I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
The plain conclusion first: closing versus assigning is not decided by whether the unit went up in value. It is the result of comparing three sets of numbers — the contract, the tax, and the mortgage. If the contract prohibits assignment, the other two sets do not matter. If it allows assignment, the HST on the assignment side and the HST rebate on the closing side can pull the two outcomes tens of thousands of dollars apart. And one baseline fact: if you cannot close and cannot assign, what remains is default, where the deposit and damages are real money. Run these numbers months before your occupancy date, not when the developer's notice lands.
Set one: the contract — does your APS actually let you assign?
Assignment is not a statutory right. It exists only if your Agreement of Purchase and Sale (APS) gives it to you. The assignment clause decides three things:
- Whether assignment is allowed at all. Some projects permit it, some prohibit it outright, and some say "at the developer's sole discretion" — which hands the decision entirely to the developer, who can reject the buyer you found, leaving you with no recourse.
- Whether prior written consent is required. Most projects that allow assignment require the developer's written consent first. A private assignment signed without it may not bind the developer and may put you in breach.
- What the assignment fee is. The fee is whatever your own contract says; it varies widely between developers, so I will not quote you a "going rate" here — open your APS, because that number is the only one that counts. Also confirm the assignment window: some contracts stop accepting assignments once occupancy begins.
If the contract prohibits assignment, your options are close or default — there is no third road. If it allows assignment, get the consent process, the fee and the deadline confirmed by the developer in writing before you go looking for an assignee, not after.
Set two: the tax — HST on the way out, rebates on the way in
The HST on an assignment. This is the number most assignors miss. Under section 192.1 of the Excise Tax Act and CRA's GST/HST Notice 323, an assignment of a new-home purchase agreement made after May 6, 2022 is a taxable supply — full stop, regardless of whether you originally intended to live in the unit or invest. In Ontario the tax is the 13% HST. One detail of the tax base matters enormously: of the money your assignee pays you, the part that reimburses the deposits you already paid the builder is excluded from the taxable consideration only if the assignment agreement states in writing that it is a deposit reimbursement. If the agreement is silent, that exclusion is zero, and HST is calculated on your own deposit money coming back to you as well.
An illustrative example with numbers I have invented: suppose your assignment premium is $60,000 — the amount the assignee pays you above reimbursing your deposits — and the assignment agreement properly identifies the deposit reimbursement in writing. The HST on the premium alone is $60,000 × 13% = $7,800, which you collect and remit to the CRA. How the assignment profit is treated for income tax — capital gain or business income — depends on your facts and pattern of activity; bring an accountant in before the assignment, not at tax season.
The HST and rebates if you close. On closing you pay 13% HST on the price first, then claim back whatever rebate you qualify for. One window deserves everyone's attention: under the arrangement published in the Ontario Budget 2026, Ontario temporarily enhanced its new-home HST rebates for one year. For qualifying new homes under purchase agreements signed between April 1, 2026 and March 31, 2027, homes valued at $1,000,000 or less can receive a rebate of the full 8% provincial portion (up to $80,000), the maximum is maintained between $1,000,000 and $1,500,000, and it phases down above that; together with up to $50,000 of support for the federal portion, total relief can reach $130,000. Conditions include use as a primary residence or a qualifying rental, the details follow the eligibility criteria published by the CRA and Ontario, and arrangements of this kind depend on federal regulatory implementation — have your lawyer or accountant confirm your own agreement's position before you rely on it.
The practical effect on this decision: your APS signing date sets the rebate tier on the closing side. A contract signed inside the window may close with a dramatically lower net HST cost; an older contract signed outside it closes under the previous rebate rules. The same logic follows the contract into an assignment — an assignee steps into your agreement, and rebate eligibility follows the agreement's terms. Both sides will run this math in a negotiation; do not assume it lands in your favour by default.
Set three: the mortgage and the holding math — closing is not just a signature
Closing means qualifying for a real mortgage on the unit, assessed on your income, debts and the interest rates in effect at closing — not the conditions from the year you signed. Higher rates, a changed income, or new debts can shrink or kill the approval. If the mortgage cannot be funded, closing stops being a question of willingness and becomes a question of ability — and in that situation assignment is often the only orderly exit, provided the contract allows it and it is completed before you are in default.
