I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
The plain conclusion first: rent is not what you would like to collect. It is what the market most recently actually paid. I price every rental the same way — build the baseline from units that have already leased, adjust the differences one item at a time, then work out what one vacant week costs you, and let that number decide how long you can afford to wait. Pricing high and waiting it out is not patience; it is money leaving by the week. Pricing low just to move fast is not harmless either, because you cannot climb back quickly. Both mistakes are expensive, just in different directions.
You will find no market averages in this article, because an average cannot price your specific unit. What follows is method only — take it and put your own unit's numbers into it.
Step one: the baseline comes from leased units, not active listings
Start with comparables, and only with units that have actually leased.
The reason is simple: a unit that is still sitting on the market is, by definition, a unit the market has not accepted at that price. An active listing tells you what another landlord hopes to get. A leased comparable tells you what a tenant actually paid. Price off the asking prices around you and you are pricing off a stack of unproven wishes — and the longer those units have sat there, the more likely it is that their prices are the problem.
When I pull comparables, this is how I screen them:
- Range: Same building first, then the same neighbourhood within walking distance. Keep the time window as recent as you can, and widen it step by step only if there are not enough leased records.
- Match the layout: Bedrooms, bathrooms and size have to line up. Drop the ones that do not. Never price a one-bedroom off two-bedroom results.
- Read three numbers: The rent actually achieved, how many days it took to lease (days on market), and the start date. Speed matters as much as price — a unit that leased in three days and a unit that leased after two months are telling you very different things about where the market really is.
What survives that screen is a small set of genuinely comparable leases. Your pricing range comes from there, not from a feeling.
Step two: adjust the differences, then do the vacancy math
A comparable is not your unit, so adjust the differences one at a time. The usual items are: floor and view, exposure and light, whether parking is included, whether utilities and internet are in the rent, furnished or not, renovated or dated, pets permitted or not, and whether the start date lines up with when tenants are looking. For each difference, add or subtract roughly what a tenant would pay for it, and you end up with a defensible range for your unit — instead of copying someone else's number.
Then do the calculation many landlords never do: what does one vacant week cost you?
Add up the unit's monthly mortgage payment, property tax, condo fee and insurance, and divide by four. That is your carrying cost for each empty week. Here is an example I invented to show the arithmetic — these are not figures from any real property:
| Illustrative item | Illustrative figure |
|---|---|
| Total monthly carrying cost (mortgage + tax + condo fee + insurance) | $3,200 / month |
| Cost of one vacant week (÷ 4) | About $800 / week |
| Holding out for $60 more per month, at the cost of 3 extra vacant weeks | About $2,400 lost |
| How long the extra $60 a month takes to earn that back | 40 months |
That table is where pricing discipline comes from. Giving up two or three weeks of vacancy to gain a few dozen dollars a month usually takes years to recover — and only if the tenant stays the whole time. So set your review point before you list: if showings and qualified applications in the first stretch are clearly below what the comparables led you to expect, revisit the price on the day you chose in advance, not in week three or four. And if you do adjust, adjust by an amount that changes the conversation; a token cut just stretches the vacancy out. The reverse also holds: if several qualified groups compete in the first few days, you priced under the market. Note it for the next turnover — but do not raise the price mid-stream on the people already applying. Your reputation is worth more than the difference.
Step three: the starting rent follows the tenant, so price with the next few years in view
Ontario's rules make the starting rent more than a one-time decision. Under section 113 of the Residential Tenancies Act, 2006, the lawful rent for a new tenant is the rent first charged under the new tenancy — whatever landlord and tenant agree at the start. But once that tenant is in, section 120 generally caps increases at the province's annual guideline unless the Landlord and Tenant Board approves more or another provision of the Act applies, and sections 116 and 119 add two more rules: at least 90 days' written notice, and no more than one increase in any 12 months. Newer units first occupied after November 15, 2018 are exempt from the guideline cap, though the notice and frequency rules still apply — check your own unit before assuming either way.
What that means for pricing is direct. Price well under the market today just to fill the unit fast, and that low base follows this tenant, climbing only slowly, year after year. Price well over the market, and you pay for it immediately, in vacancy billed by the week. The target is neither the highest number nor the fastest lease — it is the narrow band where the unit leases reasonably quickly without locking in a long-term loss. One question does most of the work: if this tenant stays three years and the rent can only rise by the guideline, does this starting rent still carry the property? If it does not, either the price is wrong or the property's carrying costs are the real problem — and those are two different conversations.
Three misunderstandings I hear most often
"The unit next door is asking this much, so I will ask the same." The unit next door is still available, which means the market has not accepted its price yet. Asking prices are wishes; leased prices are the market. Build your baseline on wishes and you will sit vacant alongside them.
"I will price it high and just wait — the right tenant will come." Waiting is not free. The mortgage, tax and condo fee do not pause because the unit is empty. Once you have your vacant-week cost written down, you know exactly what "just waiting" is charging you.
"I will price it low to fill it fast, then raise it back up later." You cannot raise it back quickly. Once a tenant is in, increases are governed by the guideline, the 90-day notice rule and the once-every-12-months rule. A low starting base can take years to climb back to market. Get the first number wrong and every year after it is catch-up.
If your unit is going on the market this week, do these five things in order
- Pull the leased comparables in the same building or neighbourhood first — leased only — and note both the rent achieved and how many days each one took.
- List every difference between your unit and those comparables — parking, utilities included or not, furniture, renovation, floor and view — and adjust item by item into your own range.
- Calculate your carrying cost for one vacant week and write it on the pricing sheet. Use it as the yardstick for the asking price and for any later decision about adjusting.
- Decide your review point before you list: if showings and qualified applications fall short, on which day will you revisit the price, and by roughly how much? Decide now, not under pressure later.
- Look three years ahead before you post: confirm the starting rent still carries the property when increases are limited to the guideline — then list it.
Trust Professional, Diligent Work. I am Ming Ren. If you are working through a rental pricing question, bring the leased comparables and your carrying-cost numbers, and we will go through it item by item.
This article is general information only, not legal advice. Whether the guideline applies to a given unit can depend on when it was first occupied and other facts. Check the official sources or consult an Ontario lawyer before acting.
Primary sources: Residential Tenancies Act, 2006, ss.113, 116, 119, 120 (Ontario e-Laws, consulted November 2026); Government of Ontario, "Residential rent increases." The $3,200, $800 and $60 figures are illustrative only, not a real case.
Frequently asked questions
The unit next door is asking this much, so should I ask the same?
The unit next door is still available, which means the market has not accepted its price yet. Asking prices are wishes; leased prices are the market. Build your baseline on wishes and you will sit vacant alongside them.
Can I price it high and just wait — the right tenant will come?
Waiting is not free. The mortgage, tax and condo fee do not pause because the unit is empty. Once you have your vacant-week cost written down, you know exactly what just waiting is charging you.
Can I price it low to fill it fast, then raise it back up later?
You cannot raise it back quickly. Once a tenant is in, increases are governed by the guideline, the 90-day notice rule and the once-every-12-months rule; a low starting base can take years to climb back to market.


