I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
Here is the plain conclusion first: giving a discount is not illegal — the shape of the discount is what matters. In Ontario, the rent written in the lease and the lawful rent the law recognizes are two different numbers. If a discount is built in one of the shapes the law sets aside, the tenant pays less for a while and the lawful rent does not move. If the shape is wrong, the lawful rent is recalculated by formula, the result can sit below the figure in your lease, and every future increase is built on that lower number. This article covers three things: which discounts leave lawful rent alone, how the recalculation works when a discount misses, and what a landlord can and cannot do when a discount ends.
First: the money actually paid is not the lawful rent
Section 111(1) of the Residential Tenancies Act, 2006 (the RTA) draws a hard line: a landlord shall not charge rent greater than the lawful rent permitted under that Part. For a new tenant, section 113 says the lawful rent for the first rental period is the rent first charged — but that section opens with "Subject to section 111," so the discount analysis comes first.
The discounted rent is what the tenant actually hands over during the discount period. The lawful rent is the ceiling the law allows you to charge, and the base on which later increases are calculated. The two can differ: a tenant paying less this month does not mean the lawful rent dropped. Whether the two stay separate depends on whether the discount fits one of the shapes in the next section.
Second: three compliant discount shapes leave lawful rent untouched
Section 111(2) and (2.1), together with sections 10 and 11 of O. Reg. 516/06, set out three routes. Fit any one of them and the lawful rent is not affected by the discount:
- Prompt-payment discount: up to 2% of the rent otherwise lawfully chargeable, for paying on or before the due date. There is only one prescribed condition: the discount must be provided for in a written or oral agreement (O. Reg. 516/06, s.10). The two kinds of discount can also be combined — section 111(2.2) confirms that giving both a prompt-payment discount and a rent-free type discount still leaves lawful rent unaffected.
- Rent-free periods: up to three months' rent in any 12-month period, given as rent-free periods. The conditions in O. Reg. 516/06, s.10 are strict: a written agreement; where rent is monthly, a discount of one month or less must be taken entirely within one rental period, a discount of more than one and up to two months must be taken as one full month in one rental period plus the balance in one other, and a discount of more than two and up to three months follows the same pattern with two full months plus the balance; where rent is daily or weekly, the free periods must run in blocks of at least one week.
- Other prescribed discounts: section 11 of O. Reg. 516/06 prescribes two written-agreement discounts — one where the total given in the first eight months of the 12-month period does not exceed one month's rent, and one where the 12-month total does not exceed two months' rent, the first seven months total no more than one month, and any discount in the last five months falls in only one of those months and does not exceed one month's rent. The "12-month period" generally means the 12 months following the start of the tenancy, or the 12 months following a rent increase.
An illustrative example, with numbers I invented for this article and no real tenancy behind them: lawful rent is $2,400 a month, and the written agreement makes the first month rent-free. The tenant pays $2,400 less that year, but the lawful rent stays at $2,400 throughout. When the free month ends, the tenant pays $2,400 — that is not a rent increase; it is the discount ending as agreed.
Third: a discount in the wrong shape is recalculated, and the old price does not come back
If a discount fits none of the routes, section 111(3) sends it to the formula in section 12 of O. Reg. 516/06: add up the rent actually charged or to be charged across the 12-month period, add back the "largest eligible discount," and divide by the number of rental periods in that period. Two details do the damage. First, if the discount is not in a written agreement, the largest eligible discount is only the largest discount given in a single rental period — an oral promise of free rent protects almost nothing. Second, if a prompt-payment discount exceeds 2%, the lawful rent is calculated by dividing the discounted rent by 0.98.
Same invented figures, different shape: the unit is $2,400 a month, and the landlord verbally promises $300 off every month for 12 months. A flat monthly reduction is not a rent-free period and does not match the timing pattern in section 11, so it is recalculated: $25,200 actually charged over the year, plus the largest eligible discount of $300, divided by 12, gives a lawful rent of about $2,125. When the discount period ends, the landlord cannot go back to charging $2,400 — that would exceed the lawful rent. From there, increases can only follow sections 110, 119 and 120: at least 12 months between increases, generally no more than the year's guideline, and at least 90 days' written notice under section 116.
