I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
The plain conclusion first: an Option to Purchase is a one-way contract. You pay an option fee for the exclusive right to buy a property at an agreed price within an agreed period. During that period the seller cannot sell to anyone else — but you are under no obligation to buy. Decide to proceed, and you exercise the option in the manner the contract requires; it becomes a binding purchase agreement. Decide not to, and the right simply expires at the deadline, with the fee staying with the seller. The rules are simple; the details are where the danger sits.
First: what exactly are you buying?
The fundamental difference from an ordinary purchase agreement is the direction of the obligation. A regular APS, once accepted, binds both sides. An option binds only the seller. Having taken your fee, the seller must hold the property for you and keep the price locked for the whole option period — the market can rise and the seller still cannot sell elsewhere. You keep the full choice: exercise, or walk away.
Because the commitment runs one way, the right is never free. The option fee is the consideration you pay for time and exclusivity. There is no statutory amount; it is negotiated, usually in relation to the price and the length of the period. One question must be answered in the document itself: if you exercise, is the fee credited toward the price or the deposit, or is it a pure extra cost? Both structures exist. Whatever the contract says governs — and if it is silent, assume the interpretation that hurts you. Get it in writing before you sign.
An option is also governed by the Statute of Frauds: an interest in land must be created in writing, signed, to be enforceable. A spoken "I'll hold the house for you for three months" is worth nothing.
Second: exercising is a strict procedural step, and a missed deadline has no cure
Exercising the option is not a phone call saying "I've decided to buy." The contract normally specifies exactly how: written notice, to a stated address, by a stated method, by an exact date and time. You must follow it to the letter. Option contracts are interpreted strictly at common law — notice a day late, or sent to the wrong address, can make the exercise invalid, and the seller has no duty to remind you or to grant grace.
Once validly exercised, the relationship converts into a purchase: the pre-agreed terms in the option (or an attached draft APS) take over — deposit, financing, title search, closing on schedule. That is why a properly drafted option settles the entire post-exercise deal at signing: price, closing date, included chattels, deposit arrangements. An option that says "price to be negotiated at market on exercise" guarantees a fight at exactly the wrong moment.
If you do not exercise, nothing happens. The period ends, the right dies, the property returns to the market, and the option fee stays with the seller as compensation for the time the property was held off it. You owe nothing more. That is the essential difference between an option and a breach: not exercising is not default — it is a choice the contract itself sold you.
Third: when it is worth using, and when it is money for nothing
An option earns its fee when the buyer needs time to resolve one specific uncertainty: selling a current home first, finalizing financing or funds, awaiting a planning or zoning outcome, or a partner or family decision. In those cases the option uses a known, limited cost to lock a specific property, and avoids the worse dilemma of signing an APS and risking a deposit and a damages claim if things fall through.
An illustrative example I made up: a buyer wants a home but needs two more months before listing his own. He pays an option fee for a three-month window. His home sells, he exercises and buys. It does not sell, and his total loss is the fee — not an APS deposit plus exposure to a breach claim. I have kept the amounts out on purpose: the point is not the size of the fee, it is that he bought time at a controlled cost.
The reverse case matters too. If your funds and financing are ready and your checks are largely done, a straight APS with sensible conditions is usually the better buy: conditions give you investigation room and an exit as well, without an extra fee. An option is not a premium version of an APS. It is a tool that charges you for a specific uncertainty — so first ask "what exactly am I waiting for?" If there is no answer, do not pay for the wait.
Three common misunderstandings
Misunderstanding 1: "Not exercising is breaking the deal — the seller can claim damages." No. Not exercising is the very right you purchased. When the period ends, both sides are done, and your loss is limited to the option fee unless the contract clearly says otherwise.
Misunderstanding 2: "We can negotiate the price and closing date when I exercise." You cannot, and that is the point of an option: price and main terms are locked at signing. Exercise is a trigger, not a reopening. Anything left open at signing will not be conceded by the seller at exercise.
Misunderstanding 3: "The seller agreed verbally to hold it — we'll paper it later." Interests in land require writing and signature. Without a written option agreement, the seller can sell to someone else tomorrow and you have no basis to stop it.
Before signing an option agreement, confirm each of these
- The option fee, when it is paid, and whether it is credited toward the price or deposit on exercise — in the contract, not by word of mouth.
- The exact start and end of the option period, with specific dates and a time of day, never "about three months."
- The exercise mechanics — form of notice, address, method of delivery — and calendar the deadline the day you sign.
- That the full post-exercise terms are attached or spelled out: price, closing date, deposit, chattels. Nothing essential left open.
- Have a lawyer review it before signing, however small the fee. A strictly interpreted contract is exactly where one wrong detail costs everything.
Ming Ren, Broker, RE/MAX Realtron. Paying for time is fine — first be clear what problem the time is meant to solve.
This article is general information, not legal advice. Option agreements are interpreted strictly on their wording; consult an Ontario lawyer before signing.
Primary sources: Statute of Frauds, R.S.O. 1990, c. S.19, s.4 (Ontario e-Laws); Ontario common law principles on the exercise and interpretation of options to purchase land (consulted November 2026). The buyer waiting to sell is an illustrative example, not a real transaction.
Frequently asked questions
Is not exercising breaking the deal, so the seller can claim damages?
No. Not exercising is the very right you purchased. When the period ends, both sides are done, and your loss is limited to the option fee unless the contract clearly says otherwise.
Can we negotiate the price and closing date when I exercise?
You cannot, and that is the point of an option: price and main terms are locked at signing. Exercise is a trigger, not a reopening.
The seller agreed verbally to hold it — can we paper it later?
Interests in land require writing and signature. Without a written option agreement, the seller can sell to someone else tomorrow and you have no basis to stop it.


