I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
Here is the plain conclusion first: an Agreement of Purchase and Sale (APS) binds title — you are committing to buy (or sell) the home on the closing date. A lease binds only the use of the home — you are committing to pay rent month by month and to leave, when the time comes, under the rules. And above the lease sits the Residential Tenancies Act, 2006 (the RTA): a term both sides signed is still void if it conflicts with that Act. Treating the two documents as "just signing an agreement either way" is where a lot of trouble starts. A rent-to-own arrangement with a purchase option is two contracts stacked together, with different rules governing each half — it must not be read as one.
This article covers three things only: how hard an APS binds you, why a lease cannot be settled by private agreement alone, and which half of a rent-to-own deal is protected and which half lives or dies by its own wording.
1. An APS commits you to a transfer of title, and the contract sets no ceiling on the cost of backing out
The APS is the contract for a resale purchase in Ontario. Once the seller accepts your offer and both sides have signed, it is a binding contract setting out the price, the deposit, the closing date, what is included, and conditions such as financing and inspection.
The conditions are the hinge. While a condition is outstanding and has not been fulfilled or waived within its time limit, the contract is not yet unconditional ("firm"). Once every condition is fulfilled or waived, the deal is firm and both sides must get to closing: the buyer pays the balance and the seller transfers title. Resale homes in Ontario have no statutory cooling-off period, and once a deal is firm, walking away is not simply a matter of losing the deposit:
- A buyer who fails to close is in breach. The deposit is usually the first money at risk, but it is not a cap — if the seller resells for less, the seller can pursue the buyer for the shortfall and other losses as well.
- A seller who fails to close can likewise be pursued for losses, and in an appropriate case the buyer can ask a court for specific performance — an order that the sale go through as agreed.
- The deposit amount is whatever the parties negotiate into the APS; no statute fixes a percentage. The deposit is held in trust as the contract directs, and in a dispute neither side can simply take it.
An illustrative example, with numbers I invented only to show the scale, not market statistics: a price of $800,000 with a negotiated deposit of $40,000. The buyer refuses to close after the deal is firm and the seller resells for $760,000. The buyer is looking at more than the $40,000 deposit — a court may also count part of that $40,000 shortfall. The exposure under an APS is open-ended.
2. A lease commits you only to use of the home, and the RTA stands above the contract
A residential lease runs on entirely different logic. The tenant is not buying title, only a right to live in and use the home for a time; the landlord collects rent, and there is no closing and no transfer. More importantly, a lease is not whatever the two sides agree to write:
- Section 3(1) of the RTA states that the Act applies to rental units "despite any agreement or waiver to the contrary." Section 4 then provides that a provision of a tenancy agreement that is inconsistent with the Act or its regulations is void — signed or not, it cannot be enforced.
- Rent increases are the same. Under section 110, a landlord may increase rent only in accordance with Part VII of the Act; a private agreement to an increase that bypasses the Act does not make an unlawful increase lawful.
- Most residential tenancies must use the province's standard form of lease (the regime under section 12.1). Additional terms may add detail, but an additional term that conflicts with the RTA or the standard lease is likewise void.
- Only one kind of deposit is allowed: under sections 105 and 106, the only security a landlord may collect is a rent deposit of at most one month's rent, applicable only to the last month's rent and never to damage. A key deposit may be no more than the actual replacement cost and is refundable. Pet deposits and damage deposits do not stand up.
- A "no pets" term is void under section 14. And the end of the term does not mean the tenant must leave: under section 37 a tenancy can be terminated only in accordance with the Act, and under section 38, if no notice of termination is given, the tenancy continues month to month. A landlord who wants the unit back must use the Act's grounds and process, and disputes go to the Landlord and Tenant Board (LTB).
On the lease side, then, the contract wording is only the starting point. The statute is the ceiling, and no amount of careful signing signs away the RTA's floor.
3. Rent-to-own is two contracts, not one
What the market calls rent-to-own or a lease with an option to purchase is usually two documents stacked together:
| Part | Governed by | What you are committing to |
|---|---|---|
| The lease | The RTA and the standard form of lease | Paying rent month by month and living in the home with a tenant's rights and duties |
| The purchase option | Ordinary contract law, as the signed wording provides | A right to buy the home by a set deadline at an agreed price |
Three differences between the two halves are the ones most often confused:
First, the source of protection differs. On the lease half, the RTA floor is still there — the deposit cap, the rent increase rules, the termination process — and a landlord cannot contract around it by calling the package a "rent-to-own agreement." On the option half — the option fee, how much of each month's rent counts as a credit toward the purchase, the future price, the deadline for exercising the option, and whether any of that money comes back if you do not buy — the RTA says essentially nothing. It is whatever the contract says. A promise that is not in the signed document should be treated as if it does not exist.