If you can close, run the holding math: the one-time closing costs (net HST, land transfer tax, legal fees, development charges) plus the ongoing mortgage, condo fees and rental return, against the net assignment proceeds (premium − assignment fee − HST − legal fees). One more tax warning for the "close and quickly resell" plan: under the Income Tax Act's flipped property rule, a residential property sold after being held less than 365 days has its profit treated in principle as fully taxable business income, with losses denied, subject to a short list of statutory exceptions. For a short hold, close-then-sell is often the worse route compared with assigning.
Three common misunderstandings
1. "An assignment is just transferring the contract — the premium is pure profit." It is not. Every assignment after May 2022 carries HST; take 13% off the premium, then the developer's assignment fee and legal fees, and what remains is yours. Negotiating on the gross number and discovering the tax after signing is the most common way assignment deals blow up.
2. "Surely the deposit reimbursement isn't taxed — that's just my own money back." The rule is strict in exactly this spot: the deposit portion is excluded from the taxable amount only if the assignment agreement identifies it in writing. Leave that sentence out and the exclusion is zero — HST reaches into your returned deposit. Have your lawyer show you, in dollars, what that one sentence is worth before the assignment agreement is drafted.
3. "There's a new-home rebate of up to $130,000 in 2026, so closing must be the smart move." The enhanced rebate applies only to purchase agreements signed inside the April 1, 2026 to March 31, 2027 window that also meet the use and other eligibility conditions. Older contracts signed outside the window follow the previous rebate framework. Check your APS signing date and eligibility first; only then talk about which route is smarter.
If you are weighing closing against assigning, do it in this order
- Open the assignment clause of your APS: allowed or not, consent required or not, the fee, and the last day of the assignment window. If this gate is closed, the rest of the math is moot.
- Have your lawyer draft or review the assignment paperwork with one explicit instruction — the deposit reimbursement must be itemized in writing — and have an accountant estimate the HST and income tax on the assignment first.
- Get a mortgage broker to re-qualify you at today's income and rates, so you are working with a real approval amount and a real monthly payment, not signing-day memories.
- Verify your HST rebate tier against your APS signing date — inside or outside the 2026 enhanced window, and whether your (or your assignee's) intended use qualifies — and get that confirmed in writing by your lawyer or accountant.
- Put the two net figures on one page: net assignment proceeds versus total closing cost plus expected holding return. Never compare one side's gross against the other side's net.
- Whichever route you choose, leave operating room before the occupancy and closing dates: developer consent takes time, and so does mortgage funding. Neither process finishes in a week.
I am Ming Ren. If you are holding a pre-construction contract and cannot decide whether to close or assign, bring the APS and your deposit records and we will run all three sets of numbers, line by line, before you decide.
This article is general information, not legal or tax advice. The HST treatment of an assignment, rebate eligibility, and the flipped property rule all depend on your contract dates, intended use and personal circumstances. Consult an Ontario lawyer and an accountant before acting.
Primary sources: Excise Tax Act, s.192.1 and CRA GST/HST Notice 323 (assignment sales); Ontario Budget 2026, Annex — Enhancing Harmonized Sales Tax Relief on New Homes (budget.ontario.ca); Income Tax Act, s.12(12)–(14), flipped property rule (CRA guidance). Checked November 2026. The $60,000 premium and $7,800 HST in the example are illustrative figures invented for this article, not a real transaction.
Frequently asked questions
Is an assignment just transferring the contract, so the premium is pure profit?
It is not. Every assignment after May 2022 carries HST; take 13% off the premium, then the developer's assignment fee and legal fees, and what remains is yours.
Surely the deposit reimbursement isn't taxed — that's just my own money back?
The deposit portion is excluded from the taxable amount only if the assignment agreement identifies it in writing. Leave that sentence out and the exclusion is zero — HST reaches into your returned deposit.
There's a new-home rebate of up to $130,000 in 2026, so closing must be the smart move?
The enhanced rebate applies only to purchase agreements signed inside the April 1, 2026 to March 31, 2027 window that also meet the use and other eligibility conditions. Older contracts outside the window follow the previous rebate framework.


