Ming RenBroker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage
☎ 647-779-9186

Renting, Landlords & Tenants

Your Tenant Wants to Paint, Drill or Swap a Light Fixture: Permission and Restoring the Unit in Ontario

By , Broker, RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc. (About Ming) · Published

Ming Ren · Broker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage

← All articles · Renting, Landlords & Tenants · Category guide

I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.

Here is the plain conclusion first: whether a tenant may change the unit is answered by section 12 of the Standard Form of Lease, not by some "renovation section" in the Residential Tenancies Act, 2006 (the RTA) — there is no such section. Decorative items, such as pictures and window coverings, the tenant may install. Anything else needs the landlord's permission first. And if the unit is not restored at move-out, the landlord cannot deduct the cost from the deposit: Ontario has no damage deposit. The only recovery route is an application to the Landlord and Tenant Board (LTB) under s.89 of the RTA, filed within one year after the tenant moves out, and the landlord must show undue damage caused wilfully or negligently — not ordinary wear and tear.

Three things follow: what a tenant may do without asking, what to write down when you say yes, and where the money actually comes from if the unit is not restored.

First: permission is decided by section 12 of the lease

Section 12 of Ontario's Standard Form of Lease (Form 2229E) sorts changes into two groups:

  • Decorative items: the tenant may install decorative items; the examples named in the lease are pictures and window coverings. These do not need permission case by case. What a landlord can do is set reasonable restrictions in the additional terms under section 15 — for example, specifying the type of hook, or requiring written notice before drilling.
  • Other changes: the tenant cannot make other changes to the rental unit without the landlord's permission. Repainting in a new colour, drilling for a wall-mounted TV bracket, and replacing a light fixture will usually fall on this side. The lease does not list them by name, so when there is doubt, the cheap solution is to ask in writing and answer in writing before the work starts.

Two limits matter. First, section 12 itself cannot be changed; extra detail belongs in the section 15 additional terms, and s.4 of the RTA makes a term that is inconsistent with the Act void. Whether a blanket rule like "nothing may be hung on any wall" is still a "reasonable restriction," or whether it takes away the very right section 12 gives, is not answered directly in the statute — the LTB decides it on the facts of the case. Second, the one thing the RTA itself says a tenant "shall not alter" is the locking system: under s.35, a tenant must not change the locks on a door giving entry to the unit or the complex during the tenancy without the landlord's consent. If they do, the landlord may apply to the Board, which can order the tenant to hand over keys or pay the reasonable out-of-pocket cost of changing the lock back.

Second: when you say yes, write the restoration standard into the same reply

In my years handling rentals, disputes rarely start over whether a change was allowed. They start over what "put it back" was supposed to mean. So when a landlord consents, the written reply should cover four points: what will be changed and where, how the work will be done, what restoration is required at move-out, and who keeps the original fixtures that come down.

Here is an example I made up, for illustration only: a tenant wants to paint one wall a dark colour. The landlord agrees in writing, and the same reply states that before move-out the wall goes back to the move-in colour, the TV bracket holes are filled, and the original light fixture is returned. When the tenancy ends and the wall is still dark and the holes are open, the landlord now has a standard both sides confirmed, plus dated photos from move-in and move-out, so what the change left behind is easy to separate from the marks of ordinary living. Compare that with a verbal "go ahead" — at move-out, the argument is no longer about a standard, it is about two memories.

The move-in record matters just as much: photograph the walls, fixtures and fittings room by room on the day the tenant moves in, and have both sides confirm the record. Without a "before," an "after" is hard to prove.

Third: no restoration, no deduction — recovery runs through s.89

Start by closing the deposit door. Under s.105, the only security deposit a landlord may collect is a rent deposit under s.106, and s.106(10) requires that deposit to be applied to the rent for the last rent period before the tenancy ends. It was never a repair fund, and section 8 of the standard lease says plainly that it cannot be used as a damage deposit. Collecting a separate "renovation deposit" or "damage deposit" is not a workaround: s.134(1) prohibits a landlord from collecting a fee, penalty or other like amount that the Act does not permit.

The real tool is s.89. A landlord may apply to the LTB for an order requiring a tenant or former tenant to pay the reasonable cost of repairing damaged property, or, where repair is not reasonable, replacing it. But three tests apply:

  • The damage test: the damage must be undue damage caused wilfully or negligently by the tenant, another occupant, or someone the tenant let in. That is the same standard as the tenant's repair responsibility in s.34. Damage from the normal use of the unit over time — wear and tear — is outside it, and Part J of the standard lease appendix draws the same line. Whether nail holes, a colour change or bracket holes are wear and tear or undue damage has no pre-written list; the LTB decides on the facts.
  • The clock test: the application may be made while the tenant is still in possession, or no later than one year after the tenant ceased to be in possession (s.89(1.1)). That year runs from the day the tenant moved out, not from the day you noticed the problem.
  • The reasonableness test: a party entitled to compensation must take reasonable steps to minimize the loss (s.16). The repair plan, quotes and receipts all have to survive the word "reasonable."

