Ming RenBroker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage
☎ 647-779-9186

Living & Communities

Heat Pump or Gas Furnace in Ontario: Work Out Your Balance Point Before You Buy

By , Broker, RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc. (About Ming) · Published

Ming Ren · Broker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage

← All articles · Living & Communities · Category guide

I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.

The plain conclusion first: neither system wins all year. A heat pump is usually cheaper on milder days and loses efficiency as it gets colder; a gas furnace delivers the same output at any temperature, but every unit of heat has to be bought as burned gas. What actually decides your bill is a term many homeowners have never heard — the balance point. Get that number right and the choice between heat-pump-only, gas-only, and a hybrid of the two makes itself. This article compares heat sources only; ductwork and distribution are a separate topic.

1. A heat pump moves heat instead of making it, so its efficiency moves with the weather

A gas furnace makes heat by burning natural gas. A good condensing furnace turns over 90 percent of the fuel's energy into heat for the house, but it can never exceed 100 percent — the heat is created by combustion.

A heat pump works differently. It uses electricity to move heat from the outdoor air into the house, so it is measured not by a percentage but by COP (coefficient of performance): how many units of heat one unit of electricity brings in. In mild weather a cold-climate heat pump can run at a COP around 3 — one unit of electricity delivering roughly three units of heat. The colder it gets, the less heat there is to move, so both output and COP fall, and in deep cold the COP can drop to the low ones.

That is exactly what Natural Resources Canada (NRCan) cold-climate air-source heat pump criteria are aimed at: these models are expected to hold up their capacity and efficiency at low temperatures, rather than fading sharply below freezing like a standard unit. So when you shop, do not stop at the headline rating. Ask for the manufacturer's low-temperature performance table: at −15°C and at −25°C, how much heat can this unit still deliver, and what COP is left? Your home's coldest-day heat load is what that table has to cover.

2. The balance point, and why it runs the operating-cost math

The balance point is simply a temperature. Above it, the heat pump alone can supply all the heat the house needs. Below it, the heat pump's output can no longer keep up with how fast the house loses heat, and a backup source has to fill the gap — electric resistance heat, or the gas furnace you kept.

The balance point is not a property of the machine alone. It comes from two curves meeting: the unit's output at low temperatures, and your home's insulation and heat loss. The same heat pump will have a low balance point in a tight, well-insulated newer home and a much higher one in a drafty older house. That is why "how cold can a heat pump handle?" has no single answer — insist that the installer base it on a heat loss calculation for your house, not on a sales line.

Operating cost follows the same logic. You are not comparing the price of electricity with the price of gas; you are comparing the cost of buying the same unit of heat each way:

Heat source Cost per unit of heat What drives it
Heat pump Electricity price ÷ COP at that moment COP changes with outdoor temperature; colder means costlier heat
Gas furnace Gas price (including delivery charges) ÷ furnace efficiency Efficiency is essentially constant, whatever the weather
Electric backup Electricity price ÷ 1 COP is always 1; the most expensive heat, meant for occasional use

An illustrative example, with invented numbers to show the method only — not anyone's real rates: say electricity costs $0.15 per unit and the heat pump is running at a COP of 3, so a unit of heat costs $0.05. On a much colder day the COP falls to 1.5 and that same unit of heat costs $0.10. If gas, worked out the same way, delivers a unit of heat for $0.07, then the heat pump wins on the mild day, gas wins on the cold day, and the crossover sits near the temperature where the COP is about 2.1. Plug in the actual per-unit prices from your own electricity and gas bills and you can find your home's real crossover — that is worth more than anyone's claim that a heat pump "cuts heating costs in half."

One piece of old math needs updating. For years, gas-cost projections built in a rising federal consumer carbon charge (the fuel charge). That calculation no longer applies: the federal government has set the consumer fuel charge to zero, so it is no longer charged on natural gas bills on the old basis. Compare using the actual current prices on your bills — not outdated carbon-price forecasts, in either direction.

On rebates, this article deliberately gives no amounts. Provincial and federal retrofit programs have changed several times in recent years, and amounts, eligibility, and whether you must apply before or after the work all move with them. Before you commit, check the current figures on the official NRCan and gas-utility program pages, and confirm the application order — getting the sequence wrong can cost you the whole rebate.

