Ming RenBroker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage
☎ 647-779-9186

Buying a Home

Closing Day Arrives and the Deal Can't Close: In Ontario, Separate a Negotiated Extension from a Default

By , Broker, RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc. (About Ming) · Published

Ming Ren · Broker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage

← All articles · Buying a Home · Category guide

I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.

The plain conclusion first: Ontario's standard Agreement of Purchase and Sale says time is of the essence — the closing date is a hard deadline, not a suggestion. When a deal genuinely cannot close that day, there are only two real paths: both sides sign an extension, or one side is in default and the other pursues its remedies under the contract and the law. The dangerous idea is the imaginary third path — "we talked it over, let's just drift a few days." A verbal extension does not hold up, and every day that drifts by, the risk sits with the side that has nothing signed.

First: why closings stall, and at which link

A closing needs three things to land at the same time: the money, clean title, and complete paperwork. If any one fails, the transfer cannot register that day. The most common stall points in practice:

  • The buyer's mortgage funds have not arrived. The lender asks for more documents in the final days, re-reviews the file, or the funding reaches the lawyer's trust account after the registration window. An approved mortgage does not mean the money is sitting with your lawyer on closing morning.
  • The seller's existing mortgage payout is not lined up. The seller's lawyer normally gives the buyer's lawyer a written undertaking to pay out and discharge the old mortgage from the closing proceeds — but discharge statements and the discharge registration itself depend on the lender's timing, which the seller does not control.
  • The title search turns something up. An undischarged lien, tax arrears, an error in the title documents. Most of these must be raised within the requisition period before closing; an issue that surfaces after that deadline is negotiated from a completely different position. The requisition date is not a formality — it is the first gate on whether closing happens on time.
  • A link in a chain breaks. Someone selling and buying on the same day cannot close the purchase if the sale money has not come in; the longer the chain, the more break points.
  • Pure administrative error. A missed signature, a wrong legal description, documents moving slowly between law firms — undramatic, and very common.

Use the list to locate the problem: which link stalled decides how many days an extension needs, how compensation is calculated, and whose responsibility it is.

Second: path one — a negotiated extension, on signed paper only

If both sides are willing to move the closing date, there is exactly one way to do it: an Amendment to the Agreement of Purchase and Sale, with the new closing date written in and both parties' signatures on it, normally drafted and vetted by the two lawyers. Language like "the parties will agree on a new date later" is useless — an extension with no fixed date is no extension at all.

Extensions are usually not free. Sellers commonly ask for two things: a top-up of the deposit, locking in the buyer's commitment, and per-diem compensation for carrying costs such as mortgage interest, property taxes, and insurance. An illustrative example with invented numbers: a home at an illustrative price of $900,000 is extended 7 days; the seller's interest, taxes, and insurance work out to roughly $85 a day, about $595 for the week, plus a $10,000 deposit top-up. The amounts are invented; the structure is real — new date, deposit top-up, and per-diem amount all belong in the signed amendment, not in a total agreed over the phone.

One boundary must stay clear: new homes do not follow this playbook. A purchase from a builder runs on the builder's contract and Tarion's delayed-closing framework, with its own notice procedures and compensation rules — and that framework applies to new homes only. There is no Tarion delayed-closing compensation in a resale deal, so do not demand it from a resale seller; and in a new-home deal, do not sign any extension paper before your lawyer explains what it does to your delay-compensation rights.

Third: path two — one side cannot close, and how the default bill is calculated

With no signed extension, a party who cannot or will not close on the day is exposed to a default claim. But the innocent party has to be standing properly first: your own money ready, your own documents signed — ready, willing and able, with tender made — before you can credibly call the other side in breach. If your own funding has not landed either, hold the accusations.

A cold splash of water as well: time is of the essence is not a trap you get to spring. Ontario courts expect parties to act honestly and cooperate to complete the deal. If the other side's funds arrive a few hours late and they are plainly trying to close, seizing on that to declare the deal dead and keep everything may not survive a courtroom — and can put liability back on you. Whether the delay is hours or weeks, whether the other side communicated early and offered a signed extension — those facts matter more to the outcome than the one line in the contract.

When a default is real, the bill looks roughly like this:

  • Buyer in default: the deposit is usually forfeited first — at law a deposit is an earnest of performance, and the seller generally does not have to prove actual loss before keeping it. And the deposit is not a cap: if the seller resells for less than the contract price, that shortfall, plus provable carrying costs, re-listing costs, and legal fees, can be claimed on top of the deposit.
  • Seller in default: the buyer can claim provable losses, or ask a court for specific performance — an order forcing the sale through. That is a court's decision on the facts of the case, not an automatic right, and both the time and the cost need to be budgeted for.
  • The deposit does not release itself. When a deal collapses, the deposit stays in the brokerage's or lawyer's trust account and neither side can take it unilaterally; it moves only on a mutual release signed by both parties saying who gets it, or on a court order. Fights over the deposit sometimes outlast the deal itself.

Three common misunderstandings

Misunderstanding 1: "The agents agreed on the phone to extend — so we have extended." You have not. An extension exists only in an amendment signed by both parties. Verbal understandings, text-message confirmations, and a nod between agents do not move the closing date in the contract by a single day.

Misunderstanding 2: "Close one day late and the contract automatically dies and the deposit is automatically forfeited." There is no "automatically" here. Whether the other side accepts an extension, whether they take the proper steps to claim a default, how a court views both sides' good faith and the real length of the delay — every step involves judgment. Doing nothing and simply being late does not automatically favour either side.

Misunderstanding 3: "Worst case, I lose the deposit — that is the ceiling on default." The deposit is only the first line of the bill. A resale shortfall and provable costs can be claimed above it — which is exactly how collapsed-closing bills get out of hand. Before treating the deposit as the price of walking away, have your lawyer add up the whole account.

If a delay is brewing on your closing, I suggest this order

  1. A week before closing, ask your lawyer to confirm three things: the mortgage funding instructions, the seller's mortgage payout arrangements, and whether any requisition items are still open. Do not ask for the first time on closing morning.
  2. The day you smell risk, tell your lawyer and your agent. An extension negotiated three days early and one negotiated at noon on closing day come with completely different terms; the side that speaks first usually gets the better deal.
  3. Extensions only on paper: new closing date, deposit top-up, per-diem amount — all written in, all signed, before you move out or give up your rental.
  4. If you are selling and buying the same day, arrange bridge financing with your mortgage broker in advance as a backstop, so one broken link does not collapse the whole chain.
  5. Any formal letter from the other side's lawyer about default or deadlines goes to your lawyer the day it arrives. Do not reply yourself and do not sit on it — the clock in those letters runs from delivery.

I am Ming Ren. A stalled closing is not the disaster; having no signed piece of paper is. Find which link stalled first, and we will work through the documents one by one.


This article is general information, not legal advice. How an extension or a default plays out depends on your agreement's wording, the cause of the delay, and how each side actually performed; consult an Ontario lawyer before acting.

Primary sources: the time-is-of-the-essence clause and amendment practice under Ontario's standard Agreement of Purchase and Sale; Trust in Real Estate Services Act, 2002, s.27 on deposit trust and release (Ontario e-Laws); Tarion's delayed-closing framework for new homes (new homes only) — all consulted November 2026. The $900,000, $85-per-day, and $10,000 figures are illustrative, not a real transaction.

This article in other languages: 中文فارسی

Want to talk about your home?

You can also call directly, or scan the code to add Ming on WeChat.

Ming’s WeChat QR code
Scan to add on WeChat

Community guides by city

All cities →
☎ Call MingFree Evaluation