I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
The plain conclusion first: what stays and what goes is not decided by what you saw at the showing. It is decided by what is written in the Agreement of Purchase and Sale. The default rule has only two halves — fixtures are included in the price unless they are expressly excluded, and chattels are not included unless they are expressly listed. Almost every dispute I see is not about that rule. It is about the grey-area items everyone assumed were too obvious to write down.
1. Learn to sort an item before you argue about it
A fixture is something attached to the property in a way that removing it would cause damage, or that takes tools to detach: built-in light fixtures, cabinetry, installed curtain rods and blinds. A chattel is personal property that can simply be carried away without harming the home: a freestanding fridge, a washer and dryer, furniture.
The rough field test people use is whether a screw has to come out and whether removal leaves a mark on a wall or counter. Treat that as a rule of thumb, not a legal definition. In Ontario, the classification of individual items has always had room for argument — which is exactly why guessing the category is the weakest strategy. Writing the specific item into the contract removes the need to argue about its category at all.
The repeat offenders: the wall mount for a television is a fixture while the television itself is a chattel; curtains and curtain rods are often treated separately; the extra fridge in the basement, the garage storage system, the smart lock and the cameras — every one of them has been assumed by somebody, and somebody has been disappointed by every one of them.
2. There are three boxes in the contract. Do not leave them vague
In the standard OREA APS, the item questions live in three places.
The first is Chattels Included. Every chattel you want must be listed, item by item. Anything not listed is not included. Write items so they can be identified: brand, location and quantity — "the stainless steel French-door fridge in the main-floor kitchen" — not a blanket phrase like "all appliances."
The second is Fixtures Excluded. This is the seller's box. A fixture that would normally stay must be listed here if the seller intends to take it. The chandelier the seller loves, the water filtration system they installed — if it is not excluded in writing, it must be there on closing.
The third is Rental Items. Hot water tanks, water softeners and alarm systems are very often rented, not owned. This box must identify the equipment and say whether the buyer assumes the rental contract. Miss it, and closing can be followed by a monthly rental bill you never agreed to, or by an equipment company saying the contract was never transferred at all.
The standard terms also carry the seller's warranty that the included chattels and fixtures will be in good working order and free of liens and encumbrances on completion. If an included item arrives broken, or still owing money, that warranty is the basis for your claim.
3. The pre-closing visit is for checking a list, not for a tour
However carefully the contract is written, verify it before closing. Most transactions allow the buyer a visit before completion — bring the APS item list and check it, item by item: are the listed appliances present, are they the same ones you saw, has a newer unit been swapped for an older one, and did the removal of excluded items damage walls or counters?
One invented example shows why item-by-item writing matters: the single phrase "washer and dryer included," with no location or count, leaves room for a seller to leave the older laundry pair in the basement and take the newer main-floor set, while arguably staying within the words. "The white front-load washer and dryer in the main-floor laundry room" leaves no such room.
Photographs are evidence. Photograph every item you expect to be included, at the showing and again at the visit, and keep them with the list. In a dispute, photos settle what memory cannot.
Three misunderstandings I hear most often
"The MLS listing said those appliances were included, so it does not matter that the contract is silent." It matters. A listing is not the contract. When there is a dispute, the signed boxes in the APS govern, and an item the listing mentioned but the contract did not is at real risk of being treated as not included — with the risk sitting on the buyer.
"It is screwed to the wall, so it obviously stays and does not need to be written." The default rule points that way, but the classification itself can be argued — wall mounts, built-in shelving, hard-wired lighting have all been argued. One line of writing is far cheaper than one closing-day argument.
"The hot water tank belongs to the seller and comes with the house." Many hot water tanks are rental equipment and are not the seller's property at all, so there is nothing of the seller's to "come with the house." What needs confirming is who assumes the rental contract and at what monthly cost — in the Rental Items box.
Before you sign, do these five things in order
- At the showing, photograph items one by one and build your list of chattels you want and fixtures you want confirmed — do not reconstruct it from memory when the offer is written.
- When the offer is drafted, enter the list item by item under Chattels Included, with brand, location and quantity. Avoid blanket phrases like "all appliances."
- Sellers: list every fixture you intend to take under Fixtures Excluded. Buyers: if that box has entries, go through each one and decide whether you can accept it.
- Verify, item by item, whether the hot water tank, water softener and alarm system are owned or rented. For rentals, write the monthly cost and who assumes the contract into Rental Items.
- At the pre-closing visit, check the contract list against the home, item by item, with your photos. Raise anything missing or swapped in writing that same day, not after closing.
Trust Professional, Diligent Work. I am Ming Ren. Before an offer is signed, bring the item list and we will go through it piece by piece — it is much cheaper than an argument on closing day.
This article is general information only, not legal advice. The classification of a specific item and the terms of your agreement can change the conclusion. Consult an Ontario lawyer before acting.
Primary source: OREA Agreement of Purchase and Sale standard forms (Form 100 / Form 101), Chattels Included, Fixtures Excluded and Rental Items clauses (consulted November 2026). The laundry example is an illustrative scenario, not a real transaction.
Frequently asked questions
The MLS listing said the appliances were included, so does the contract's silence matter?
It matters. A listing is not the contract. When there is a dispute, the signed boxes in the APS govern, and an item the listing mentioned but the contract did not is at real risk of being treated as not included — with the risk sitting on the buyer.
It is screwed to the wall, so it obviously stays — no need to write it?
The default rule points that way, but the classification itself can be argued — wall mounts, built-in shelving, hard-wired lighting have all been argued. One line of writing is far cheaper than one closing-day argument.
The hot water tank belongs to the seller and comes with the house, right?
Many hot water tanks are rental equipment and are not the seller's property at all, so there is nothing of the seller's to come with the house. What needs confirming is who assumes the rental contract and at what monthly cost — in the Rental Items box.


