I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
The plain conclusion first: screening tenants is entirely legal in Ontario. What gets landlords into trouble is not checking — it is checking the wrong things, or refusing someone for the wrong reason. The law sets out a short list of information you may request, and it is equally clear about what may never drive your decision. Keep those two lists separate and the whole process stays on solid ground.
In my years working with landlord clients, the question I hear most is exactly this: how far am I allowed to go? So let me go by the regulation itself — not by industry habit, and not by any scoring sheet. Ontario has never issued landlords a scorecard, and you should not invent one.
1. What the regulation allows you to request — and that is the whole list
Ontario Regulation 290/98, made under the Human Rights Code, deals specifically with information requests in rental housing. It sets out the information a landlord may request from a prospective tenant, and the list is this:
| You may request | What it means in practice |
|---|---|
| Income information | Used to assess whether the applicant can carry this rent — but it comes with conditions, covered in the next section |
| A credit check | A check of the applicant's credit record; obtain the applicant's consent before you run it |
| Credit references | References bearing on the applicant's credit history |
| Rental history | Where the applicant has lived and how they paid; this can be checked with previous landlords |
| A guarantee | Where the circumstances support it, you may ask the applicant to provide a guarantor |
Treat this list as closed. If something is not on it, do not add it on your own — and above all, do not add an extra layer of demands only for applicants of a particular background. Use the same application form, the same questions, and the same verification steps for every applicant. That consistency is your strongest evidence. If your process is ever challenged, what protects you is not saying "I don't discriminate" — it is producing a record that shows everyone went through exactly the same process.
2. Income: you may ask, but only alongside the rest, and never on its own
Income is the item the regulation restricts most carefully, and the one landlords most often misuse.
Under O. Reg. 290/98, a landlord may request income information only if the landlord also requests credit references, a credit check, and rental history. In other words, income cannot be the only thing you ask for. It has to sit in the same basket as the applicant's credit and rental history.
The companion rule matters even more: the information must be considered together. A landlord must not refuse an applicant based on any one factor on its own. The Ontario Human Rights Commission's rental housing policy makes the same point in practical terms: using a fixed rent-to-income ratio as a hard cut-off — meet the ratio or be refused — does not hold up. The reason is simple. What share of income a person chooses to spend on rent is their own household decision. Your job is to assess whether they can pay this rent and whether they have paid reliably in the past, not to judge whether what is left over looks like enough to live on.
An invented example, for illustration only: an applicant earns $4,000 a month and applies for a unit at $1,600 a month. On ratio alone, some landlords would stop right there. But if the credit record is clean and the previous landlord confirms three years of rent paid on time, every time, the regulation expects you to weigh those things together — not to let one ratio make the decision for you. The reverse is also true: a high income does not cancel out a chaotic credit and rental history. No single line on the application decides the outcome, in either direction.
3. A guarantor is allowed — but the reason can never be who the applicant is
When an applicant's credit record is thin or there is no local rental history to check, asking for a guarantor is a permitted step. The line to hold is this: the request must rest on a genuine gap in the information available about that applicant, not on the group the applicant belongs to.
In housing, the Human Rights Code protects applicants on grounds that include race, ancestry, place of origin, colour, ethnic origin, citizenship, creed, sex, sexual orientation, gender identity and expression, age, marital status, family status, disability, and receipt of public assistance. Refusing an applicant, treating them differently, or demanding a guarantor only from them because of one of these grounds crosses the line. You cannot, for example, require a guarantor only from an applicant who receives social assistance, or add conditions for a newcomer or a family with children that you do not impose on anyone else.
The compliant way to handle it is to write the guarantor requirement as one standard that applies to everyone: any applicant who cannot provide a verifiable credit record or rental history is asked to provide a guarantor. That screens for an objective fact — missing information — not for an identity. And the standard applied to the guarantor should not be harsher than the standard applied to applicants themselves. A guarantee fills an information gap; it is not a second, higher gate.
Three misunderstandings I hear most often
"Asking a lot of questions and checking thoroughly is itself discrimination." It is not. The regulation expressly permits income information, credit checks, credit references and rental history. The problem is never how much you check — it is whether you check the same things for everyone, and whether a protected ground is doing the deciding.
"A fixed rent-to-income cut-off is the fastest way to screen." Fast, but offside. The regulation requires income, credit references, a credit check and rental history to be considered together, and no single factor may decide the result on its own. A ratio cut-off is exactly the practice of letting income decide alone.
"Asking applicants on assistance, or newcomers, for a guarantor is just being careful." If the extra demand lands only on one kind of applicant, and the reason traces back to who they are, it is not caution — it is differential treatment. A guarantor requirement may only attach to a genuine information gap, applied the same way to everyone who has one.
If you are screening an applicant right now, do these five things in order
- Prepare one standard application form that asks only for what the regulation allows — income, credit references, rental history, and a guarantee where relevant — and use that same form for every applicant, with no improvised extra questions.
- Before running a credit check, get the applicant's consent and keep a record of it.
- Collect income, credit and rental history together before you judge anything. Do not eliminate anyone early on income alone.
- If you need a guarantor, write down your uniform standard first — what information gap triggers the requirement — then apply it by the book, not by the person in front of you.
- Keep a file for every applicant: what you asked, what you checked, and what your decision rested on. If a complaint ever reaches the Human Rights Tribunal, that file is your defence.
Trust Professional, Diligent Work. I am Ming Ren. If you are unsure about the screening step on a rental, bring your application form and your process, and we will go through them against the regulation, item by item.
This article is general information only, not legal advice. The applicant's circumstances, the type of housing, and current policy guidance can change the conclusion. Consult an Ontario lawyer before acting.
Primary sources: O. Reg. 290/98 under the Human Rights Code, R.S.O. 1990 (Ontario e-Laws); Ontario Human Rights Commission, Policy on Human Rights and Rental Housing. The $4,000 and $1,600 figures are illustrative only, not a real case.
Frequently asked questions
Is asking a lot of questions and checking thoroughly itself discrimination?
No. The regulation expressly permits income information, credit checks, credit references and rental history. The problem is whether you check the same things for everyone and whether a protected ground is doing the deciding.
Can I refuse an applicant whose rent exceeds a fixed share of income?
No. Income, credit references, a credit check and rental history must be considered together, and no single factor may decide the result on its own. A ratio cut-off is exactly letting income decide alone.
Is asking applicants on assistance or newcomers for a guarantor just being careful?
If the extra demand lands only on one kind of applicant and traces back to who they are, it is differential treatment, not caution. A guarantor requirement may only attach to a genuine information gap, applied the same way to everyone who has one.


