I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
Here is the plain conclusion first: neither buying nor renting is always right. If you will stay in one place for a long time and your work and family life are settled, the case for buying gets stronger the longer you stay. If you may change cities or jobs within three to five years, or your down payment is not ready yet, renting is not a fallback — it is often the sensible choice. What you should compare is not the purchase price against the rent. It is three things: how long you will stay, what each option truly costs per month, and who is responsible when something goes wrong.
1. First, decide how long you will stay
Buying carries a cost many people leave out of the math: getting in and out costs money. On the way in there is land transfer tax, legal fees, an appraisal and inspection. On the way out there are selling costs such as commission and legal fees, and sometimes a penalty for breaking a mortgage early. None of this is small, and all of it is one-time money.
That means the shorter you stay, the more those one-time costs weigh on each month. Buy, then sell two years later because of a job change, and the price growth may not even cover the cost of entering and exiting. Stay ten years instead, and those same costs are spread thin, while the part of each payment that pays down principal has time to build real equity.
Renting is the opposite: moving means ending a tenancy and finding a new home, not selling one first. So the first question is not "can I afford to buy?" It is "how many years am I realistically likely to live here?" When the answer is fuzzy, rent first and buy once life settles. There is no shame in that.
One caution: the "buying wins after five years" line you see online is only a rough rule of thumb, not a promise. Your taxes, rate, and buy and sell prices are your own. What actually decides the question is your entry and exit costs spread over the years you really stay.
2. Compare monthly costs on a full-cost basis — not mortgage payment versus rent
The most common mistake is comparing a mortgage payment directly to rent. A mortgage payment is only part of an owner's monthly cost; rent is nearly all of a renter's. Put both sides in one table, on the same basis:
| Monthly item | Buying (illustrative figures) | Renting (illustrative figures) |
|---|---|---|
| Mortgage payment / rent | $2,900 | $2,400 |
| Property tax | $380 | — |
| Home insurance / tenant insurance | $150 | $40 |
| Condo fees (condos only) | $450 | — |
| Maintenance reserve | $300 | — |
| Total monthly cash out | $4,180 | $2,440 |
Every figure above is an illustrative number I made up to show the method — not a quote for any real property. Replace them with your own numbers. The structure, though, is real: owners spend a good deal beyond the mortgage payment.
One more distinction matters. Part of a mortgage payment is principal, and principal is not money spent — it is equity stored in the home. If about $900 of that $2,900 payment is principal, the amount actually consumed each month is roughly $4,180 minus $900, about $3,280. That is the number to compare with renting — not $4,180, and not $2,900.
And be fair in the other direction too: the down payment and monthly difference a renter keeps can be saved and invested, and over time that is not zero. Run both sides in full, not just the half that supports the answer you already like.
3. Think through flexibility — and who fixes what
Beyond money, two things carry real weight, and they differ by person.
The first is flexibility. A lease usually runs in one-year terms and, in Ontario, generally continues month to month after the initial term; moving means giving proper notice. An owner who wants to move has to sell first, and in a slow market that can take months. If your job is unsettled, a transfer is possible, or your children's schooling is not yet decided, flexibility is worth real money.
The second is control. In your own home, how you renovate, whether you keep a pet, whether you install a charger — those are basically your calls. In a rental, most of that needs the landlord's agreement first. For some people that control is the biggest reason to buy. It does not show up in any table, but you live with it every day. Only you can decide how much it weighs.
The third is repair responsibility. In Ontario, the big-ticket upkeep of a rental home — structure, heating, plumbing and the like — is by law the landlord's responsibility; the tenant's job is to report problems promptly and keep the home reasonably clean. An owner carries all of it personally: a furnace, a leaking pipe, a roof — each can run into the thousands, and none of them sends notice first. That is why a maintenance reserve line belongs in every buying budget, like the one in the table above. A plan without it is a plan that breaks at the first furnace failure.
Three common misunderstandings
1. "Rent is money thrown away; a mortgage payment at least pays yourself." Only half true. The interest, property tax, insurance, condo fees and repairs inside an owner's costs are spent and gone, just like rent — they build no equity. Only the principal portion is saved. Over a short stay, the spent portion can exceed what rent would have cost.
2. "The mortgage payment is about what I pay in rent, so I should buy." A mortgage payment is only part of ownership. Add tax, insurance, condo fees and maintenance, and the monthly cash out is often far above the number you started with. Do the full-cost math first, then conclude.
3. "Buying always builds wealth; renters never save." Prices rise and fall, and nobody can promise that your buy and sell years will be rising ones. Whether a renter saves depends on whether the down payment and the monthly difference actually get saved — not on the label "rent" or "buy."
If you are stuck on this decision, work through it in this order
- Write down how many years you are realistically likely to stay in this city and this neighbourhood. If it is under three to five years, cost out the renting option seriously before you start viewing homes.
- Redo the table above with your own numbers: pick a home you would genuinely buy and cost it in full; pick a home you would genuinely rent and cost the rent plus insurance. Use real listings, not imagined figures.
- Count the down payment twice: once for whether you have it, and once for what is left after the down payment and closing costs. If nothing remains for emergencies, do not buy yet.
- Put a maintenance reserve in the budget, even for a new home. A buying plan without one cannot survive its first furnace breakdown.
- If the numbers come out close, choose by life, not by spreadsheet: buy for stability and control over your space; rent to keep your next few years open. When the math is close, lifestyle decides — and that is a legitimate answer.
老老实实做人,踏踏实实做事 — work honestly, and do solid work. I am Ming Ren. If you are stuck between buying and renting, bring me your numbers and how long you plan to stay, and we will go through it table by table before anyone draws a conclusion.
This article is general information only, not legal, financial or mortgage advice. Rights and obligations in a tenancy are governed by Ontario's Residential Tenancies Act, 2006 and the Standard Form of Lease; mortgage figures vary by borrower. Consult a licensed Ontario lawyer and a mortgage professional before signing.
Primary sources: Financial Consumer Agency of Canada (FCAC) public guidance on comparing the costs of renting and buying; CMHC public guidance on homebuying costs; Ontario Residential Tenancies Act, 2006 and the Ontario Standard Form of Lease (landlord and tenant maintenance responsibilities). All dollar figures in the table are illustrative, not quotes for any real property.
Frequently asked questions
Is rent money thrown away, while a mortgage payment at least pays yourself?
Only half true. The interest, property tax, insurance, condo fees and repairs inside an owner's costs are spent and gone, just like rent — they build no equity. Only the principal portion is saved, and over a short stay the spent portion can exceed what rent would have cost.
The mortgage payment is about what I pay in rent, so should I buy?
A mortgage payment is only part of ownership. Add tax, insurance, condo fees and maintenance, and the monthly cash out is often far above the number you started with. Do the full-cost math first, then conclude.
Does buying always build wealth while renters never save?
Prices rise and fall, and nobody can promise that your buy and sell years will be rising ones. Whether a renter saves depends on whether the down payment and the monthly difference actually get saved — not on the label rent or buy.