Second, "the right to buy" and "the obligation to buy" are one word apart and worlds apart. If the document grants an option, you may choose not to buy at the end, and the cost is normally what the contract says you give up — the option fee and accumulated credits. If it obliges you to buy at the end (a lease-purchase style arrangement), it is in economic substance close to an APS: fail to close, and the other side can pursue you as for a failed purchase. Find that sentence and read it before you sign.
Third, part of the risk sits with the other side. Over a term of years, if the owner stops paying their own mortgage, sells the home to someone else, or is pursued by creditors, your ability to exercise the option can be caught in the fallout. Whether a notice of your agreement should be registered on title to protect the option is a question for a lawyer before signing, not on the deadline day.
An illustrative example: rent of $2,400 a month, with $300 a month recorded as a purchase credit over a three-year term — $10,800 in credits in total. Whether that money can be used, and whether it is wiped out if you do not buy, is decided entirely by the wording of the option document.
Three misunderstandings I hear most often
"Both sides signed the lease term, so of course it is enforceable." No. Under section 4 of the RTA, a lease term that conflicts with the Act is void even though it was signed — a pet ban, an excess deposit, a rent increase that bypasses the Act. An APS runs the other way: the terms the parties negotiated are, in principle, enforced as written, with no comparable statute standing above the contract to rewrite them for you.
"Breaking an APS is like breaking a lease — you lose a deposit and walk away." No. The bill for ending a tenancy early is worked out largely around rent and the LTB process. Default on a firm APS and the deposit is only the starting point; the resale shortfall and other losses can follow. Treating a purchase as "a bigger rental" understates the exposure by an order of magnitude.
"Every dollar paid under a rent-to-own is protected because I am a tenant." Only half of it is. Your rent deposit is protected by sections 105 and 106 of the RTA. The option fee and the monthly credits travel on the option contract's track, where the protection comes only from the contract's own wording and ordinary contract law. Before any money leaves your hands, ask which document it is being paid under.
Before you sign, I suggest doing these things in order
- Identify which kind of document you are actually signing: an APS, a standard lease, or a lease plus an option. The label matters less than whether it commits title or only use.
- Before signing an APS, check the conditions, the deposit amount and when it is due, and the closing date, item by item. Before waiving a condition, confirm the financing and the inspection have truly landed — there is no cooling-off period once the deal is firm.
- Before signing a lease, check it against the standard form: is the only deposit one month's rent, and do any additional terms — a pet ban, extra charges — conflict with the RTA?
- With a rent-to-own, insist on reading the lease and the option as two separate documents: the exercise deadline, the price, the credit rules, and what happens to your money if you do not buy must all be spelled out in the option itself. Verbal promises do not count.
- Read whether the option gives you a right to buy or an obligation to buy. If it is an obligation, treat the document with the same caution as an APS.
- In all three cases, have an Ontario real estate lawyer review the documents before you sign — above all a rent-to-own, where there are two documents and two sets of rules, and judging a contract's legal effect is a lawyer's work.
Trust Professional, Diligent Work. I am Ming Ren. Before you sign anything connected with a home, bring the documents and we will go through the terms and the numbers, item by item, before anyone picks up a pen.
This article is general information only, not legal advice. The wording of your contract, and whether your tenancy falls within the RTA's application or an exemption, can change the conclusion. Consult an Ontario lawyer before acting.
Primary sources: Residential Tenancies Act, 2006, S.O. 2006, c.17, ss.3(1), 4, 12.1, 14, 37, 38, 105, 106, 110 (Ontario e-Laws, consulted November 2026); on the binding effect of an APS, deposit trust obligations and the absence of a statutory cooling-off period for resale homes, RECO guidance under the Trust in Real Estate Services Act, 2002 (TRESA). The price, deposit, resale price, rent and credit figures are illustrative numbers I invented; they are not a real transaction or statistics.
Frequently asked questions
Both sides signed the lease term, so is it enforceable?
Not necessarily. Under section 4 of the RTA, a lease term that conflicts with the Act is void even though it was signed — a pet ban, an excess deposit, or a rent increase that bypasses the Act. An APS runs the other way: the negotiated terms are, in principle, enforced as written.
Is breaking an APS like breaking a lease — lose the deposit and walk away?
No. The bill for ending a tenancy early is worked out largely around rent and the LTB process, while on a firm APS the deposit is only the starting point and the resale shortfall and other losses can follow.
Is every dollar paid under a rent-to-own protected because I am a tenant?
Only half of it is. Your rent deposit is protected by sections 105 and 106 of the RTA, while the option fee and monthly credits travel on the option contract's track, where protection comes only from the contract's own wording and ordinary contract law.


