Ming RenBroker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage
☎ 647-779-9186

Buying a Home

Rent or Buy in Toronto? Run Both Sides of the Ledger Honestly Before You Decide

By , Broker, RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc. (About Ming) · Published

Ming Ren · Broker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage

← All articles · Buying a Home · Category guide

I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.

The plain conclusion first: neither renting nor buying is automatically the smarter move. What actually hurts people is usually not picking the wrong side — it is doing the math wrong, and the most common error is comparing the mortgage payment directly with the rent. Part of every mortgage payment is principal, which is saving, not spending. But the true cost of owning is also more than the payment: interest, property tax, maintenance, insurance, and the return your down payment could have earned if it were not tied up in the house. Count only the money you never get back, on both sides, then spread the one-time costs over the years you actually plan to stay — that is when this decision becomes clear.

Three things follow: how to list the real cost of renting, how to list the real cost of owning, and the variable that actually decides the answer.

1. Renting: the real ledger is more than the rent

The renting side is simpler, but it is not a single number:

  • The rent itself — the largest item on this side, and pure expense.
  • Tenant insurance — a few dozen dollars a month that many people leave out of the comparison entirely.
  • What the lease does not include — parking, storage, and whichever utilities the landlord does not cover, added line by line from your actual lease.
  • Moving costs — flexibility is not free. Every move costs money: movers, deposit timing, and the overlap between the old rent and the new.

Ontario adds one renting-specific variable: whether your unit's rent increases are protected by the provincial guideline. Ontario's rent increase guideline for 2026 is 2.1%, and it applies to most rental homes covered by the Residential Tenancies Act. But units first occupied after November 15, 2018 are exempt from the guideline — on renewal, the landlord can price to the market. So a long-term renting projection cannot assume rent always rises gently. Find out which class your unit falls into first, then decide what rent growth to build into your numbers.

Also give renting credit for what it buys: no repair bills, no being tied to one property, and the ability to move when work or family changes. Those are not numbers, but they are real value — do not enter them as zero.

2. Owning: the mortgage payment is only part of the bill

Start by splitting the payment. A mortgage payment is interest plus principal: the interest is a pure cost you never get back; the principal builds equity in your own name and is not a cost. Treating the whole payment as a cost overstates owning; looking only at the payment understates it. Both errors are common.

The owner's full list of unrecoverable money is: mortgage interest, property tax, a maintenance and repair reserve, home insurance (plus condo fees on a condominium), and the opportunity cost of the down payment and closing costs — money that, had you not bought, could have been invested. The Financial Consumer Agency of Canada (FCAC) puts closing costs at 1.5% to 4% of the purchase price, and that is before the cost of selling later.

Here is a set of invented numbers, mine, purely to show the method — not market data and not a forecast:

Item (illustrative numbers only) Approximate monthly amount
Assumed price $800,000; 20% down = $160,000; mortgage $640,000 at an assumed 4.5%, 25-year amortization; payment about $3,558 —
Of which: interest portion in year one (pure cost) about $2,380
Of which: principal portion in year one (goes into your own equity — not a cost) about $1,178
Property tax $450
Maintenance reserve $400
Home insurance $120
Opportunity cost on about $180,000 of down payment plus closing costs (at an assumed 4% annual return) $600
Total unrecoverable cost of owning, per month about $3,950
For comparison: illustrative rent of $2,800 on a similar home, plus $40 tenant insurance about $2,840

On these illustrative numbers, looking only at year-one pure cost, renting comes out about $1,100 a month cheaper. That is not the conclusion — because this table deliberately leaves out the two biggest variables: what prices do, and how long you stay. That is the third point.

3. What actually decides it: how long you stay, and what prices do

Buying carries an entry and exit toll that renting does not: land transfer tax on the way in (in Toronto, the provincial and municipal taxes stack), legal and other closing costs, and selling costs — commission and legal fees — on the way out. Still on illustrative figures: roughly 6% to 8% of the price for both ends combined, or about $50,000 to $65,000 on an $800,000 home. Spread over three years, that is more than $1,500 a month, enough to flip the table above completely. Spread over ten years, it is about $450 a month — a very different weight. Same home, same person: stay three years and stay ten years can produce opposite answers. That is not a matter of opinion; it is division.

