I'm Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
Here is the plain conclusion first: a seller refusing repairs does not leave you powerless — but do not assume the seller must fix things, either. In Ontario, what you can demand, and whether you can walk away, turns on two questions: is your agreement still conditional, or is it already firm? And what exactly did the seller promise, in writing, in that agreement? Until those two are clear, arguing gets you nowhere.
First: Check Which Stage Your Deal Is In
The same sentence — "we won't fix it" — means two very different things at two different stages.
| Stage | Where you stand | What you can generally do |
|---|---|---|
| Inspection condition period still open | The condition is not yet fulfilled; you still have a choice | Follow the condition wording and deliver any notice, in the required form, before the deadline — fulfil, waive, or let the deal end by not fulfilling it |
| Agreement already firm | Both sides are bound to close as agreed | You generally cannot walk away just because you dislike a defect; your rights come from the contract terms themselves |
While a condition period is open, your leverage is time. How the condition is worded, when it expires, and how notice must be given all come from the agreement you signed. Miss the deadline and the condition may be treated as fulfilled — and the leverage flips to the other side.
Once a deal is firm, an old common-law principle applies: caveat emptor, or "buyer beware." Problems that are visible or reasonably discoverable — often called patent defects — are generally the buyer's responsibility to have found before offering, and a seller is usually under no duty to repair them before handing over the home. An aging roof or a dripping faucet, discovered after the deal is firm, will not on its own justify refusing to close.
But that principle is not a free pass for sellers. The exceptions are the next section.
Second: Check What the Seller Actually Promised
After a deal is firm, whether you can require the seller to act depends not on frustration but on whether a promise in the contract covers the problem. The usual categories:
First, the condition of included items. The standard terms of Ontario's widely used OREA Form 100 contain a seller's undertaking about included chattels and fixtures — in general terms, that they will be in good working order on closing. If a pre-closing visit shows the included furnace or dishwasher simply does not work, that is not asking the seller a favour; it is a question of whether a contractual promise was kept, and your lawyer should deal with it against the actual wording.
Second, warranties and representations the seller gave in writing. If the agreement or a schedule states something — that a system is in a certain state, that certain work was done — and it turns out not to be true, that is a different matter, handled as breach or misrepresentation, again on legal advice.
Third, hidden problems the seller knew about. RECO's guidance to registrants distinguishes a latent defect — a hidden defect not discoverable on a reasonable inspection — from a patent defect. If a seller knowingly concealed a serious latent defect, that is a very different situation from an obvious one. But "the seller knew" has to be proven with evidence, not guessed, and disputes like this need a lawyer involved early.
Fourth, title problems. If what you found concerns title or zoning, that belongs in your lawyer's requisitions — a separate track from the physical condition of the house, and the two should not be mixed together in one argument.
A quick calculation with invented numbers (all figures in this example are illustrative only, not a real transaction): suppose a pre-closing visit finds the included furnace does not work, and replacing it is quoted at $6,500 (illustrative figure). The negotiation is then not "you must fix it" but "the contract promised a furnace in good working order." Through your lawyer, in writing, you ask for repair before closing or a matching price adjustment. Whether the seller agrees is negotiation — but your footing is the contract, not emotion.
Third: Put the Negotiation on Paper, Not in the Air
Once you know your stage and your footing, the rest is method. What I walk my clients through:
Split the findings into two piles. One pile is safety and basic function — gas, electrical, an active leak getting worse, no heat in winter. The other is wear and appearance — scuffed walls, old carpet, a loose handle. Negotiate hard on the first pile only; keep the second in perspective. Fighting over everything wins nothing.
Get real quotes. Have a qualified contractor quote the work in writing, with scope and price spelled out. When you ask for a price reduction or a closing credit, you hand over a quote, not a feeling.
Then write down whatever is agreed as a signed amendment: who repairs what, to what standard, by when, how it will be checked before closing — or how much the price changes. A spoken "don't worry, I'll take care of it" cannot be cashed on closing day. And if talks fail where a contractual promise is at stake, do not stall on your own: hand it to your lawyer promptly to decide next steps, including whether closing should be delayed and how your rights are preserved. Those are legal decisions, not ones your agent can make for you.
Common Misunderstandings
Misunderstanding 1: "Everything in the inspection report is the seller's job to fix." No. An inspection report informs your decision; it is not a repair order for the seller. Whether the seller must fix anything comes from the contract and the exceptions above.
Misunderstanding 2: "The deal is firm, but I can still back out over anything I find before closing." You cannot. Walk away from a firm deal without a contractual basis and you may be the party in breach, with your deposit and further losses at stake. If you believe a problem is serious enough to stop closing, have your lawyer read the contract before you act, not after.
Misunderstanding 3: "The seller didn't tell me, so the seller deceived me." Not necessarily. For patent defects, buyer beware generally applies and a seller has no duty to catalogue every flaw. Only a latent defect that the seller knew of and concealed may become a problem — and that takes evidence, not suspicion.
Pre-Closing Action Checklist
- Confirm the deal's status: which conditions remain unfulfilled, and their exact deadlines — check them against a calendar.
- List every problem found, and label each: patent issue, possible latent defect, or an included item not working.
- Go back to the agreement and find the matching promise: included-items terms, seller's warranties, your revisit rights — clause by clause.
- Get one or two written repair quotes for anything you intend to raise, so every number has support.
- Make your request in writing through your agent: repair, price reduction, or credit — pick the form and state it clearly; do not negotiate verbally only.
- Record any agreement in a signed amendment, with the pre-closing revisit time and method settled.
- For latent defects, untrue seller statements, or title issues, send the complete file to your lawyer right away.
- Make any decision to exit or delay closing only after your lawyer confirms it — never jump the notice.
A home is a major purchase, but problems before closing are solved with the contract and the evidence, not with whoever raises their voice. Sort out your stage, pin down the promise, and get the negotiation in writing, and most issues can be settled. For the ones that cannot, your lawyer can tell you exactly where the boundary lies.
Honest in conduct, diligent in work — 老老实实做人,踏踏实实做事. I'm Ming Ren, Broker with RE/MAX Realtron. If something turns up before closing and you're unsure which category it falls into, send me the agreement and the inspection report, and I'll help you sort it out before we talk about next steps.
This article is general information only, not legal advice. Contract terms and facts differ from deal to deal; before deciding to exit an agreement, delay closing, or make a claim, consult your own Ontario real estate lawyer.
Primary sources: the standard terms of OREA Form 100 (Agreement of Purchase and Sale), including the undertaking on the condition of included chattels and fixtures; RECO's published guidance on latent and patent defects and the caveat emptor principle.
Frequently asked questions
Is everything in the inspection report the seller's job to fix?
No. An inspection report informs your decision; it is not a repair order for the seller. Whether the seller must fix anything comes from the contract and the exceptions discussed in the article.
The deal is firm — can I still back out over anything I find before closing?
No. Walking away from a firm deal without a contractual basis may make you the party in breach, with your deposit and further losses at stake. Have your lawyer read the contract before you act.
The seller didn't tell me about a defect, so the seller deceived me, right?
Not necessarily. For patent defects, buyer beware generally applies and a seller has no duty to catalogue every flaw. Only a latent defect the seller knew of and concealed may become a problem, and that takes evidence, not suspicion.


