I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
The plain version first: the biggest factor in rent versus buy is not the price level — it is how long you will stay. Stay briefly, and the transaction costs of buying never get recovered; stay long, and the math of owning slowly takes over. This article offers no market call. Prices and rents change every quarter. What does not change is the framework: three tests you can run with the actual price of a home you would buy and the actual rent of a home you would rent.
First, fix the comparison: mortgage payment versus rent is the wrong test
Most people compare the monthly mortgage payment directly with monthly rent. That comparison is flawed, because part of every mortgage payment is principal — money moved from one pocket to another, building your own equity. It is not spent. What is genuinely spent and never recovered is the interest, property tax, maintenance, insurance and, for condos, the monthly fees. The honest comparison is: the unrecoverable cost of owning, versus the rent on an equivalent home. All three tests below are built on that sentence.
Test 1: The 5% rule — a fast screen
The logic of this screening tool: owning carries an annual unrecoverable cost of roughly 5% of the home's value, assembled from about 1% property tax, about 1% maintenance, and about 3% cost of capital — the return your down payment and accumulated equity could earn if invested instead.
The math: price × 5% ÷ 12 = a monthly threshold. If an equivalent home rents for less than that threshold, renting wins on cash math; if it rents for more, buying starts to win.
Illustrative numbers, invented for the example: an $800,000 home gives $800,000 × 5% ÷ 12 ≈ $3,333 per month. If the equivalent rents for $2,800, renting is cheaper on pure cash terms; at $3,600, buying pulls ahead. The 5% is an assembly of estimates — if your tax bill or maintenance reality differs, adjust the inputs. The framework stays; the parameters are yours.
Test 2: The price-to-rent ratio — a second ruler
Simpler still: price ÷ annual rent. The commonly used guideposts: below 15 leans buy, 15 to 20 is a grey zone, above 20 leans rent.
Same illustration: an $800,000 home against annual rent of $2,800 × 12 = $33,600 gives a ratio of about 23.8 — on the renting side, agreeing with the 5% rule. When both rulers agree, your conclusion is sturdier. When they disagree, the property sits near the boundary, and the third test decides.
Test 3: The break-even horizon — how long will you actually stay?
Buying carries a one-time entry cost: land transfer tax, legal fees and other closing costs. In Toronto that cost is heavier than elsewhere in Ontario, because a Toronto buyer pays the provincial land transfer tax and a second, municipal land transfer tax (the City of Toronto publishes its current MLTT rates at toronto.ca). That entry cost — plus the cost of selling later — has to be recovered gradually out of the monthly difference between owning and renting.
So the third question is the honest one: how many years will you live in this home? If a move within three to five years is likely — a job change, a school change, a family change — entry and exit costs can consume any paper gain, and renting while your direction settles is usually the steadier path. If you can stay long, the entry cost is spread thin, principal accumulates, and ownership's long-run value shows up. My working rule: ask whether you can commit to five full years before asking whether to buy at all.
Three misunderstandings I hear most often
"Rent is just paying the landlord's mortgage — pure waste." Rent buys housing, flexibility and zero maintenance responsibility. Owning's unrecoverable costs — interest, tax, upkeep — are equally money out the door; they simply are not called rent.
"The mortgage payment is about the same as rent, so obviously buy." The payment includes principal. Compare unrecoverable cost against rent, and spread the entry cost over the years you realistically expect to stay, before concluding anything.
"Prices always go up, so buying early always wins." Whether prices rise is the market's business; no framework can promise it. The framework only tells you at what rent, and over what horizon, the mathematics of buying starts to work. A decision that requires prices to rise is a decision outsourced to luck.
Before deciding, run the numbers in this order
- Pick one home you would genuinely buy and one equivalent you would genuinely rent, and use their real price and real rent — not averages.
- Run the 5% rule for the threshold and the price-to-rent ratio as a cross-check; write down what each says.
- Cost the entry fully: provincial land transfer tax, Toronto's municipal land transfer tax where it applies, and legal fees — plus a rough estimate of future selling costs.
- Write down your expected years of stay, and honestly assess the chance of moving within three to five years — work, school, family, one by one.
- If the tests disagree, default to the more flexible option: renting "wrong" can be corrected by buying next year; buying "wrong" carries real exit costs.
Trust Professional, Diligent Work. I am Ming Ren. Bring me the real numbers on the home you are actually considering, and we will run all three tests on it, one at a time.
This article is general information only, not financial or legal advice. The percentages and ranges are a decision framework, not a market forecast; tax rates are those published by Ontario and the City of Toronto, and should be rechecked at the time you decide.
Primary sources: City of Toronto Municipal Land Transfer Tax pages (toronto.ca) and Ontario land transfer tax guidance (ontario.ca), consulted November 2026. The $800,000 price and $2,800 rent are illustrative only, not market data.
Frequently asked questions
Is rent just paying the landlord's mortgage and pure waste?
No. Rent buys housing, flexibility and zero maintenance responsibility, while owning's unrecoverable costs — interest, tax and upkeep — are equally money out the door.
If the mortgage payment is about the same as rent, should I obviously buy?
Not on that comparison alone. The payment includes principal; compare unrecoverable cost against rent and spread the entry cost over the years you realistically expect to stay.
Do prices always go up, so buying early always wins?
No framework can promise price growth. The framework only tells you at what rent, and over what horizon, the mathematics of buying starts to work.


