I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
My conclusion up front: in an Ontario purchase, fixtures are included by default and chattels are excluded by default — unless the agreement says otherwise. Most closing-day arguments are not about bad faith; they happen because, at signing, everyone assumed “that goes without saying.” It does not. Write it down.
First: learn the default rules
A fixture is attached to the home or land and forms part of the property — chandeliers, built-in cabinetry, central air conditioning, fixed window coverings. The rule: it is included, unless it is listed in the agreement's Fixtures Excluded section. A chattel is movable personal property — a freestanding fridge, washer, dryer, furniture, area rugs. The rule runs the other way: it is excluded, unless it is written into the Chattels Included section. The standard Ontario Agreement of Purchase and Sale is built on exactly this logic: fixtures are overridden by an exclusion list, chattels by an inclusion list.
Legally, classification turns on the degree and purpose of attachment, and the grey zone is wide: TV wall mounts, chandeliers, drapes, built-in speakers and garage remotes generate disputes again and again. Because the test itself is flexible, the only safe approach is to name items one by one.
Second: rental equipment is a third category — do not mix it in
Hot water tanks, furnaces, air conditioners and water softeners are very often rented. The seller does not own them and cannot “include” them. The agreement has a Rental Items section: which items are rented, whether the buyer assumes the rental contracts, and at what monthly cost. Before signing, confirm ownership of every major system — owned or rented. Discovering after closing that the water heater comes with a long rental contract is one of the most common buyer surprises.
Third: write it down to the model and the condition
Do not write just “fridge” on the inclusion list. Write the brand, model, or at least colour and location — “stainless double-door fridge in kitchen.” Condition matters too: standard agreement wording addresses included chattels and fixtures being in good working order on completion, as set out in the clauses you sign. Photograph rooms at viewings, then use the pre-closing walk-through to check the list item by item: is it there, is it the same unit, does it work? Raise problems before closing through your agent and lawyer; chasing them afterwards costs far more.
Common misunderstandings
One: “If it hangs on the wall, it stays.” Not necessarily. Attachment is a matter of degree and purpose; artwork and the TV itself are often chattels. If you want it, list it as included.
Two: “The MLS listing said it was included, so I am covered.” Listing copy is marketing. The signed agreement governs. If it is in the listing but not in the agreement, it is hard to claim on closing day.
Three: “The seller swapped the chandelier for a cheap one — am I overreacting?” No. Naming brand, model and the as-viewed condition in the list exists precisely to prevent substitutions. One extra line at signing saves an argument at closing.
Action checklist
- Photograph every room at viewings, especially appliances, light fixtures, window coverings and anything you expect to stay.
- Before offering, draft two lists — chattels to include, fixtures to confirm — with brand, model and location for each item.
- Confirm whether the furnace, air conditioner and water heater are owned or rented, and the rental terms if rented.
- Before signing, verify the Chattels Included, Fixtures Excluded and Rental Items sections against your lists.
- At the pre-closing walk-through, check items off the list and test appliances; report problems to your agent and lawyer immediately.
— Ming Ren, Broker, RE/MAX Realtron
This article is general information, not legal advice. How a specific item is classified depends on the facts and the agreement wording; consult an Ontario lawyer on disputes.
Primary sources: the Chattels Included, Fixtures Excluded and Rental Items provisions of the standard Ontario Agreement of Purchase and Sale (OREA forms) and the common-law annexation test (reviewed November 2026).
Frequently asked questions
If it hangs on the wall, does it stay?
Not necessarily. Attachment is a matter of degree and purpose; artwork and the TV itself are often chattels, so if you want it, list it as included.
The MLS listing said it was included, so am I covered?
Listing copy is marketing and the signed agreement governs. If it is in the listing but not in the agreement, it is hard to claim on closing day.
The seller swapped the chandelier for a cheap one; am I overreacting?
No. Naming brand, model and the as-viewed condition in the list exists precisely to prevent substitutions; one extra line at signing saves an argument at closing.