Appreciation is the second variable, and it can only be an assumption, never a promise. My practice is to run the same ledger three times, at 0%, 2% and 4% annual appreciation. If buying does not lose under all three scenarios, the decision is solid. If it only wins in the 4% column, that is not a calculation — that is a bet.

Finally, the affordability guardrails. The FCAC's reference points: on the renting side, keep rent plus household costs at or under about 35% of gross income; on the buying side, keep housing costs (mortgage, property tax, heat) at about 39% of gross income, and total debt payments at or under 44%. Whichever plan bursts its line first is out, no matter how good it looks on paper — a plan that breaks your monthly cash flow is not a plan. And one warning in the other direction: renting's paper advantage only survives if you actually save or invest the monthly difference. Spend it, and ten years later neither side has anything to show.

Three misunderstandings I hear most often

"Rent is money thrown away; a mortgage payment is money saved." Only half true. The interest portion of a payment is gone for good, and in the early years interest is the larger part. Rent, meanwhile, buys flexibility and freedom from repair bills, which are real value. Both sides have money you never get back; the question is which side has less of it, and by how much.

"The mortgage payment is about the same as rent, so I should buy." Beyond the payment sit property tax, maintenance, insurance, condo fees where they apply, and the one-time costs at both ends. Comparing payment to rent leaves out a large slice of the owner's ledger — and that kind of "about the same" is the kind people regret after closing.

"Prices always rise in the long run, so buying early always wins." Appreciation is an assumption, not a commitment. Stay a short time and the entry and exit costs eat the gain first, while the down payment's opportunity cost keeps accruing on the other side. If a purchase only works when prices rise, ask yourself first: can I carry it if prices are flat, or down, for three to five years?

If you are going back and forth, do these six things in order

  1. Fix the time horizon first. In the next five years, are work, family or city likely to change? If you probably will not stay five years, run the numbers as a renter first, unless they are overwhelmingly one-sided.
  2. Build an "unrecoverable money" list for each side, with your own real figures: rent, insurance and parking against interest, property tax, a maintenance reserve, insurance and condo fees. Leave no line blank.
  3. List buying's one-time costs separately: closing costs budgeted at 1.5% to 4% of the price, plus the future cost of selling, spread over the number of years you expect to stay.
  4. Run appreciation at 0%, 2% and 4%. Decide based on whether you can live with the worst of the three results.
  5. Check the guardrails: 35% on the renting side, 39% and 44% on the buying side, calculated on your household's actual gross income — not on a raise you are hoping for.
  6. Check whether your current rental is covered by the rent increase guideline (November 15, 2018 is the dividing line). If it is exempt, leave real room for market-level rent increases in your projection.

Trust Professional, Diligent Work. I am Ming Ren. If you are weighing renting against buying, bring the real numbers from both sides of your life and we will go through them, one table at a time — by the end, the answer is usually visible in your own figures.


This article is general information only, not financial, tax or legal advice. Interest rates, taxes and your personal income situation can change the conclusion. Before signing anything, consult your mortgage broker, accountant or lawyer.

Primary sources: Financial Consumer Agency of Canada (FCAC), "Renting vs. buying a home" and its home-buying cost guidance (Canada.ca, consulted November 2026); Ontario's 2026 rent increase guideline of 2.1% and its scope of application (Ontario.ca, consulted November 2026). The $800,000 price, $2,800 rent, 4.5% rate and all other figures in the worked example are numbers I invented for illustration — not market data and not a forecast.

Frequently asked questions

Is rent money thrown away while a mortgage payment is money saved?

Only half true. The interest portion of a payment is gone for good, and in the early years interest is the larger part, while rent buys flexibility and freedom from repair bills.

The mortgage payment is about the same as rent, so should I buy?

Beyond the payment sit property tax, maintenance, insurance, condo fees and one-time costs at both ends; comparing payment to rent leaves out a large slice of the owner's ledger.

Prices always rise in the long run, so does buying early always win?

Appreciation is an assumption, not a commitment; stay a short time and entry and exit costs eat the gain first.

This article in other languages: 中文فارسی

Want to talk about your home?

You can also call directly, or scan the code to add Ming on WeChat.

Ming’s WeChat QR code
Scan to add on WeChat

Community guides by city

All cities →
☎ Call MingFree Evaluation