Ming RenBroker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage
☎ 647-779-9186

Tax

You Gutted and Rebuilt the House. Is the Sale Subject to 13% HST? Two Tests Must Both Be Met

By , Broker, RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc. (About Ming) · Published

Ming Ren · Broker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage

← All articles · Tax · Category guide

I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.

The conclusion first: a sale of a used home is normally an exempt supply — no HST. But the Excise Tax Act has a doorway: renovate thoroughly enough, and be in the business of doing it, and the old house is treated for HST purposes much like a newly built one, potentially taxable at Ontario's 13%. Both conditions must hold at the same time. Miss either one and you are usually back to the ordinary exempt resale. This article is about whether HST applies at all, not about computing it.

1. What counts as a "substantial renovation" — structure comes out first, then the 90% test

The statutory term is not the same as a "big renovation" in everyday speech. Under s.123(1) of the Excise Tax Act, a substantial renovation means renovating or altering a building to such an extent that all or substantially all of the building that existed just before the work began — other than the foundation, external walls, interior supporting walls, floors, roof and staircases — has been removed or replaced, and the building is still a residential complex when the work is done.

That exclusion list is the key to the whole rule. Keeping the shell and structure while gutting the inside is exactly the situation the definition contemplates. "I never touched the load-bearing walls or the roof" does not get you out — those elements were never in the calculation. What is measured is everything else. CRA's GST/HST Technical Information Bulletin B-092 puts it plainly: in a project of this kind, the interior of the building is essentially gutted.

How is "all or substantially all" measured? CRA reads it in B-092 as 90% or more, and accepts any fair and reasonable method, for example:

Method How it is calculated
Floor area Renovated floor area ÷ total floor area
Floor plus wall area Renovated floor and wall area ÷ total area
Room count Rooms renovated ÷ total rooms (for example, 9 of 10 rooms = 90%)

B-092 is equally clear about what does not count: the cost of the renovation and the increase in market value are not a basis for the determination. "I spent a fortune" and "the appraisal doubled" do not answer this question either way.

2. Is the renovator a "builder"? That turns on the nature of the activity

The same gut renovation can land two different ways depending on who did it and why:

Individual renovating for their own home Person in the renovation business
Tax status Not a builder: paragraph (f) of the s.123(1) builder definition excludes an individual who does the work otherwise than in the course of a business or an adventure in the nature of trade A builder: while holding an interest in the property, they carry out or engage another person to carry out the substantial renovation, in the course of a business or an adventure in the nature of trade
Treatment on sale Schedule V, Part I, s.2: a non-builder's sale of a residential complex is exempt s.4's exemption for builders is carved back by paragraph (c) for a complex the builder acquired and then substantially renovated — the sale is a taxable supply
Watch out for If input tax credits (ITCs) were claimed on the purchase or the improvements, the s.2 exemption does not apply An individual builder may still fit the personal-use exit below; a corporation cannot use the paragraph (f) exclusion, which is written for individuals

What decides status is the nature of the activity, not the size of the job. Where these cases actually go wrong is a mismatch between the story and the facts: the home was never genuinely lived in before it was listed, or the same person has done several in a row over a short period. The statute judges facts, not self-descriptions. If you are anywhere near the line, assemble the timeline — why you bought, when the work happened, how the home was actually used afterwards — before you ask a tax professional to rule on it.

One practical signing point: whether the price is "plus HST" or "HST included" must be settled in the offer itself. If the supply turns out to be taxable and the agreement is silent, the difference between collecting HST on top of the price and absorbing it out of the price is a full tax bill, and it tends to surface a week before closing, when there is no time left to fix it.

3. An individual builder still has one exit: genuine personal use

Even if you meet the builder definition, Schedule V, Part I, s.3 can still exempt an individual's sale. The conditions: at some point after the substantial renovation was substantially completed, the complex was used primarily as a place of residence for you, an individual related to you, or a former spouse or common-law partner — and before that point it was not used primarily for any other purpose. The same ITC condition applies: you must not have claimed ITCs on acquiring the real property or on the improvements.

Note what the section does not contain: any minimum number of days of residence. It tests the fact of primary residential use, and what the property was mainly used for before that. If someone has quoted you a specific number of days, it did not come from this provision.

Keep one neighbouring rule separate. The Income Tax Act's flipped-property rule — a housing unit sold within 365 days is treated as business income, with life-event exceptions — decides how income is taxed, and it says on its face that it applies for the purposes of that Act. Whether HST is charged is decided separately under the Excise Tax Act's builder definition and Schedule V. Selling within a year does not automatically mean HST applies, and holding past a year does not automatically mean it does not.

Three common misunderstandings

"We only redid the kitchen and bathrooms, so it can't be substantial." Kitchens and baths alone usually are not enough — but the test is run on the whole building: after excluding the structural elements, was 90% or more of what existed removed or replaced? Run the area or room-count math before concluding.

"The renovation cost a fortune, so it must be substantial." Cost and value increase are expressly excluded by CRA as a basis. An inexpensive but complete gutting can qualify; an expensive partial renovation may not.

"Live there for a set number of days and the HST goes away." Section 3 sets no day count. It looks at primary residential use after completion, no primary other use before that point, and whether ITCs were claimed.

If you are about to sell a heavily renovated home, I suggest this order

  1. Do a rough self-check using B-092's methods: excluding foundation, external walls, interior supporting walls, floors, roof and staircases, roughly what share of the interior was removed or replaced?
  2. Put the facts on one page: purchase date and purpose, renovation start and finish, who lived there afterwards and for what, and whether any ITCs were claimed.
  3. Before signing an offer, have an accountant or tax lawyer confirm on those facts: are you a builder, is the sale exempt or taxable, and how should the agreement state the HST treatment of the price?
  4. If the sale is taxable, deal with the HST allocation in the offer, not when the buyer's lawyer raises it during requisitions.
  5. Keep the renovation contracts, invoices and completion photos on file — if CRA ever asks about the 90% or the use, records answer, not recollections.

Trust Professional, Diligent Work. I am Ming Ren. I will not rule on your taxes for you — but arriving at your tax professional's office with the facts organized will save you several rounds of back and forth.


This article is general information only, not tax or legal advice. Different facts can produce a completely different answer. Have an accountant or tax lawyer confirm your situation before you sign.

Primary sources: Excise Tax Act, s.123(1) (definitions of "builder" and "substantial renovation") and Schedule V, Part I, ss.2–4 (Justice Laws); CRA GST/HST Technical Information Bulletin B-092 (consulted November 2026).

Frequently asked questions

We only redid the kitchen and bathrooms, so it can't be substantial, right?

Kitchens and baths alone usually are not enough, but the test is run on the whole building: after excluding the structural elements, was 90% or more of what existed removed or replaced? Run the area or room-count math before concluding.

The renovation cost a fortune, so it must be substantial, right?

Cost and value increase are expressly excluded by CRA as a basis. An inexpensive but complete gutting can qualify; an expensive partial renovation may not.

If I live there for a set number of days, does the HST go away?

Section 3 sets no day count. It looks at primary residential use after completion, no primary other use before that point, and whether ITCs were claimed.

This article in other languages: 中文فارسی

Want to talk about your home?

You can also call directly, or scan the code to add Ming on WeChat.

Ming’s WeChat QR code
Scan to add on WeChat

Community guides by city

All cities →
☎ Call MingFree Evaluation