Ming RenBroker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage
☎ 647-779-9186

Buying a Home

Right of First Refusal in Ontario: Before You Sell, Someone Gets Asked First

By , Broker, RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc. (About Ming) · Published

Ming Ren · Broker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage

← All articles · Buying a Home · Category guide

I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.

The plain conclusion first: a right of first refusal (ROFR) is a passive right. The holder cannot force the owner to sell. Only when the owner decides to sell and has a third-party offer the owner is willing to accept must the owner first put those same terms — the same price and conditions — in front of the holder and ask: will you buy on these terms? If the holder does not take it within the agreed window, the owner may sell to the third party. The trouble with a ROFR is that it is invisible for years and tends to surface at the worst moment — from an old agreement, just as a deal is about to close.

First: how a ROFR is actually triggered

The chain has fixed steps, and skipping one breaks it:

First, the owner decides to sell and receives a genuine third-party offer the owner is prepared to accept — price and conditions settled to the point of a yes. Second, the owner gives the holder written notice of the complete terms, in the manner the agreement requires. Third, the holder decides within the deadline stated in the agreement: match the terms and become the buyer, or decline — expressly, or by letting the window close, depending on the wording. Fourth, once the holder passes, the owner may sell to that third party on the terms that were notified. If the owner then changes the deal in substance — a lower price, different conditions — that is effectively a new transaction and the notice process generally has to run again.

The Supreme Court of Canada confirmed this character of the right in Canadian Long Island Petroleums Ltd. v. Irving Industries: the holder cannot compel a sale; the decision to sell stays with the owner. That is also why, before it is exercised, a ROFR is generally a contractual right rather than an interest in land of the kind an option creates — a distinction that matters for registration on title and for how lenders view it.

One practical detail: exercising a ROFR means matching the whole deal, not just the price. The third party's closing date, deposit and conditions come with it. And the owner's notice has to disclose the complete terms — a notice that reports only a headline price invites a dispute about when the holder's clock even started.

Second: three "first" rights that are not the same thing

These three are constantly blurred together, but who holds the switch is completely different. Read the clause, not the label:

  • Right of first refusal (ROFR): the owner negotiates on the market first, then must ask the holder. The owner controls the process; the holder can only match.
  • Right of first offer (ROFO): the order flips. As soon as the owner wants to sell, the owner must first offer the property to the holder on terms the owner sets. Only if the holder declines can it go to market. The holder is one step earlier, but the owner still sets the price.
  • Option to purchase: the strongest of the three. During the option period the holder can unilaterally require the owner to sell at a pre-agreed price, whether or not the owner wants to sell. An option is generally treated as an interest in land, with the most direct effect on title and financing.

A short way to remember it: with an option, the holder decides; with a ROFO, the owner offers first; with a ROFR, the owner deals first and the holder may match.

Third: where ROFRs hide, and what a workable clause must say

You will find ROFRs in commercial leases (a tenant's right over the leased premises), co-ownership agreements, family property arrangements, private agreements between neighbouring owners, and shareholder agreements involving real estate. They are not always registered on title — an unregistered ROFR is found by reviewing agreements and disclosure, which is exactly why it can detonate at the last minute of a transaction.

A clause that actually works should pin down at least these points: what triggers it (an accepted offer, or merely listing); how notice is given and to what address; the holder's response deadline, and whether silence counts as a refusal; how quickly the holder must close after exercising; whether a price cut or changed terms require fresh notice; whether the right can be assigned; and whether it is one-time or applies to every future sale. Leave these vague and the dispute will arrive at the most expensive moment — with a buyer and a seller already in place.

Three common misunderstandings

1. "I hold a ROFR, so the owner has to sell to me when I want to buy." No. The right sleeps until the owner decides to sell and has an acceptable offer. The right that lets you force a purchase is an option, not a ROFR.

2. "We agreed verbally that I'd get first refusal, so it counts." Arrangements about land belong in writing, with complete terms, and a lawyer should assess whether registration or notice on title is advisable. A verbal promise has almost no practical enforceability in a closing dispute.

3. "The holder passed once, so I never have to ask again." Read the clause. Some ROFRs cover a single sale; others apply to every sale during their term. Whether one refusal ends the right is a question of the document's wording.

If you are buying, selling, or signing one of these, do this in order

  1. Sellers: before listing, search your own files — co-ownership agreements, leases, family agreements — for any first-refusal promise, and plan the notice process with your lawyer before an offer arrives.
  2. Buyers: beyond the title search, ask the seller directly whether any ROFR, ROFO or option arrangement exists, and have the answer reflected in the transaction documents.
  3. Holders: when a notice arrives, look at the calendar first — the response window runs from delivery and does not wait. If you intend to exercise, reply in writing immediately and have your funds ready.
  4. Anyone signing a ROFR: settle trigger, deadline, notice method, re-notice on price changes, assignment and expiry — then have an Ontario lawyer review it before you sign.
  5. If the wording is ambiguous, do not interpret it yourself. In these disputes, the outcome usually sits inside the exact words of the original document.

I am Ming Ren. Before signing anything with the word "first" in it, let us be sure which right it actually is.


This article is general information, not legal advice. The enforceability of a right of first refusal depends on the document's wording, registration and the facts of the case. Consult an Ontario lawyer before acting.

Primary source: Canadian Long Island Petroleums Ltd. v. Irving Industries (Irving Wire Products of Canada) Ltd., [1975] 2 S.C.R. 715 (Supreme Court of Canada, confirming the passive, contractual nature of a right of first refusal; reviewed November 2026).

Frequently asked questions

If I hold a right of first refusal, does the owner have to sell to me when I want to buy?

No. The right sleeps until the owner decides to sell and has an acceptable offer; the right that lets you force a purchase is an option, not a ROFR.

Does a verbal promise of first refusal count?

Arrangements about land belong in writing with complete terms, and a lawyer should assess whether registration or notice on title is advisable; a verbal promise has almost no practical enforceability in a closing dispute.

If the holder passed once, do I never have to ask again?

It depends on the clause. Some ROFRs cover a single sale and others apply to every sale during their term, so whether one refusal ends the right is a question of the document's wording.

This article in other languages: 中文فارسی

Want to talk about your home?

You can also call directly, or scan the code to add Ming on WeChat.

Ming’s WeChat QR code
Scan to add on WeChat

Community guides by city

All cities →
☎ Call MingFree Evaluation