3. Three ways to set it up, and who each one suits

Gas furnace only. Suits homes where gas is clearly cheap on your actual bills, the house has a large heat loss, or you do not want to touch the electrical service. Simple, steady output, no cold-day anxiety — but cooling still needs a separate air conditioner, so two systems each cover one season.

Cold-climate heat pump only (with electric backup). Suits a well-insulated home with a modest heat load and a low balance point, or a home with no gas service at all. One machine covers heating and cooling, and mild-weather running costs are low. The catch is the coldest stretch: if electric backup runs often, those days get expensive, so the lower your balance point, the better this option works.

Hybrid (heat pump plus gas furnace backup). The heat pump carries most heating days and all of the summer cooling; below the balance point the system switches to gas automatically. That is not a cop-out — it lets each source do the segment where it is cheapest. The cost is maintaining two systems and the highest upfront spend, which suits a home whose furnace still has life left while you add a heat pump now.

One real-estate note: buyers do look at heating equipment age and type, and they price it in. A recently installed cold-climate heat pump or hybrid system, with the invoice, the low-temperature performance table, and the heat loss calculation on file, is a genuine listing point. An old furnace of unclear age with no paperwork is a lever to push your price down. Keep the documents when you do the work.

Three common misunderstandings

"A heat pump is 300 percent efficient, so my bill will be a third of gas." COP changes with temperature — around 3 on a mild day, possibly under 2 or lower in deep cold. A season's bill has to be figured across the whole winter's temperature range, not from the best day's number.

"Installing a heat pump means removing the furnace." It does not. A hybrid system keeps the furnace precisely for the days below the balance point. Whether to remove it depends on your balance point, the furnace's remaining life, and the bill structure you want — it is not an equipment requirement.

"The carbon tax goes up every year, so gas will only get more expensive — switch now." The consumer fuel charge has been set to zero, so that premise is gone. Energy prices will keep changing, but a decision worth tens of thousands of dollars should be run on today's real prices from your own bills, not on an outdated policy forecast.

If your furnace is being replaced this year, do these five things in order

  1. Pull a full year of electricity and gas bills and note the real delivered price per unit of each, including delivery and other charges — not just the headline rate.
  2. Have the installer do a proper heat loss calculation and state, in writing, your system's balance point and which low-temperature performance table it is based on. Do not accept "it works down to minus twenty-something" as an answer.
  3. Using the method above, work out your cost per unit of heat on a mild day and on a cold day, find where the crossover falls, and only then choose heat-pump-only, gas-only, or hybrid.
  4. Get at least two quotes that state the model's output and COP at −15°C and −25°C, and have the backup heat's switch-over temperature written into the contract.
  5. Before any work starts, check the current rebate amounts, eligibility, and application order on the official NRCan and utility program pages, and keep every invoice and document.

Trust Professional, Diligent Work. I am Ming Ren. Before you replace a heating system, run the balance point and the bills first — we go by the numbers, item by item, not by the sales pitch.


This article is general information only, not engineering or financial advice. Your home's heat loss, your electricity and gas rate structures, and equipment sizing can change the conclusion. Have a licensed HVAC contractor calculate and quote for your specific home before you sign.

Primary sources: Natural Resources Canada (NRCan) air-source and cold-climate heat pump guidance; Government of Canada fuel charge pages (consulted November 2026). Electricity prices and per-unit heat costs above are illustrative examples, not real rates; rebate amounts change — see the official program pages for current figures, which is why none are listed here.

Frequently asked questions

A heat pump is 300 percent efficient, so will my bill be a third of gas?

COP changes with temperature — around 3 on a mild day, possibly under 2 or lower in deep cold. A season's bill has to be figured across the whole winter's temperature range, not from the best day's number.

Does installing a heat pump mean removing the furnace?

It does not. A hybrid system keeps the furnace precisely for the days below the balance point. Whether to remove it depends on your balance point, the furnace's remaining life, and the bill structure you want.

The carbon tax goes up every year, so will gas only get more expensive?

The consumer fuel charge has been set to zero, so that premise is gone. A decision worth tens of thousands of dollars should be run on today's real prices from your own bills, not on an outdated policy forecast.

This article in other languages: 中文فارسی

Want to talk about your home?

You can also call directly, or scan the code to add Ming on WeChat.

Ming’s WeChat QR code
Scan to add on WeChat

Community guides by city

All cities →
☎ Call MingFree Evaluation