Ming RenBroker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage
☎ 647-779-9186

Buying a Home

New Build vs. Resale in Ontario: Compare Four Costs Before You Compare Price Per Square Foot

By , Broker, RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc. (About Ming) · Published

Ming Ren · Broker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage

← All articles · Buying a Home · Category guide

I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.

The plain conclusion first: neither a new build nor a resale home is simply "better." Each fits a different timeline and cash flow. A new build buys you a brand-new home, a Tarion warranty and a staged deposit schedule, at the cost of HST, a long wait, and a delivery date you do not fully control. A resale home buys you a house you can see and a firm move-in date, at the cost of no warranty and a condition you must investigate yourself. Settle four accounts — deposits, tax, warranty and time — before you compare price per square foot. Reverse that order and the conclusion is usually wrong.

First: deposits and tax — the cash flows are shaped completely differently

Start with how the money leaves. On a resale home, the deposit is typically paid in one amount shortly after acceptance, at the percentage the parties negotiated, and the balance is completed on closing day by your mortgage and remaining funds. Pre-construction is the mirror image: deposits are paid in instalments on the builder's schedule over the months after signing, and the cumulative total is usually higher than a resale deposit. The money goes out earlier and stays out longer, but each payment is smaller. Whether your cash works better as "one larger amount now" or "smaller amounts spread out" can decide the route by itself.

Then tax. A brand-new home in Ontario is subject to HST. A resale home bought from an individual for personal use is generally exempt from GST/HST — a major cost that exists only on the new-build side. Eligible new-home buyers can claim the CRA's GST/HST New Housing Rebate: the federal and Ontario parts each have their own calculation and price ceilings, the rebate phases out as the price rises and reaches zero above the ceiling, and your own eligibility is governed by CRA's Guide RC4028. In practice, builder pricing often already credits the expected rebate into the price and requires you to assign the rebate to the builder — which means the "net price" you see rests on assumptions, chiefly that you are an eligible buyer who will live in the home. If you actually intend to rent it out, a different rental rebate regime may apply and the pricing assumption can fail. Having your lawyer pin this down before signing is the single easiest way to avoid an expensive surprise on a pre-construction purchase.

First-time buyers should also check the federal and provincial relief aimed at newly built homes for their own use. These programs have specific agreement dates and eligibility windows and apply only to new homes. Whether you qualify, and for how much, should be calculated from your actual agreement date by your lawyer or accountant — not taken from an advertisement.

Second: warranty — a new build has Tarion, a resale home has your inspection

The new build's strongest card is warranty. New homes in Ontario carry a builder's warranty backed by Tarion, structured as the familiar 1/2/7: year one covers defects in workmanship and materials and Ontario Building Code violations; year two covers water penetration through the basement and foundation walls and defects in the electrical, plumbing and heating systems; year seven covers major structural defects. The warranty runs from the date of possession, and claims follow Tarion's forms and deadlines — miss a deadline and even a legitimate defect may go unremedied. A new-home buyer's first serious task after moving in is putting those filing dates in a calendar.

Tarion also provides deposit protection: qualifying deposits are protected up to set limits if the builder fails to perform, with different treatment for freehold homes and condos — confirm the current limits on Tarion's site. Note the words "up to": protection has a ceiling and does not mean every dollar of a large staged deposit is covered in full. The more deposit a pre-construction schedule asks you to accumulate, the more carefully you should separate the protected portion from the excess.

A resale home has no Tarion warranty and no one standing behind its condition; it is sold as it stands. Your substitute tools are exactly two: a home inspection, to surface roof, furnace, wiring and water risks inside the conditional period, and conditions and clauses in your offer that leave you a way out. Skip the inspection on a resale purchase and you have taken the new build's warranty and the resale buyer's one real check, and chosen neither.

Comparison New build (builder / pre-construction) Resale
Deposit rhythm Staged on the builder's schedule; cumulative total usually higher One amount shortly after acceptance; balance on closing
GST/HST Payable on a new home; new housing rebate may apply Generally exempt on a personal-use resale
Warranty Tarion 1/2/7 statutory warranty plus capped deposit protection None — as-is, rely on inspection
Move-in timing Wait for construction; possible delays; condos may have interim occupancy Firm closing date, usually weeks away
Extra closing costs Development-related charges, connections, occupancy fees — check caps in the agreement Mainly land transfer tax, legal fees and adjustments

Third: time and certainty are the most expensive account of all

A resale closing date, once it is in the agreement, is a date. You can see the home as it is and the neighbourhood as it is, and you move in weeks later with the fewest variables. A new build's timeline is different in kind: a pre-construction project waits on construction, the builder has room to move key dates within the agreement and the Tarion framework, and when a condo unit is finally ready to live in there may be an interim occupancy period first — monthly occupancy fees, with title and the mortgage still to come.