If the damage shows up during the tenancy, termination notices exist, but they are built on the same undue-damage test. Section 62 (Form N5) covers undue damage caused wilfully or negligently: the termination date is no earlier than the 20th day after the notice, and the tenant gets seven days to repair or pay, which voids the notice if done. Section 63 (Form N7) covers only wilful undue damage: the termination date can be as early as the 10th day, there is no seven-day cure period, and the landlord must prove the damage was wilful at the hearing. A change made without permission that caused no undue damage does not automatically fit either section — think that through before serving anything.

Three common misunderstandings

Misunderstanding one: "I hold the deposit, so I will just deduct the repainting cost." You cannot. The rent deposit must go to the last rent period; by move-out it is already spent on rent. Repair money has to come through a s.89 application, not out of the deposit on your own say-so.

Misunderstanding two: "The tenant signed a restore-on-move-out clause, so any failure to restore is automatically money owed." A signed restoration term is valuable evidence of the standard the two sides agreed on. But an LTB claim still has to pass the s.89 tests: undue damage caused wilfully or negligently, and a reasonable cost to fix it. The clause helps you prove the facts; it does not skip the tests.

Misunderstanding three: "The change was never approved, so I can make the tenant leave right away." It does not work that way. Termination turns on undue damage: s.62 gives the tenant a seven-day cure period, and s.63 requires proof the damage was wilful. For an unapproved change with no undue damage, preserve your evidence, communicate in writing, and then choose the right process.

If a tenant asks to change something, I suggest working in this order

  1. Classify the request against section 12 of the standard lease: decorative item, or an "other change" that needs your permission. If it is unclear, treat it as needing permission and ask the tenant to put the request in writing.
  2. Answer in writing either way. If you agree, include the scope, the method of work, the move-out restoration standard and who keeps the original fixtures. If you refuse, give the reason and keep the correspondence.
  3. Photograph the whole unit at move-in and again at move-out, confirmed by both sides. Add close-ups before and after any approved change, and keep dated copies.
  4. Take only the lawful rent deposit and apply it only to the last rent period. Do not collect a damage deposit under any name, and do not deduct repair costs from the deposit.
  5. At move-out, separate ordinary wear and tear from identifiable undue damage, get reasonable repair quotes and receipts, and keep the claim within a reasonable scope.
  6. If you need to claim, respect the s.89 clock: one year from the day the tenant moved out. Do not let a late discovery become a missed deadline.
  7. If serious damage appears mid-tenancy, check which of s.62 and s.63 you can actually support — whether you can prove the damage was wilful decides which notice fits. Do not pick by feel.

I am Ming Ren. With rental changes and restoration, get the permission and the standard on paper first, and we will go through the documents one by one.


This article is general information, not legal advice. The lease terms, the nature of the change and how damage is characterized will affect the outcome in a specific case; consult an Ontario lawyer or licensed paralegal before acting.

Primary sources: Residential Tenancies Act, 2006, S.O. 2006, c.17, ss.4, 16, 33, 34, 35, 62, 63, 89, 105, 106, 134 (Ontario e-Laws, checked November 2026); Standard Form of Lease (Form 2229E), ss.8, 12, 15 and Appendix Part J. The dark-wall example above is illustrative and is not a real case.

Frequently asked questions

I hold the deposit, so will I just deduct the repainting cost?

You cannot. The rent deposit must go to the last rent period and by move-out it is already spent on rent; repair money has to come through a s.89 application, not out of the deposit on your own say-so.

The tenant signed a restore-on-move-out clause, so is any failure to restore automatically money owed?

A signed restoration term is valuable evidence of the standard the two sides agreed on, but an LTB claim still has to pass the s.89 tests: undue damage caused wilfully or negligently, and a reasonable cost to fix it. The clause helps you prove the facts; it does not skip the tests.

The change was never approved, so can I make the tenant leave right away?

It does not work that way. Termination turns on undue damage: s.62 gives the tenant a seven-day cure period, and s.63 requires proof the damage was wilful; for an unapproved change with no undue damage, preserve your evidence, communicate in writing, and then choose the right process.

This article in other languages: 中文فارسی

Want to talk about your home?

You can also call directly, or scan the code to add Ming on WeChat.

Ming’s WeChat QR code
Scan to add on WeChat

Community guides by city

All cities →
☎ Call MingFree Evaluation