Ming RenBroker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage
☎ 647-779-9186

Buying a Home

The Mortgage Is Approved — but Will an Insurer Take This House? Ontario Red Flags to Check While You Still Have Conditions

By , Broker, RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc. (About Ming) · Published

Ming Ren · Broker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage

← All articles · Buying a Home · Category guide

I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.

The plain conclusion first: an approved mortgage does not mean the deal can close. When you buy with a mortgage, the lender typically requires valid home insurance to be in place at closing — the home is the collateral, and without insurance the lender generally will not advance the funds. Mortgage approval and insurance are two separate gates: the loan looks at you, the policy looks at the house. The safest move is to settle "can this house be insured?" while you still have conditions — not in the week before closing.

First: insurers underwrite the house, not you — and every insurer's answer can differ

An insurer prices the risk features of the property: its age, heating, wiring, plumbing and roof. One point matters more than any list: for every item below, insurers differ. One declines, another adds a surcharge, a third gives you time to fix the problem and then insures. So no single item means "definitely uninsurable" — but every item is worth one direct question to your insurance broker, before or during your conditions: "Will you insure this house, and on what terms?" Get the answer in writing.

On wiring, Ontario's Electrical Safety Authority (ESA) is worth hearing precisely: knob-and-tube wiring is not automatically unsafe, and Ontario's electrical code is not retroactive — existing wiring in good condition can remain. But the ESA also states plainly that many insurers will not provide or renew coverage on homes with it, and some require replacement first. In other words, what stops you is usually not the code. It is the underwriting.

Second: the three groups of red flags I see most often

Group Specific features What the primary sources say
Heating and oil tanks Underground or unused fuel oil tanks, older oil furnaces, wood stoves Fuel oil tanks are regulated by the TSSA: an unused underground tank must be removed, removal may only be done by a TSSA-registered contractor, the owner bears the costs of maintenance, removal and cleaning up contamination, and an environmental assessment is required on removal; wood stoves are commonly required to pass a WETT inspection before coverage (the exact requirement is the insurer's to set)
Electrical Knob-and-tube wiring, aluminum branch wiring, a 60-amp service The Insurance Bureau of Canada (IBC) notes knob-and-tube has no ground wire and its insulation deteriorates with age; the ESA says many insurers decline it or require remediation; aluminum wiring, common in homes built from the mid-1960s to the late 1970s, turns on the connections — a Licensed Electrical Contractor can address them with approved connectors (pigtailing), electrical work is filed with the ESA and a Certificate of Acceptance issues when it passes; insurers may require an older low-amperage service to be upgraded
Plumbing and roof Kitec plumbing, galvanized or lead pipes, a roof near the end of its life Kitec is an IPEX piping system sold between 1995 and 2007 whose fittings can deteriorate and leak; its class-action settlement (US$125 million) closed to claims on January 9, 2020, so replacement today is at the owner's cost; galvanized or lead piping and an end-of-life roof can likewise draw a replacement requirement or a higher premium

Use the table the right way: it is not a "decline list," it is a question list. The moment your home inspector writes down any of these, the next step is not panic — it is sending that page to your insurance broker and asking how they treat it.

Third: get the order right, and most red flags become a cost question, not a dead deal

A red flag does not automatically kill a purchase. Most of them come down to remediation cost: replacing Kitec, rewiring knob-and-tube, having a TSSA-registered contractor remove an unused oil tank, replacing a roof. What matters is pricing those costs while you can still negotiate — or still walk away under your conditions.

An illustrative example, invented by me and not a quote: suppose the inspection finds Kitec throughout, and a plumber quotes $9,000 (illustrative) to repipe the house. That $9,000 belongs on the negotiating table during your conditions — ask the seller to deal with it, price it into the deal, or do the full math and go firm only if the numbers still work. Discover after going firm that your insurer requires the repipe before it will cover the home, and the $9,000 is yours alone — possibly against a closing date that cannot move.

So the order is: note the features when you view the home, have the inspector confirm them, ask insurers and get remediation quotes during your conditions, and only then decide whether to firm up or walk away. Asking a second insurer is worth the phone call: the house one company declines, another may cover once the fix is done.

