Ming RenBroker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage
☎ 647-779-9186

Buying a Home

A High Review Score Is Not a Contract: Vetting a Renovation Contractor in Ontario

By , Broker, RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc. (About Ming) · Published

Ming Ren · Broker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage

← All articles · Buying a Home · Category guide

I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.

The plain conclusion first: a review platform is a tool for building a shortlist, not for making the decision. A score and a stack of good reviews can only tell you "this company is worth talking to." What actually protects you is the checking you do yourself, and a written contract that says the right things. Doing it the other way around — letting the score convince you first and treating the paperwork as a formality — is how most renovation disputes begin.

This article covers three things: how to read reviews, how to verify the company, and how the contract should be signed.

1. Read the reviews themselves, not just the score

On any review platform, an overall score compresses many different jobs from different years into a single number. A countertop swap and a kitchen gut with moved plumbing are both "kitchen renovations," but they are not the same difficulty — yet the score mixes them together. When you read reviews, I suggest you look at four things only:

  • Recent beats old. Read the reviews from the last few months first. Renovation crews turn over quickly; praise from two or three years ago may describe people who no longer work there.
  • Watch how complaints end. Almost no company has zero negative reviews. What matters is what the complaint was about, whether the company responded, and whether it got resolved. The warning sign is not one bad review — it is the same problem, delays, price increases, going silent, showing up in different customers' stories.
  • Detail beats adjectives. A review that describes the scope of work, the timeline, what went wrong and how it was fixed is worth trusting. One that only says "very professional, highly recommend" tells you almost nothing — and the same goes for vague one-star reviews.
  • Match the job to your job. If you are finishing a basement, weight the reviews from basement clients, not a pile of praise for painting and flooring.

There is also a step no platform can do for you: ask the contractor for at least three references from clients who had similar work done, and call them yourself. Ontario's consumer guidance gives the same advice — get references from the recent past and from further back, because some problems, like roofing or paving defects, only show up a year or more later.

2. Before you sign, verify the company and its licences

However good the reviews look, first confirm who you are actually dealing with. One operator can run several businesses, or reopen under a new name, so search both the business name and the operator's own name:

  • Check the province's Consumer Beware List for complaints or charges against the company and the operator, and look at recent postings of charges and convictions under the Consumer Protection Act.
  • Ask whether the workers have valid WSIB (Workplace Safety and Insurance Board) coverage, and, for licensed trades, whether they hold certification from Skilled Trades Ontario.
  • Electrical work may only be done by a company holding an ESA/ECRA electrical contractor licence. The licence number should appear on the estimate, and you should receive the certificate of inspection when the work is done, where one is required.
  • For a major project, ask your municipality whether a building permit is needed. The permit is the homeowner's responsibility; if you want the contractor to obtain it for you, that must be written into the contract — and do not let work start until you have seen the permit.

None of this costs money; it costs half a day. A reputable company will not mind being checked. And a contractor who insists "sign today or the price is gone" has already answered your question.

3. How the contract is written is what protects you

Most of the protection Ontario's Consumer Protection Act, 2002 gives a renovation homeowner is delivered through a proper written contract. A home renovation contract worth more than $50 must be in writing, and it should state at least the following:

Term How specific it needs to be
The parties The contractor's name, business name, address and contact information
The work What will be done and what materials will be used, with the estimate attached as part of the contract
Price and payment The total cost, the terms of payment, a payment schedule, and the deposit amount
Schedule A start date and a completion date
The rest The warranty terms, who is responsible for clean-up, which work is subcontracted out, and who pays the sub-trades

Three rules are worth remembering before you sign anything:

First, there is a cap on estimate overruns. If the written estimate forms part of your contract, the final price cannot be more than 10% above the estimate — unless you agreed to new work or a new price and signed a change to the contract. Mid-project extras come after a signature, not after a verbal okay.

