I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
Here is the plain conclusion first: when I review offers on a home I am selling, I look first at which buyer is most likely to reach closing day, not simply at who offered the most. I am not a mortgage professional and I do not arrange buyers' financing. But after years of transactions, I know this much: a high offer that stalls on financing is worth less than a slightly lower offer whose funds have actually been verified. Where the buyer's money comes from, how far their approval has really gone, and whether the home will appraise high enough — a seller should ask about all three before signing.
This article works through those three things: what a pre-approval actually is, the standard the buyer is really being tested against, and what still stands between an accepted offer and a closed deal.
1. A pre-approval is not an approval — ask how far the checking went
Many buyers treat a pre-approval as if the mortgage were settled. According to the Financial Consumer Agency of Canada (FCAC), a pre-approval is an early review: the lender looks at the buyer's income, debts and down payment, states a maximum amount the buyer may qualify for, and may hold an interest rate for a period that varies by lender, generally 60 to 130 days. FCAC states it plainly: the process does not guarantee approval for a mortgage, and a lender can still refuse after pre-approving.
Why? Because at the pre-approval stage, the lender has not yet reviewed your specific home. On a real application, the lender still has to verify that the property meets its standards, what the property is worth, where the down payment comes from, and whether the buyer's income, debts or credit have changed in the meantime. If any of those do not line up, the approved amount can come in below the pre-approved figure — or not come at all.
So when I review an offer for a seller, I do not stop at the line that says "pre-approved." I ask the other agent to confirm more specific points: which lender issued it, whether income and employment documents were actually submitted, whether a credit check was done, what amount and rate are held and until what date, and whether the down payment is sitting in the buyer's own funds or depends on another home selling first. The more specific the answers, the easier it is to tell serious preparation from a quick online estimate.
2. Buyers are tested at a higher rate, and the down payment has hard floors
How much a buyer can borrow is not calculated at the rate on their contract. Under OSFI's Guideline B-20 and the federal mortgage insurance rules, the buyer must pass a stress test: the qualifying rate is the higher of the contract rate plus two percentage points, or the 5.25% minimum qualifying rate. In other words, the buyer makes payments at one rate, but the lender sizes the mortgage as if the rate were higher — and that higher-rate calculation is what sets the buyer's real ceiling.
What does that mean for a seller? It means "I feel I can afford it" counts for nothing. What counts is how much the buyer can carry under the stress test. A job change, self-employment income, a recent move to a new position, or parental leave can all change how income is counted and how much documentation is required. A seller does not need to run those numbers for the buyer, but should understand this: the closer an offer sits to the buyer's own ceiling, the less room there is when something in the financing shifts.
The down payment has hard rules too. Under CMHC's current rules, the minimum down payment is 5% on the first $500,000 of the price and 10% on the portion above that; at a price of $1,500,000 or more, mortgage loan insurance is not available, so the buyer needs at least 20% down. An illustrative example with invented numbers: on a $1.2 million purchase (illustrative only, not a real transaction), the minimum down payment is 5% of $500,000 plus 10% of $700,000, which is $95,000. If that is exactly all the buyer has set aside, there may be nothing left for closing costs or an appraisal shortfall. That buyer is not necessarily a bad buyer — but the seller should know how thin the margin is.
3. Appraisal and closing certainty are the real test of a high offer
A lender lends against the value it accepts, not against the purchase price. After a deal is signed, the lender will typically order an appraisal. If the appraisal comes in below the purchase price, the lender will not lend extra to fill the gap; the buyer has to cover the difference in cash.
Another illustrative example: suppose the price is $1,000,000 (illustrative) and the appraisal comes in at $950,000. A buyer who planned to borrow 80% of the price — $800,000 — can now borrow at most 80% of $950,000, which is $760,000. Before closing, that buyer needs an extra $90,000 in cash: the $50,000 price gap plus the $40,000 the loan shrank by. If the buyer cannot produce it, the deal may never close. That is why, when an offer comes in well above recent comparable sales, I ask one more question: has this buyer set aside cash to cover an appraisal gap? That single question filters out a good number of offers written on enthusiasm alone.
