I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
The conclusion first: a leak in a new home is not something you simply have to accept as "how new homes are." Under Ontario's Tarion statutory warranty, water problems sit mainly in the first two years — year one covers defects in work and materials, year two specifically covers water penetration and the major systems, and years three to seven are left with major structural defects only. Whether the repair is free rarely depends on how bad the leak is. It depends on whether you reported it, on the right form, inside the right window. Filing late, or not at all, is the most common way owners lose coverage they actually had.
Three warranty periods: match the leak to the coverage
| Period (from the date of possession) | What is covered | Leak examples that fit |
|---|---|---|
| Year one | Defects in work and materials, Ontario Building Code violations, the home not being fit for habitation, unauthorized substitutions of materials | A dripping faucet, leaking tile grout, window frames sealed so poorly that wind and rain get in |
| Year two | Water penetration through the basement or foundation walls, water penetration into the building envelope, defects in the electrical, plumbing and heating systems, exterior cladding that detaches or deteriorates, Code violations affecting health and safety | A damp basement wall, water coming in around windows, moisture inside a wall assembly |
| Years three to seven | Major structural defects only: failure of a load-bearing element, or a defect that materially affects the use of a significant part of the home | Foundation problems causing structural cracking and water entry |
Two further points are worth fixing in mind. First, the warranty stays with the home: if you sell within the warranty period, the remaining coverage passes to the next owner rather than disappearing. Second, warranty compensation has limits — under Tarion's current published figures, $400,000 per freehold home and $300,000 per condominium unit (check Tarion for the figures in force at the time). Amounts beyond the limit are not resolved inside the warranty plan.
What actually decides the outcome: four forms, four deadlines
The warranty exists in law, but forms are what start it:
- The PDI record: items found at the pre-delivery inspection go on the record before you take possession. It is the start of the paper trail.
- The 30-Day Form: filed within the first 30 days after possession, for items you only notice once you are living there.
- The Year-End Form: filed in the last 30 days of the first year. Year-one items must be captured in this window.
- The Second-Year Form: filed in the last 30 days of the second year, for the year-two items — water penetration and the systems.
- The Major Structural Defect Form: can be filed at any time within the seven years, as soon as you see the problem.
File through Tarion's MyHome portal, and send the same list to the builder in writing, keeping proof of delivery. A phone call, or a site supervisor nodding on a walk-through, counts for nothing procedurally — if it is not on a Tarion form, it was never reported. If the builder stalls or refuses a warranted repair, use Tarion's process and request a conciliation inspection, where Tarion assesses whether the item is warranted. Do not open up walls or repair things yourself first: once the scene is disturbed, the evidence is gone.
On the day you find a leak, get the evidence right first
Leak claims are won and lost on records. Photograph and video the leak the day you find it, with the date visible, showing the source point, the spread of staining and any affected walls and floors. Write down when you found it, where it is, and whether it was repaired before. If the same spot leaks again after a repair, file both records together — a repeat leak tells Tarion the problem is not cosmetic, and that changes how the item is assessed. And keep two accounts separate: repairing the defect itself runs through the Tarion warranty, while damage to furniture and finishes generally runs through your own home insurance. Do not park both on one track and wait.
Three common misunderstandings
Misunderstanding 1: "After year one, nobody covers a leak." Wrong. Water penetration and the electrical, plumbing and heating systems remain covered through year two — and basement seepage in particular often shows up in the second year, squarely inside that form's window.
Misunderstanding 2: "I told the builder, so it is reported." It is not. A verbal report leaves no Tarion record; when the builder's staff changes, your report vanishes with them. Every applicable form has to be filed.
Misunderstanding 3: "Tarion is the buyer's advocate, so I will win." No. Tarion administers the warranty plan and decides items against the warranty terms and its construction performance guidelines; it does not take the owner's side unconditionally. Your photographs, your records and, where needed, an independent engineer's opinion are what the decision rests on — prepare them yourself, in advance.
If your home is leaking now, do these in order
- Photograph and video it today, with the date and location recorded. Fix the evidence before touching any repair.
- Work out from your possession date which warranty period you are in and which form window is next, and set the deadline as a reminder.
- File the matching form through Tarion MyHome inside its window, and send the same list to the builder in writing, keeping the record.
- When the builder repairs, photograph the result. If the same spot leaks again, re-file immediately with both episodes documented together.
- If the builder stalls or refuses, move to Tarion's conciliation process; for structural or repeat leaks, consider an independent engineer's report before you negotiate further.
Ming Ren, Broker, RE/MAX Realtron. Before accepting a leak as your problem, bring your possession date and your leak records, and we will go through the warranty periods and the forms one by one.
This article is general information, not legal advice. Whether an item is warranted is decided by Tarion against its standards; for individual cases, consult an Ontario lawyer or a licensed home inspector.
Primary sources: Ontario New Home Warranties Plan Act (Ontario e-Laws); Tarion warranty coverage and warranty form deadlines (tarion.com, consulted November 2026).


