I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
Here is the plain conclusion first: there is no Ontario law and no single province-wide rule that says a roof is automatically uninsurable once it reaches a set age. Each insurer underwrites differently. What matters is getting three answers in writing while you are still in your conditional period: can this house be insured, on what basis would the roof be settled if it is damaged, and can the proof of insurance your lender needs be delivered on time? If any one of those fails, closing can stall.
1. Why insurers keep asking about the roof
When an insurer prices a home, it looks at the property's age, materials, condition and update history. The roof stands out because it drives the risk of leaks and storm loss. As a roof gets closer to the usual service life for its material, some insurers ask for photos, require an inspection first, add conditions, raise the premium, or limit the roof portion of the coverage. Those are individual underwriting decisions, not a line set by FSRA. In Ontario, FSRA regulates whether the people selling insurance are licensed and follow the rules; it cannot make any company sell you a policy.
So when you hear "past a certain age, nobody will insure it," ask a follow-up: which insurer, which policy, and which roofing material is that about? Some insurers tighten their approach on older roofs; others will still write the policy on different terms. Treating one company's practice as an industry-wide rule leads buyers to misprice a house — or to waive conditions they should have kept.
What a buyer can control is proving the age. Do not settle for "the roof is about ten years old." Useful records include the seller's disclosure, a contractor's invoice for a replacement, building permit records, and the home inspection report's description of the roof material and condition. If the age cannot be pinned down, your broker has to ask insurers on more conservative assumptions, and quotes come back slower and less certain.
2. Being insured is not the same as being paid for a new roof
This is where an old roof costs people money, and it is the question fewest buyers ask in advance: how a claim would be calculated.
Home policies commonly settle on one of two bases. As the Financial Consumer Agency of Canada explains it, actual cash value is what an item cost new, less depreciation; replacement value is what it costs to replace the item with one of similar quality. The same wind damage to the same roof can produce very different cheques depending on which basis the policy applies to the roof.
An illustrative example, with invented numbers only to show the arithmetic — not any insurer's quote: suppose a like-for-like roof replacement costs $18,000, but the policy settles this older roof at actual cash value and, after depreciation, allows $7,000, before your deductible. The gap is yours to fund. Under a replacement-cost basis, the handling is entirely different. So when you compare quotes, do not stop at the annual premium. Ask directly: is the roof settled at replacement cost or actual cash value? Is there a roof-specific limitation endorsement or a higher roof deductible?
Draw one more line clearly. The Insurance Bureau of Canada states the point repeatedly: damage from a sudden insured event — wind or hail, for example — and the interior water damage that follows are typically part of the standard policy discussion, but damage to the roof itself caused by wear and tear or poor maintenance is not covered. Insurance is not a maintenance plan. A roof that has simply reached the end of its life is the owner's expense, and no claim will convert it into a new one.
| Question to ask | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Can this house be bound now, and on what conditions? | Decides whether your lender gets its proof of insurance on time |
| Is the roof settled at replacement cost or actual cash value? | Decides how much of a claim shortfall you fund yourself |
| Is there a roof limitation tied to age or condition? | Some limits sit in endorsements, not on the quote summary |
| Can the policy start date match the closing date? | A misaligned start date leaves you without proof on closing day |
3. Insurance and the mortgage are two ends of the same rope
Home insurance is not legally mandatory in Ontario. If you buy with no mortgage and pay cash, no provincial law forces you to carry it. With a mortgage, the picture changes: lenders typically require active home insurance, want to see proof of it before advancing funds, and are named on the policy as loss payee. The reason is straightforward — the house is the lender's collateral, and the lender wants that collateral protected.
Connect that back to the roof and the chain is clear. If an insurer will not bind the house because of the roof's age or condition, or will only bind it after an inspection or a replacement, you do not have the proof your lender requires, the mortgage does not advance, and closing slips. The failure usually does not happen on closing day. It happens because the buyer asked about insurance too late — after conditions were waived and the deposit was committed, when there is no leverage left to deal with a roof problem.
So keep the order right: line the insurance up before you waive conditions, and get at least a clear written confirmation from your insurance broker stating whether the home can be insured, on what terms, and starting on what date. A verbal "should be fine" is not enough in closing week.
Three common misunderstandings
"Once a roof passes 20 years, no insurer in Ontario will touch it." There is no such universal rule. Different insurers, materials and roof conditions produce different answers. The right move is to put this specific house to two or three insurers and compare the actual terms.
"I bought a policy, so a damaged roof will be paid at the cost of a new one." Not necessarily. Check whether the roof is settled at replacement cost or actual cash value, and whether a roof limitation applies. The cheaper premium can hide the shortfall until claim time.
"The roof wore out gradually and started leaking, so insurance should handle it." It will not. Wear and aging are not insured events; insurance responds to sudden damage from covered perils. Budgeting a roof replacement around a future claim is budgeting around money that will not arrive.
If you are buying a house with an older roof, do these in order
- During the conditional period, ask the seller for the roof's installation or replacement year, and try to get an invoice, a permit or a disclosure document — not just a spoken estimate.
- Have your home inspector describe the roof material, approximate age, remaining condition and any signs of active leaking, with photos on file.
- Send the age and the inspection findings to your insurance broker early. Ask whether the home can be insured, whether the roof settles at replacement cost or actual cash value, and whether any limitation or extra deductible applies — and ask for the answer in writing.
- Ask your lender and your lawyer what form of insurance proof they need, the latest date they need it, and which date the policy must start on.
- If the answer is "inspection or repairs first," price that work and count the days immediately, then decide whether to negotiate price, negotiate repairs, or rely on your conditions. Do not waive first and solve it later.
- After closing, keep the roof invoice and the policy together. When you renew or switch insurers, proof of the roof's age is the most useful document you own.
Trust Professional, Diligent Work. I am Ming Ren. If a house you like has a roof age nobody can document, do not rush to waive conditions. Get the insurance answer in writing first, and we will work through the file item by item from there.
This article is general information only, not insurance or legal advice. Every insurer's underwriting standards and every policy's wording differ; whether your home can be insured and how a claim would be settled depend on the specific policy text and your broker's written confirmation.
Primary sources: Insurance Bureau of Canada home insurance and storm guidance (roof damage from wear and tear or poor maintenance is not covered; wind damage is typically covered, ibc.ca); FSRA Ontario Property and Other Insurance consumer pages (regulatory role; asking whether a policy pays replacement cost or actual cash value, fsrao.ca); Financial Consumer Agency of Canada home insurance guidance (definitions of actual cash value and replacement value; lender as loss payee, Canada.ca), consulted November 2026. The $18,000 and $7,000 figures are illustrative only, not a real quote.
Frequently asked questions
Once a roof passes 20 years, will no insurer in Ontario cover it?
There is no such universal rule. Different insurers, materials and roof conditions produce different answers, so put the specific house to two or three insurers and compare the actual terms.
If I bought a policy, will a damaged roof be paid at the cost of a new one?
Not necessarily. Check whether the roof is settled at replacement cost or actual cash value and whether a roof limitation applies; the cheaper premium can hide the shortfall until claim time.
Should insurance handle a roof that wore out gradually and started leaking?
No. Wear and aging are not insured events; insurance responds to sudden damage from covered perils, so budgeting a roof replacement around a future claim is budgeting around money that will not arrive.


