Ming RenBroker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage
☎ 647-779-9186

Selling a Home

The Wrong Agent Rarely Fails in Nine Ways. The Signs Group Into Three Problems

By , Broker, RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc. (About Ming) · Published

Ming Ren · Broker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage

← All articles · Selling a Home · Category guide

I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.

Here is the plain conclusion first: you do not need a long checklist to judge an agent. Watch three things — whether you can actually reach them and they do what they said, whether they stand on your side of the table or their own, and whether their pricing and local judgement hold up. If two of those three are failing, a slow sale or a frustrating purchase is usually not bad luck. It is the wrong hire.

Lists of warning signs tend to run long. I have regrouped the usual nine, because item by item each one looks minor. Together, they show whether you are looking at an off day or a habit.

Problem one: unreachable, and promises that evaporate

This group shows up first and gets forgiven most easily. It is also the one that quietly costs you chances.

Replies with no predictable timing. If an agent took a long time to answer you when you first called, expect slower, not faster, after you sign. Showings and offer deadlines move in hours; an agent who is half a day behind can cost you a window. Ask before you sign: how quickly do you normally reply, what is the best way to reach you, and is that contact information actually public and findable?

Agreed tasks that never get followed up. The question they said they would ask goes unasked; the material they said they would send needs two reminders. Once is a busy week. Every time is a working method.

Big promises made to win you, then forgotten. A promise is worth nothing until it is written down and delivered. Whatever the agent offers — how often you will get updates, what marketing will be done, when pricing will be reviewed — get it on paper before signing. If there is a dispute later, you will have text; they will have "I don't think I said that."

None of this requires market expertise to judge. Count reply times and kept promises. The answer is in the count.

Problem two: they stand on their own side of the table

This group is more serious than slowness, because it costs you interest, not just patience.

Documents put in front of you to sign before they are explained. In Ontario, before providing services, an agent must give you RECO's Information Guide and explain it. Before you sign any representation agreement, its term, remuneration, and termination terms should be walked through item by item. An electronic signature is a convenience, not a substitute for the explanation. If a tablet is pushed at you with "just sign here," you are entitled to stop: unexplained means unsigned, for now.

Showings that keep landing on their own listings. An agent who has listings is not a problem, and an occasional one that genuinely fits is fine to see first. But if nearly every home you are shown is listed by that agent or their team, while better matches sit on the market unshown, ask what the selection is serving: screening homes for you, or finding a buyer for their listings? The test is simple — ask for the full list of homes that meet your criteria, then compare what you were taken to with what you were not.

The plainest test of where an agent stands is this: when their income and your interest point in different directions, which one gets mentioned first? If the answer comes out the same way twice, do not wait for a third time.

Problem three: pricing and judgement that do not hold up, and too little time in the business

This group is the most expensive for sellers and the most time-consuming for buyers.

A price quoted high to win the listing. This is the costliest move in selling. An illustrative example, with invented numbers: three agents value a home at around $1,000,000, and a fourth says $1,100,000. Choose the fourth, and the usual result is a listing nobody visits, followed by a series of price cuts, ending at or below what a realistic start would have achieved. Remember: what your home is worth is decided by the buyer who eventually pays, not by the agent who quoted the highest number to get your signature. An outlier valuation should come with sold evidence, not with flattering talk.

Selling reduced to one step: putting the home on MLS. An MLS listing is the baseline, not the whole marketing effort. Photography, pricing pace, showing arrangements, communication within the brokerage community, and follow-up on enquiries together decide how many of the right buyers ever see the home. Before signing, have the agent lay out the marketing plan item by item. A plan that cannot be described in advance usually will not be performed afterwards.

Working everywhere, rooted nowhere. An Ontario licence permits trading across the province, but real estate is a local business. An agent who rarely works in your neighbourhood will have a weak feel for its prices, buyer expectations, and local habits. Discount their pricing advice accordingly, on both the buying and selling side, and verify it against local sold evidence.