One last line that cannot be contracted around: section 4 of the RTA makes a provision in a tenancy agreement void if it is inconsistent with the Act or the regulations. A side agreement in which the tenant "agrees" that rent returns to the old price after the discount does not rescue a discount built in the wrong shape. In the other direction, a tenant who has been charged more than the lawful rent can apply to the Landlord and Tenant Board under section 135 for a rebate, generally within one year; and under section 136, rent that has been charged for a year without a timely application raising its lawfulness is deemed lawful. Time is a hard constraint on both sides.
Three common misunderstandings
Misunderstanding one: "The lease says $2,400, so the lawful rent is $2,400." Not necessarily. A new tenancy's lawful rent is subject to section 111, and where a discount misses the permitted shapes, the number produced by the formula in O. Reg. 516/06, s.12 is the one that counts.
Misunderstanding two: "One free month and a small cut every month work out the same." They do not. A rent-free period is a shape the law specifically protects, provided it is written and taken in whole blocks inside the required rental periods. A flat monthly cut usually matches no route at all, and ends up averaged into the lawful rent by the formula.
Misunderstanding three: "When the discount expires, the rent automatically goes back to the advertised price." Only for a compliant discount: the lawful rent never changed, so charging it in full when the discount ends is straightforward. Where the discount did not comply, the lawful rent has already been recalculated downward, and returning to the old price is overcharging — money a tenant can apply to get back.
If you are about to offer a discount, I suggest this order
- Choose the shape before the amount: start with a rent-free period, a prompt-payment discount of 2% or less, or a discount prescribed by O. Reg. 516/06, s.11 — fit the shape first, then negotiate how much to give.
- Put every discount other than a prompt-payment discount in a written agreement, naming which months, how much in each block, and in which rental period each block falls. Do not write only "one year of incentives."
- Lay the 12 months out month by month in a table and check it against sections 10 and 11: is the total within three months, is each free block whole, does the distribution in the last five months comply?
- If a non-compliant discount has already been given, run the section 12 calculation yourself first, and base the next increase on the recalculated figure, not on the face value in the lease.
- Before a discount ends, confirm which situation you are in: a compliant discount simply ends and the lawful rent is charged; a non-compliant one calls for advice from an Ontario lawyer or licensed paralegal before any increase notice is drafted.
- Keep every agreement, receipt and notice at least until a year after the tenant moves out — the one-year limits in sections 135 and 136 turn on those dates and documents.
I am Ming Ren. Before you offer a discount, get the shape right — then we can go through the sections and the numbers one by one.
This article is general information, not legal advice. Whether a particular unit is subject to the rent guideline, and how an individual discount is calculated, can change the conclusion. Consult an Ontario lawyer before acting.
Primary sources: Residential Tenancies Act, 2006, S.O. 2006, c.17, ss.4, 110, 111, 113, 116, 119, 120, 135, 136; O. Reg. 516/06, ss.10–12 (Ontario e-Laws, consulted November 2026). The $2,400, $300 and $2,125 figures are illustrative only, not a real tenancy.
Frequently asked questions
The lease says $2,400 — is the lawful rent $2,400?
Not necessarily. A new tenancy's lawful rent is subject to section 111, and where a discount misses the permitted shapes, the number produced by the formula in O. Reg. 516/06, s.12 is the one that counts.
Do one free month and a small cut every month work out the same?
They do not. A rent-free period is a shape the law specifically protects, provided it is written and taken in whole blocks inside the required rental periods. A flat monthly cut usually matches no route at all, and ends up averaged into the lawful rent by the formula.
When the discount expires, does the rent automatically go back to the advertised price?
Only for a compliant discount: the lawful rent never changed, so charging it in full when the discount ends is straightforward. Where the discount did not comply, the lawful rent has already been recalculated downward, and returning to the old price is overcharging — money a tenant can apply to get back.