Second, keep the deposit small. Ontario's guidance recommends a down payment of no more than 10% of the total price. That is a recommendation, not a statutory cap, but the logic is simple: whoever holds the money holds the leverage. An invented example, for illustration only: on a $60,000 basement project (illustrative figure), a 10% deposit is $6,000. If the contractor asks for half — $30,000 (illustrative figure) — "to buy materials," ask yourself whether a real company has no credit terms of its own. And whatever happens, never pay the full amount before the work is finished.

Third, a contract signed in your home carries a 10-day cooling-off period. If the contract is worth $50 or more and you sign it in your home, you have 10 calendar days to cancel for any reason, with no cancellation fee. One caution: if you asked the contractor to start work during that period and then cancel, you still owe reasonable compensation for the work done and materials supplied.

Three misunderstandings I hear most often

"A high score and lots of reviews mean the company is reliable." A score is a summary of other people's experiences, not a guarantee issued to you. It can screen out companies with obvious problems; it cannot screen out "wrong fit for your project." The final check is always your own verification and your contract.

"A friend recommended them, so I can skip the checking and the detailed contract." Ontario's guidance makes a point of this: even with a personal recommendation, get three references and check them. A recommendation answers "where did you find them." It does not answer "what happens if something goes wrong" — that is the contract's job.

"A bigger deposit gets me scheduled sooner and makes them take the job more seriously." It is usually the opposite. The further ahead your money is, the less leverage you keep. Payments should follow completed work, not the contractor's cash-flow needs.

If you are about to renovate, do these five things in order

  1. Write down exactly what you want done and set your budget first; then build your candidate list from review platforms and personal referrals. Do not keep changing the scope while you negotiate.
  2. Get at least three written estimates — Ontario's guidance says at least three — and only count an estimate given after the contractor has inspected the site in person. A price quoted over the phone is not an estimate.
  3. For each finalist, search the Consumer Beware List and the charges postings, verify WSIB coverage and any relevant licences, and call at least three past clients who had similar work done.
  4. Before signing, check the contract line by line: Is the estimate included? Is the deposit held to around 10%? Are the schedule and the subcontracting arrangements written down? Do changes require a signed document first?
  5. If you sign at home, mark the end of the cooling-off period on your calendar. Use those 10 days to think it over, and ask a lawyer about anything unclear — before the work starts, not after.

Trust Professional, Diligent Work. I am Ming Ren. If you have bought a home and are planning a renovation, clear the two gates first — the people and the contract — and only then talk about style and finishes. Bring the paperwork and we will go through it, item by item.


This article is general information only, not legal advice. The size of your project, where you sign, and the type of contract can all affect your rights. Consult an Ontario lawyer before acting.

Primary sources: Consumer Protection Act, 2002, S.O. 2002, c.30, Sched. A, ss.10, 41–43 (Ontario e-Laws, consulted November 2026); Ontario consumer guidance, "Your rights when starting home renovations or repairs" and "A guide for home renovation and roofing businesses" (ontario.ca, consulted November 2026). The $60,000, $6,000 and $30,000 figures are illustrative only, not a real transaction.

Frequently asked questions

A high score and lots of reviews mean the company is reliable?

A score is a summary of other people's experiences, not a guarantee issued to you. It can screen out companies with obvious problems; it cannot screen out “wrong fit for your project.” The final check is always your own verification and your contract.

A friend recommended them, so I can skip the checking and the detailed contract?

Ontario's guidance makes a point of this: even with a personal recommendation, get three references and check them. A recommendation answers “where did you find them.” It does not answer “what happens if something goes wrong” — that is the contract's job.

A bigger deposit gets me scheduled sooner and makes them take the job more seriously?

It is usually the opposite. The further ahead your money is, the less leverage you keep. Payments should follow completed work, not the contractor's cash-flow needs.

This article in other languages: 中文فارسی

Want to talk about your home?

You can also call directly, or scan the code to add Ming on WeChat.

Ming’s WeChat QR code
Scan to add on WeChat

Community guides by city

All cities →
☎ Call MingFree Evaluation