Ming RenBroker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage
☎ 647-779-9186

Selling a Home

Switching Listing Agents Mid-Contract in Ontario: Get the Sequence Right, or Risk Paying Commission Twice

By , Broker, RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc. (About Ming) · Published

Ming Ren · Broker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage

← All articles · Selling a Home · Category guide

I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.

Here is the conclusion first, in plain terms: if your listing is live and the agent is not the right fit, you can switch — but the order matters more than the decision itself. A listing agreement is a contract between you and the brokerage, not a handshake with one individual. If you sign with a new brokerage and relist before the old agreement has been dealt with in writing, the biggest risk is not awkwardness — it is paying commission twice on the same sale. So a switch really has three steps: settle the status of the old agreement in writing, deal with the holdover clause, and only then sign the new agreement. Here is how each step works.

Step one: know who your contract is actually with — two very different kinds of "switch"

RECO (the Real Estate Council of Ontario) makes this point in its consumer guidance on representation agreements: the agreement is between you and the brokerage, and the broker or salesperson is the person who provides services on the brokerage's behalf. That one fact splits "switching agents" into two situations with very different levels of difficulty.

The first is switching within the same brokerage. If your problem is with the individual serving you — slow communication, a working style that does not fit — but you have no issue with the brokerage itself, you can contact the brokerage's Broker of Record, explain the situation, and ask to be reassigned to another agent. Because the brokerage is your contracting party, an internal switch normally does not require terminating anything: the term, commission and other terms of the original agreement continue, and a different person does the work. This is by far the simplest switch.

The second is switching to a different brokerage. That is not just a change of person — it means ending your contract with the current brokerage first, then signing with a new one. An agreement does not dissolve before its expiry date just because you announce "I don't want to work with you anymore." Whether it can end early, and on what terms, depends on what the agreement itself says and on what the two sides can negotiate. So before you sit down with a new agent to talk strategy, pull out the agreement you actually signed and read it. That document is where every switch starts.

Step two: closing out the old agreement — terminate, suspend, or let it expire

In practice, there are three common ways to wrap up the relationship with the current brokerage. Which one fits depends on how much time is left on the term and how the relationship stands.

Negotiated termination (mutual written agreement). This is the cleanest route: you and the brokerage agree in writing to end the agreement early, setting out the effective date, how commission is to be treated, and how buyers already introduced are to be handled, and both sides sign. A spoken "fine, let's just call it off" is not enough. If there is ever a dispute, what counts is the paper, not anyone's memory.

Suspension. In some cases the two sides agree to suspend the listing instead: the home comes off the market and promotion stops, but the agreement itself remains in force and its clock keeps running. Suspension suits a seller who wants to pause — you are not ready to sell right now, or you want time to think. Remember that suspended is not terminated: the contract obligations are still alive, so do not sign with another brokerage and relist during a suspension.

Let it expire. If little time remains on the term and an early termination cannot be agreed, letting the agreement run to its expiry date is the unglamorous but safest option. After expiry you are free to sign with any brokerage — but do not forget the holdover clause below. Expiry does not mean everything is wiped clean.

Whichever route you take, one line should not be crossed: do not sign a new listing agreement, and do not let a new agent start marketing the home, until the status of the old agreement is confirmed in writing. If a new agent urges you to "sign now and let me sort out the old one," be careful — if a double-commission dispute erupts, the person who pays is you, not them.

Step three: the trap most switchers miss — the holdover clause

Listing agreements typically contain a holdover clause. In general terms, it says that for a period after the agreement expires or is terminated, if the home sells to a buyer who was introduced to the property — who viewed it or negotiated — during the original agreement through the original brokerage, that brokerage may still be entitled to commission. The clause exists for a fair reason: to stop a seller from cutting out a brokerage after it did the work of bringing the buyer.

Why is it dangerous when you switch? An illustrative example, with invented numbers that are not a real transaction: suppose your agreement's holdover period runs for a set number of days after the term ends. A buyer viewed your home while the first agent had the listing. You switch brokerages and relist, and that same buyer comes back and buys through the new brokerage. If the sale falls within the holdover period and the buyer is one the clause covers, you could owe commission under the new agreement and face a commission claim from the original brokerage under the holdover clause — two commissions on one sale.