Three common misunderstandings

1. "The inspection passed, so insurance will be fine." Different test. An inspection reports the home's condition and safety; underwriting decides whether an insurer will take the risk, and on what terms. An inspector can call knob-and-tube "in serviceable condition" while an insurer still requires its replacement — as the ESA puts it, the wiring can be legal to keep and still be something many insurers will not cover.

2. "One insurer declined, so this house can't be bought." Not necessarily. Underwriting appetites vary widely: one declines, one surcharges, one allows a remediation period. But that only helps if you ask several insurers during your conditions. Ask them after you go firm and time is no longer on your side.

3. "This old stuff must be illegal — it all has to come out eventually." Not exactly. On the regulatory side, the ESA's position on both knob-and-tube and aluminum wiring is that they can remain if conditions are met, and the electrical code is not retroactive; on oil tanks, what the TSSA actually mandates is that unused underground tanks be removed and in-use tanks be maintained to code. The gate that decides whether your purchase closes is usually the insurer's, not the regulator's — ask the two questions separately.

If you are looking at an older home, I suggest this order

  1. On the viewing, note four things and photograph them: the heating system (any oil tank? a wood stove?), the panel's amperage, the plumbing material, and the roof's approximate age.
  2. Ask your home inspector to flag those four specifically: wiring type, the condition of aluminum connections, whether the plumbing is Kitec or galvanized, and whether any oil tank is in use or abandoned.
  3. During your conditions, send the relevant inspection pages to your insurance broker and ask three things — will you insure it, must anything be remediated first, and what is the premium — and ask for the answer in writing.
  4. Where there is a red flag, get remediation quotes before you negotiate: a Licensed Electrical Contractor for wiring (work filed with the ESA; keep the Certificate of Acceptance), a TSSA-registered contractor only for oil tanks, and the relevant trades for plumbing and roof.
  5. Decide — negotiate, ask the seller to remediate, or withdraw under your conditions — only once the insurance answer and the costs are on paper. Do not go firm before the insurance question is answered.

I am Ming Ren. There is nothing wrong with buying an older home with a red flag or two — what hurts is finding out at closing. Bring the paperwork together first, and we will go through it item by item.


This article is general information, not insurance, legal or engineering advice. Every insurer's underwriting policy differs, and no feature listed here means any particular insurer will decline or accept a home; confirm your situation with your insurance broker, an Ontario lawyer and licensed professionals before acting.

Primary sources: Insurance Bureau of Canada (IBC) consumer guidance on older homes and knob-and-tube wiring; Electrical Safety Authority (ESA) pages on knob-and-tube and aluminum wiring; TSSA fuel oil storage tank FAQ and O. Reg. 213/01 (Fuel Oil); former FSCO guidance, Insurance Coverage Issues Affecting Older Homes; official Kitec settlement materials (claims closed January 9, 2020) — all consulted November 2026. The $9,000 figure is illustrative, not a real quote.

Frequently asked questions

The inspection passed, so insurance will be fine?

Different test. An inspection reports the home's condition and safety; underwriting decides whether an insurer will take the risk, and on what terms. An inspector can call knob-and-tube "in serviceable condition" while an insurer still requires its replacement — as the ESA puts it, the wiring can be legal to keep and still be something many insurers will not cover.

One insurer declined, so this house can't be bought?

Not necessarily. Underwriting appetites vary widely: one declines, one surcharges, one allows a remediation period. But that only helps if you ask several insurers during your conditions. Ask them after you go firm and time is no longer on your side.

This old stuff must be illegal — it all has to come out eventually?

Not exactly. On the regulatory side, the ESA's position on both knob-and-tube and aluminum wiring is that they can remain if conditions are met, and the electrical code is not retroactive; on oil tanks, what the TSSA actually mandates is that unused underground tanks be removed and in-use tanks be maintained to code. The gate that decides whether your purchase closes is usually the insurer's, not the regulator's — ask the two questions separately.

This article in other languages: 中文فارسی

Want to talk about your home?

You can also call directly, or scan the code to add Ming on WeChat.

Ming’s WeChat QR code
Scan to add on WeChat

Community guides by city

All cities →
☎ Call MingFree Evaluation