Doing this as a sideline. You would not choose a surgeon who operates twice a year, and buying or selling deserves the same instinct. Volume is not everything, but someone who rarely completes a transaction will be out of practice on market feel, negotiation pace, and paperwork. Whether an agent is registered with RECO, and with which brokerage, is public: you can check it yourself in RECO's Public Register rather than relying on an introduction.

Three misunderstandings I hear most often

"Whoever quotes the highest price must be the most able to sell my home high." Usually the opposite. The quote is what an agent gives to earn your signature; the selling price is what a buyer gives. Choosing the highest quote often buys you a longer listing period and a set of forced price cuts.

"A representation agreement can be left any time I am unhappy." No. In Ontario, the agreement is a contract with the brokerage, not a casual arrangement with one agent. Whether it can be ended early depends on the termination terms written into it — Ontario regulation requires an agreement to set out the terms related to termination, if any. Without a term that helps you, or the brokerage's agreement, you may have to wait for expiry, and still watch the holdover clause afterwards. That is why the careful reading belongs before you sign: expiry date, termination terms, holdover — item by item.

"Complaining to RECO will cancel my contract and get my money back." RECO regulates the conduct of agents and brokerages. It cannot release you from a contract, and it cannot award damages. RECO's own guidance is to raise the concern with the brokerage and its Broker of Record first; conduct concerns can then be filed through the complaints section of RECO's website, and RECO will first decide whether the matter is within its authority. Contract and money disputes belong on the lawyer-and-court track. Mixing the two tracks up wastes the deadlines on both.

If you already suspect you hired wrong, do these six things in order

  1. Turn feelings into a record: what was promised on which date, what was not delivered, how long replies took. Bring facts to the conversation, not frustration.
  2. Pull out the agreement you signed and read three places: the expiry date, the termination terms, and the holdover clause. Know what actually binds you before discussing next steps.
  3. Compare the services you were promised, item by item, with what was delivered. Raise each gap directly and ask for it to be confirmed in writing; keep a written record where it cannot be resolved.
  4. Take that record to the brokerage's Broker of Record for a formal conversation: improved performance, a different agent, or a negotiated release are all decided at this step. Ask for the answer in writing.
  5. If the problem is conduct — documents signed unexplained, an undisclosed conflict of interest — file through RECO's complaints process and attach your record and copies of the documents.
  6. If the dispute is about ending the contract or about money, consult an Ontario lawyer before acting, and do not sign with a new brokerage until the holdover and commission exposure are clear.

Trust Professional, Diligent Work. I am Ming Ren. Half an hour of hard questions before you sign beats three months of regret after. If you have an agreement in hand and are unsure what it binds you to, bring the documents and we will go through the clauses, item by item.


This article is general information only, not legal advice. The terms, length, and circumstances of the agreement you signed can change the conclusion. Consult an Ontario lawyer before acting.

Primary sources: RECO Information Guide and RECO complaints process (reco.on.ca, consulted November 2026); Trust in Real Estate Services Act, 2002 and O. Reg. 567/05, ss.13 and 13.4 (Ontario e-Laws). The $1,000,000 and $1,100,000 figures are illustrative only, not a real transaction or market statistics.

Frequently asked questions

Whoever quotes the highest price must be the most able to sell my home high, right?

Usually the opposite. The quote is what an agent gives to earn your signature; the selling price is what a buyer gives. Choosing the highest quote often buys a longer listing period and forced reductions.

Can I leave a representation agreement any time I am unhappy?

No. In Ontario, the agreement is a contract with the brokerage, not a casual arrangement with one agent. Whether you can end it early depends on the termination terms written into it; otherwise you generally wait for expiry and watch the holdover clause.

Will complaining to RECO cancel my contract and get my money back?

RECO regulates the conduct of agents and brokerages. It cannot release you from a contract, and it cannot award damages. Contract disputes and compensation go through a lawyer and the courts.

This article in other languages: 中文فارسی

Want to talk about your home?

You can also call directly, or scan the code to add Ming on WeChat.

Ming’s WeChat QR code
Scan to add on WeChat

Community guides by city

All cities →
☎ Call MingFree Evaluation