I'm Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
Here is the short answer first: resale homes in Ontario are governed by caveat emptor — "buyer beware." Most problems you discover after closing are yours to fix and yours to pay for. You can only go back to the seller in a few situations: the seller knew about a serious hidden defect and stayed silent or actively covered it up; the seller wrote something untrue in the contract or in the Seller Property Information Statement (SPIS); or the problem falls within something the seller actually promised in the deal. So when a problem shows up, don't start arguing and don't start spending on major repairs. First, classify the problem. Then pull out the paperwork.
First: Sort the Problem Into "Visible" or "Hidden"
Ontario practice divides defects into two categories, and the category largely decides whether you have a case.
| Category | What it means | Seller's responsibility |
|---|---|---|
| Patent defect | A problem an ordinary buyer would find on a normal viewing and inspection — a cracked wall, obviously damaged flooring | The seller generally has no duty to point it out; the risk sits with the buyer |
| Latent defect | A serious problem a normal viewing cannot reveal, hidden inside walls or underground — long-term water penetration rotting the structure, concealed mould | If the seller knew about it, it must be disclosed; knowing and concealing it can create liability |
The difference matters: the more hidden the problem, the more it may be the seller's concern; the more it was sitting in plain sight, the harder it is to blame the seller. An invented example, with illustrative numbers only: after closing, a buyer finds water coming through a basement corner. Opening the wall reveals framing that has been rotting for years, and a repair quote of $18,000 (illustrative figure). If the evidence shows the seller lived with that leak for years and, right before listing, covered the entire wall with new cabinets, that starts to look like a known latent defect that was concealed. If, on the other hand, the wall already showed obvious water staining when the buyer viewed the home and the buyer didn't pay attention, that is most likely a patent defect — and the buyer's cost.
Second: Go Through the Paperwork and See What the Seller Actually Promised
Once you've classified the problem, pull out the full transaction file and read it piece by piece.
Start with the Agreement of Purchase and Sale (APS) and its schedules. Look for undertakings by the seller — for example, wording that included systems and equipment will be in good working order on completion. If the furnace was already dead on closing day and the contract contains that kind of promise, your claim has somewhere to stand. Next, the SPIS. It is not mandatory in Ontario — a seller may decline to complete one — but if the seller did complete and sign it, the answers carry weight: the buyer relied on them in deciding to buy, and answers that clearly don't match the facts can amount to misrepresentation. Finally, reconstruct what happened at viewings and at closing: anything the seller or their agent said, any unusual coverings or fresh paint, anything neighbours know about the home's history. Evidence that the seller knew all along — old repair invoices, insurance claim records, what neighbours say, photos from before and after a cover-up — often matters more than how serious the problem is, because disputes usually turn not on "is there a problem" but on "did the seller know."
Third: Resale and New Builds Are Two Different Roads
Everything above concerns resale homes. A newly built home works differently: Ontario's statutory new home warranty program is administered by Tarion, the builder provides the warranty, and coverage and time limits follow the warranty program's rules. If you find construction defects after moving into a new build, the first step is to file under the Tarion process — not to apply the resale "buyer beware" logic.
Timing matters too. A problem found and documented in the first days or weeks after closing carries very different weight from one that surfaces a year or two later — the longer the gap, the easier it is for a seller to argue the problem arose after closing. You may waive the inspection condition, but don't skip your pre-closing visits: photograph anything unusual on the spot and raise it on the spot, because that record becomes an anchor on the timeline.
For a resale home, the practical routes are these: have a lawyer assess whether the evidence is strong enough, then decide between negotiating through a lawyer's letter and starting a legal claim. Smaller claims may fit a lower-cost route such as Small Claims Court; larger, evidence-heavy disputes require an honest calculation of whether the time and cost of litigation are worth it. Two more practical notes: home insurance generally covers sudden, accidental losses — not problems that already existed before you bought or normal wear and tear; and title insurance protects against title-related risks, not the physical condition of the house. Neither policy should be expected to pay for a problem the seller hid.
Common Misunderstandings
Misunderstanding 1: "I waived the inspection condition, so I gave up all my rights." No. Waiving the condition gives up your chance to walk away if an inspection turns something up. It does not give the seller permission to lie or to deliberately conceal a known latent defect. Liability for fraud and misrepresentation does not disappear just because you didn't inspect.
Misunderstanding 2: "The seller said nothing, so the seller can't be responsible." Not necessarily. For a known latent defect that makes a home dangerous or unfit for habitation, silence itself can be a problem — especially where the seller also took active steps to cover it up, such as blocking or painting over the area.
Misunderstanding 3: "Fix it first, then settle accounts with the seller." That is the wrong order. The moment you tear things out and complete major repairs, the physical evidence is gone, and it becomes very hard to prove the problem existed before closing, or for how long. The right order is: photograph and video everything, get a written assessment from a professional, speak to a lawyer — then decide whether and how to repair.
If You've Found a Problem, Work Through It in This Order
- Stop the damage and make things safe: shut off the water for a leak, cut power for an electrical hazard — but don't rush into major demolition or repairs.
- Document everything: photos, video, the date you found it and what you observed; bring in a home inspector or the relevant tradesperson and get a written report.
- Pull out the APS, the schedules and the SPIS (if there is one), check the seller's promises and answers line by line, and mark every mismatch.
- Gather "the seller knew" evidence: cover-up traces, old repair records, what neighbours say — in writing wherever possible.
- Take the file and the evidence to an Ontario real estate lawyer and assess which route — negotiation, a lawyer's letter, or a claim — is worth it, before you repair or demand payment.
- If it's a new build, check your Tarion warranty documents immediately and file within the program's deadlines instead of following the resale playbook.
老老实实做人,踏踏实实做事 — work honestly, and do the work properly. I'm Ming Ren. When a problem shows up, don't panic: classify it, gather the paperwork, and let's go through it item by item before anyone acts.
This article is general information, not legal advice. Defect liability and the outcome of any claim depend on the evidence in each case; consult an Ontario lawyer before acting.
Primary sources: Real Estate Council of Ontario (RECO) public guidance on latent and patent defects and the SPIS; Tarion new home warranty program (tarion.com). The water-damage example and repair figure in this article are invented, illustrative numbers.
Frequently asked questions
I waived the inspection condition, so did I give up all my rights?
No. Waiving the condition gives up your chance to walk away if an inspection turns something up; it does not give the seller permission to lie or to deliberately conceal a known latent defect. Liability for fraud and misrepresentation does not disappear just because you did not inspect.
The seller said nothing, so can the seller be responsible?
Possibly. For a known latent defect that makes a home dangerous or unfit for habitation, silence itself can be a problem, especially where the seller also took active steps to cover it up, such as blocking or painting over the area.
Should I fix the problem first and then settle accounts with the seller?
That is the wrong order. Once you tear things out and complete major repairs, the physical evidence is gone and it becomes very hard to prove the problem existed before closing. Photograph and video everything, get a written professional assessment, and speak to a lawyer first.


