the by-law first. A beautiful design that exceeds the standards does not get built.

An illustrative example, with numbers I made up only to show the arithmetic: suppose a lot is 600 square metres and the by-law caps lot coverage at 30%. The building footprint can then cover at most about 180 square metres. If the floor plan you want needs a 220-square-metre footprint, that plan does not work on that lot — unless you obtain a variance. Percentages and limits differ by municipality and by zone, so never carry these figures to a real property.

If a proposal is only slightly over a standard, section 45 of the Planning Act allows an application to the local Committee of Adjustment for a minor variance. The committee decides whether the variance is minor in nature and maintains the general intent of the official plan and the by-law, among other tests. It is an application, not a right, and approval is never guaranteed.

Severance is a separate question. If your plan involves splitting one lot into two, or reshaping lot lines, that generally requires a consent under section 53 of the Planning Act, granted by the approving authority subject to conditions. Whether a lot can be severed cannot be inferred from the fact that a neighbour severed theirs. So question one is this: can the house I want be built as-of-right under the current by-law — and if a variance or a severance is needed, have I priced in the odds and the time?

Gate two: demolition and construction both need a permit first

Section 8 of Ontario's Building Code Act, 1992 is direct: you must apply to the municipality's chief building official and obtain a building permit before you construct or demolish a building, unless a prescribed exemption applies. A teardown-rebuild stacks two regulated jobs together — demolish the old house, then build the new one — and each step follows the permit process.

A permit application is more than a form. You generally submit drawings and documents showing the design complies with the Building Code, the applicable zoning standards, and other applicable law. Work starts after the permit is issued, and inspections follow at stages of construction. Reversing that order — demolishing, excavating, or pouring first and sorting out paperwork later — is usually far more expensive than waiting for the review, and can lead to stop-work orders or orders to undo work.

So question two: does my timeline leave real room for design, review, and revisions? And question three follows immediately: where does the family live during construction, for how long, and is that temporary-housing cost in the total budget? Rebuilds run in months or years, and the in-between housing bill is the one most often left out.

Gate three: tax and financing do not follow resale-home rules

This is the gate most often underestimated. Under the self-supply rules in section 191 of the Excise Tax Act, a person who builds a home and moves into it can be treated as a "builder" for GST/HST purposes. When the home is substantially complete and you occupy it as your residence, you are generally deemed to have made a taxable supply to yourself at the home's fair market value at that time, and to have paid tax on that supply — with the net amount owing worked out from there. Put simply, HST may be calculated on the fair market value of the finished home, land included in the picture, not just on the invoices your contractors gave you. A GST/HST New Housing Rebate may be available if the conditions are met, subject to its limits, and that has to be checked against CRA's rules case by case.

Why this matters, in illustrative terms: if the finished home's fair market value is well above what you paid for the land plus construction — not unusual after a rising market — the tax base under the self-supply rules is the value figure, not your out-of-pocket figure. The wider that gap, the less this tax can afford to be a surprise at move-in. Have an accountant run your numbers against CRA's builder self-supply guidance before you start, not after. This article gives the framework only.

Financing differs just as much, in general terms:

Regular mortgage on an existing home Construction financing for a rebuild (general)
How funds advance Essentially in one advance on closing In stages, as construction progresses, usually with progress inspections
What the lender reviews The existing home's value and your ability to pay The land, plans, budget, builder, and the value when finished
Cash-flow rhythm Normal payments begin after closing You bridge each stage and your own contributions along the way
Biggest risk Paying too much Cost overruns and delays straining your cash flow

Products and conditions vary widely between lenders; the table describes the general pattern, not any one institution's offer. That leads to question four: is the construction financing actually arranged, and who covers an overrun if one happens? And question five: adding land, construction, permits and professional fees, temporary housing, tax under the self-supply rules, and a contingency for overruns — is the total still better than buying an existing home? If the answer is fuzzy, it is not yet time to buy the lot.

Three common misunderstandings

"My neighbour built that big, so I can copy it." No. The neighbour's house may be legal under older standards, or may have gone through a variance. What you can build is set by the current by-law and the approvals you obtain yourself.

"It's my own home, so there is no HST — HST is only when you sell." Not so. Building and occupying your own new home is one of the situations the self-supply rules specifically address: tax may be calculated on fair market value when you move in. A resale home is generally exempt from GST/HST; a new self-built home is a different analysis. Do not blend the two.

"The land loan was approved, so the rebuild money is sorted." It is not. Financing the land purchase and financing the construction are different arrangements. Construction funds advance in stages with inspections, and bridging those stages — plus any overrun — has to be planned in advance.

If you still want to rebuild, do these things in this order

  1. Take the property address to the municipality and check the current zoning by-law and official plan: use, coverage, height, and setbacks, tested against the floor plan you actually want — not just the seller's word for it.
  2. If the plan exceeds a standard or involves splitting land, consult the municipal planning department and an Ontario planning professional about the minor variance or consent route, its conditions, and a realistic timeline, before you make an offer.
  3. Have a designer experienced in rebuilds prepare preliminary plans, and work the schedule backwards from the permit requirement in section 8 of the Building Code Act, leaving room for review and revisions.
  4. Before construction starts, have an accountant model the tax under CRA's builder self-supply rules: when the tax point falls, how fair market value is approached, and whether a New Housing Rebate application is available to you. Get it in writing.
  5. In parallel, settle the construction financing with a lender: how many draws, what each inspection requires, how much of your own money goes in first, and what happens on an overrun. Get clear answers before you sign the land purchase.
  6. Finally, build one total-cost table — land, construction, soft costs, temporary housing, tax, and contingency — and set it beside the total cost of buying an existing home in the same area. If the numbers hold up, proceed.

Trust Professional, Diligent Work. I am Ming Ren. For a decision like buying land or a teardown to rebuild, answer these five questions first, and then we will go through the documents and the numbers, item by item.


This article is general information only, not legal or tax advice. Zoning standards, permit requirements, and tax outcomes vary by municipality, property, and personal circumstances. Consult an Ontario lawyer, a planning professional, and an accountant before acting.

Primary sources: Planning Act, R.S.O. 1990, ss.34, 45, 53; Building Code Act, 1992, S.O. 1992, s.8 (Ontario e-Laws); Excise Tax Act, s.191 and CRA guidance on builder self-supply and the GST/HST New Housing Rebate (Canada.ca). The 600-square-metre and 30% figures are illustrative only, not a real case.

Frequently asked questions

My neighbour built that big, so can I copy it?

No. The neighbour's house may be legal under older standards, or may have gone through a variance. What you can build is set by the current by-law and the approvals you obtain yourself.

It's my own home, so is there no HST?

Not so. Building and occupying your own new home is one of the situations the self-supply rules specifically address: tax may be calculated on fair market value when you move in. A resale home is generally exempt from GST/HST; a new self-built home is a different analysis.

The land loan was approved, so is the rebuild money sorted?

It is not. Financing the land purchase and financing the construction are different arrangements. Construction funds advance in stages with inspections, and bridging those stages — plus any overrun — has to be planned in advance.

This article in other languages: 中文فارسی

Want to talk about your home?

You can also call directly, or scan the code to add Ming on WeChat.

Ming’s WeChat QR code
Scan to add on WeChat

Community guides by city

All cities →
☎ Call MingFree Evaluation