New-build closings also carry a list of charges resale buyers never see: development and education levies, utility connections, Tarion-related enrolment costs and the like. Amounts live in the agreement; some can be negotiated to a cap, some cannot. Comparing a builder's sticker price against a resale price without that list misses exactly the difference that matters. The correct method is to have your lawyer list everything payable on top of the price, arrive at a true total, and compare totals.

So my decision framework is simple. If you must be in by a date, and your cash flow cannot absorb waiting and surprises, look at resale first — or at a completed, ready new home. If you can wait, value brand-new condition and warranty coverage, and qualify for the rebates, the new-build math may win. Either way, decide on total cost, possession date and who carries the risk — never on price per square foot alone.

Three common misunderstandings

"The builder's price already includes the tax and the rebate, so I never have to think about tax." The rebate credited into a price rests on assumptions, including that you are an eligible owner-occupier. Fail the eligibility test, or decide to rent the home out, and the assumption reverses — the shortfall is yours. Have your lawyer verify eligibility before you sign, not when the statement of adjustments arrives.

"With a Tarion warranty, a new home needs no inspection and no attention from me." The warranty has a scope, deadlines and a claims process. It covers defects as defined, not routine maintenance, and not losses you let slide by missing a filing window. The pre-delivery inspection and every claim deadline still need you to show up and do them properly.

"Resale avoids HST, so its total cost is always lower." Avoiding HST is not the same as saving money. An older home's roof, furnace, windows and water repairs are real cash; the bills simply arrive later and in pieces. A fair total includes the major repairs of the next several years.

If you are deciding between a new build and a resale home, do these in order

  1. Fix your timeline first: the latest date you must be living there, and how much delay you can honestly absorb. This alone removes half the options.
  2. Lay out the cash both ways: the resale deposit and closing balance against the staged pre-construction deposits and how long they sit out, matched against your income and any sale of your current home.
  3. For a new build, have your lawyer list every charge on top of the price and every rebate assumption, and confirm which charges are capped. For a resale home, budget the inspection and the next five years of major repairs. Then compare totals.
  4. Verify eligibility: new housing rebates and first-time buyer relief for new homes, calculated from your agreement date and intended use by a professional — not from advertising figures.
  5. Once you decide, calendar the deadlines that matter: for a new build, the Tarion claim windows and expected delivery dates; for a resale home, the conditional period and closing day. No deadline should live in your memory alone.

Trust Professional, Diligent Work. I am Ming Ren. The new-versus-resale argument was never really about old and new — it is about how the money is paid and who carries the risk. Settle those four accounts first, and then we can talk about which home.


This article is general information, not legal or tax advice. Rebate eligibility, warranty scope and agreement charges vary by case; consult an Ontario lawyer and an accountant before you sign.

Primary sources: Tarion official new home warranty (1/2/7 years) and deposit protection pages (tarion.com); CRA GST/HST New Housing Rebate and Guide RC4028 (canada.ca), consulted November 2026.

Frequently asked questions

The builder price already includes tax and the rebate, so I never have to think about tax?

The rebate credited into a price rests on assumptions, including that you are an eligible owner-occupier. Fail the eligibility test, or decide to rent the home out, and the assumption reverses and the shortfall is yours. Have your lawyer verify eligibility before you sign.

With a Tarion warranty, does a new home need no inspection or attention?

The warranty has a scope, deadlines and a claims process. It covers defects as defined, not routine maintenance, and not losses you let slide by missing a filing window. The pre-delivery inspection and every claim deadline still need you to show up properly.

Resale avoids HST, so is its total cost always lower?

Avoiding HST is not the same as saving money. An older home's roof, furnace, windows and water repairs are real cash; the bills simply arrive later and in pieces. A fair total includes the major repairs of the next several years.

This article in other languages: 中文فارسی

Want to talk about your home?

You can also call directly, or scan the code to add Ming on WeChat.

Ming’s WeChat QR code
Scan to add on WeChat

Community guides by city

All cities →
☎ Call MingFree Evaluation