Closing certainty also shows up in conditions and timing. An offer with a financing condition gives the buyer time to obtain a final approval — and during that time, the seller is waiting on an uncertain result. An offer with no conditions looks cleaner, but if the buyer does not yet hold a final approval on this specific property, the absence of conditions hides the risk rather than removing it. Buyers who are also selling carry one more layer: their down payment may be tied up in the proceeds of their own sale, and if the two closing dates do not line up, they may need bridge financing — which generally requires both the sale and the purchase agreements to be firm, with no conditions outstanding. Asking "how is your closing money arranged?" is not prying. It is checking whether the transaction's timetable is real.
Three misunderstandings I hear most often
"The buyer is pre-approved, so the financing is fine." No. FCAC is explicit that a pre-approval does not guarantee a mortgage. A pre-approval reviews the person; it has not yet reviewed the home. Final approval only counts once the lender has verified the property, its value, and the buyer's current financial position.
"A higher offer means a stronger borrower." An offer price is a number the buyer writes. A borrowing limit is a number the lender calculates under the stress test. The two are not necessarily related — and the further an offer runs ahead of comparable sales, the greater the risk the appraisal does not follow.
"An unconditional offer is the safest offer for a seller." Not necessarily. Waiving the financing condition only means the buyer gives up the right to walk away if financing fails; it does not mean the financing is in place. What a seller actually needs to confirm is how far the final approval has gone, where the down payment funds are, and who covers an appraisal gap.
If you are selling now, check offers in this order
- Compare closing certainty before price: line up each offer's financing condition, condition period, closing date and deposit first, and look at price second.
- Ask the other agent to confirm the pre-approval details: which lender issued it, which documents were verified, and what amount and rate are held until what date. Do not settle for a sheet that just says "pre-approved."
- Ask where the down payment comes from and what margin is left: how much it is, where the funds are, and whether the buyer has cash to cover a shortfall if the appraisal comes in below the price.
- Treat offers well above comparable sales with extra care: ask for a larger deposit or a shorter condition period, so the buyer proves with real arrangements that the money matches the number.
- If you are also buying your next home, run your own numbers early: breaking your existing mortgage can trigger a penalty, and commission and land transfer tax both need to be budgeted. If you will need bridge financing, talk to your lender early — not when the two closing dates are already colliding.
Trust Professional, Diligent Work. I am Ming Ren. If you are weighing offers and are unsure about any of them, lay the conditions and the numbers side by side and we will go through them one by one — closability first, price second.
This article is general information only, not legal advice and not mortgage or financial advice. For lending decisions, insurance eligibility and your own circumstances, confirm with a licensed mortgage professional and your lender; for transaction documents, consult an Ontario lawyer.
Primary sources: Financial Consumer Agency of Canada (FCAC), "Getting preapproved for a mortgage"; OSFI, Minimum Qualifying Rate for Uninsured Mortgages (Guideline B-20); CMHC, "Mortgage Loan Insurance for Consumers" (all consulted November 2026). The $1.2 million, $1,000,000 and $950,000 figures are illustrative only, not real transactions.
Frequently asked questions
The buyer is pre-approved, so is the financing fine?
No. FCAC is explicit that a pre-approval does not guarantee a mortgage. A pre-approval reviews the person; it has not yet reviewed the home. Final approval only counts once the lender has verified the property, its value, and the buyer's current financial position.
Does a higher offer mean a stronger borrower?
An offer price is a number the buyer writes. A borrowing limit is a number the lender calculates under the stress test. The two are not necessarily related — and the further an offer runs ahead of comparable sales, the greater the risk the appraisal does not follow.
Is an unconditional offer the safest offer for a seller?
Not necessarily. Waiving the financing condition only means the buyer gives up the right to walk away if financing fails; it does not mean the financing is in place. What a seller actually needs to confirm is how far the final approval has gone, where the down payment funds are, and who covers an appraisal gap.