Avoiding that trap is about doing detailed work at the moment of the switch:

  • When the agreement is terminated or expires, ask the original brokerage for a written list of the buyers it introduced during the term. The clearer the list, the clearer everything is later.
  • Before signing with the new brokerage, show the new agent the holdover clause and that buyer list, and ask directly how commission would be handled if a sale closes inside the holdover period. Get the agreed handling written into the new agreement or a schedule to it — not left as a verbal assurance.
  • If a buyer plainly came through the original agent's work, dealing with it honestly under the clause is usually far cheaper than fighting a dispute afterwards.

Holdover is not the only thing to negotiate. Before signing the new agreement, settle these as well: the length of the new term (for a first engagement, a shorter term leaves both sides room), the commission structure, and what early-termination terms would apply if this relationship also goes wrong. Whatever made you uncomfortable in the last agreement is exactly what should be spelled out in the next one.

Common misunderstandings

Misunderstanding 1: "The agent works for me, so if I fire the agent, the contract is gone." It is not. Your contracting party is the brokerage, not the individual. If you are unhappy with the agent, you can ask the brokerage to assign someone else; but ending the contract with the brokerage has to follow the agreement — negotiated termination, suspension, or expiry. A unilateral declaration does not end it.

Misunderstanding 2: "The listing was taken off MLS, so the agreement must be over." Removing a listing only stops the marketing. It does not terminate the agreement. Whether the agreement has ended, and how the holdover period runs, is determined by the written documents between you and the brokerage — not by a status shown on MLS.

Misunderstanding 3: "Once the agreement expires, I owe the old brokerage nothing, ever." Not necessarily. The holdover clause exists precisely for the period after expiry: if a buyer introduced during the term buys within the holdover period, a commission claim may still stand. The expiry date and the end of the holdover period are two different dates, and a clean switch requires knowing both.

Action checklist for switching agents

  1. Find your signed listing agreement and confirm three things: the brokerage's full legal name, the expiry date, and what the holdover clause says — how many days, and which buyers it covers.
  2. Talk to your current agent once, plainly. Many problems are communication and expectations; if they can be fixed, you may not need to switch — and if they cannot, you leave a record of a good-faith attempt.
  3. Choose your path: for an internal switch, contact the Broker of Record; for a new brokerage, first arrange termination or suspension of the old agreement.
  4. Put every termination or suspension in a document signed by both sides, with the effective date and commission treatment stated. Do not rely on a verbal "okay" or a text message.
  5. Get the list of buyers introduced during the term from the original brokerage, in writing, and keep it on file.
  6. Before signing the new agreement, show the new brokerage the old agreement's status documents and the buyer list, and write the holdover-period commission handling into the new agreement.
  7. Mark both dates before you relist: the old agreement's termination/expiry date and the end of the holdover period. Plan marketing and pricing inside the holdover window with the new agent in advance.
  8. If the brokerage refuses to negotiate and you believe it has failed its obligations or acted improperly, raise it formally with its Broker of Record; if that fails, RECO's complaints process is available, and it is worth consulting an Ontario real estate lawyer before acting.

Honest work, done properly, is what lasts. Switching agents does not have to be a falling-out: get the sequence right, keep the paperwork complete, and you can change representation with a clear head and a clean file.

— Ming Ren, Broker, RE/MAX Realtron


This article is general information, not legal advice. Termination, holdover and commission obligations depend on the exact wording of the agreement you signed and the facts of your case; consult an Ontario lawyer before acting.

Primary sources: Real Estate Council of Ontario (RECO) consumer guidance on representation agreements and the RECO Information Guide (reco.on.ca); Trust in Real Estate Services Act, 2002 (TRESA), Ontario e-Laws. No market statistics are used in this article; the example given is illustrative only.

Frequently asked questions

The agent works for me, so if I fire the agent, is the contract gone?

It is not. Your contracting party is the brokerage, not the individual; you can ask the brokerage to assign someone else, but ending the contract with the brokerage has to follow the agreement — negotiated termination, suspension, or expiry.

The listing was taken off MLS, so is the agreement over?

Removing a listing only stops the marketing; it does not terminate the agreement. Whether the agreement has ended, and how the holdover period runs, is determined by the written documents between you and the brokerage, not by a status shown on MLS.

Once the agreement expires, do I owe the old brokerage nothing ever?

Not necessarily. The holdover clause exists precisely for the period after expiry: if a buyer introduced during the term buys within the holdover period, a commission claim may still stand, and the expiry date and the end of the holdover period are two different dates.

This article in other languages: 中文فارسی

Want to talk about your home?

You can also call directly, or scan the code to add Ming on WeChat.

Ming’s WeChat QR code
Scan to add on WeChat

Community guides by city

All cities →
☎ Call MingFree Evaluation