I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
Here is the plain conclusion first: having listed a home for short stays does not, by itself, make its sale taxable. Most homes that were lived in, rented long-term, or only occasionally rented short-term are still sold tax-exempt. The real risk is narrow — a property that has been run, over a sustained period, in a hotel-like way, with almost all of its arrangements for short stays. In that case it may no longer count as a home in tax law at all, and the exemption written for homes may not reach it. Sort out the facts before you list, not at closing.
1. Why a resale home is usually exempt
Section 2 of Part I of Schedule V to Canada's Excise Tax Act makes a sale of a residential complex by a person who is not its builder an exempt supply. In ordinary language: you bought a resale home, you did not build it, and when you sell it on, the sale normally carries no HST. In Ontario that HST rate is 13% — a 5% federal part plus an 8% provincial part — and on a taxable sale it is calculated on the sale price, which is why the number worries people, understandably.
Two limits matter. First, the exemption does not apply in the way people expect if the seller claimed an input tax credit on the last acquisition of the property or on improvements made after acquiring it; the section expressly carves that situation out. Second — and this is the point of this article — the exemption protects a "residential complex." If the property has fallen outside that definition, the exemption has nothing to attach to. So the question is never simply whether you did short-term rentals. It is whether, at the time of sale, the property is still a residential complex.
2. When a property can fall outside the definition
Subsection 123(1) of the Excise Tax Act defines "residential complex" and excludes one category. In substance, a building, or part of a building, is not included if it is a hotel, motel, inn, boarding house, lodging house or other similar premises, and all or substantially all of the leases, licences or similar arrangements for its residential units provide for periods of continuous possession or use of less than 60 days.
That sentence contains two conditions, and both must be met at the same time:
| Condition | What is examined | What to note |
|---|---|---|
| Hotel-like premises | Is it a hotel, motel, inn, boarding house, lodging house or other similar premises? | CRA Policy P-099 looks at the overall picture — temporary accommodation offered to the public, furnished rooms, check-in arrangements and similar factors — not at whether a particular platform was used |
| Enough short stays | Do all or substantially all arrangements provide for continuous stays of less than 60 days? | The statute sets no percentage. CRA Policy P-053 generally reads "all or substantially all" as 90% or more — an administrative reading, not a number written into the Act |
Miss either condition and the property does not fall out of the definition on this ground. A furnished unit offered year-round but rented half the time on leases of three months or more will generally not meet the proportion test. A home rented short-term at a very high proportion, but which in substance is still an ordinary home let out when the owner is away, raises a real question on the first condition — and that question is answered on all the facts, not on the proportion alone.
On how the proportion is calculated, P-053 allows a method that is appropriate in the circumstances and used consistently — for example, based on revenues or on room nights — over a period that is reasonable, normally about a year, with seasonal operations treated accordingly. You cannot pick the single month that helps you most, and you cannot switch methods year to year to get a lower answer. The method has to be defensible and consistent.
An illustrative example, using invented numbers only to show the scale: if a property sold for $800,000 and that sale were taxable, 13% would be $104,000. That is not a rounding item to be negotiated on closing day; it changes the seller's net proceeds in a major way. That is why an owner who has run intensive short-term rentals should confirm the property's status before pricing the listing. These figures are illustrative only, not a real transaction.
3. Two related points that are easy to miss
First, tax on the rental income side and exemption on the sale are separate questions. Whether GST/HST had to be charged on accommodation, and whether the owner had to register, turn on different rules about the nature and amount of the supplies. "The sale may be exempt" does not prove the nightly rentals were handled correctly, and the reverse is also true.
Second, changing the use of a property can itself have tax consequences. Moving a property from personal or long-term rental use into intensive short-term use, or moving it back again before a sale, can engage the change-in-use rules in the Excise Tax Act in some circumstances. It is not safe to assume that switching back to a long-term tenant shortly before listing simply restores the old status and erases the history. That switch is itself a step that needs to be assessed. Whether it triggers anything, and in what amount, depends on your purchase, filing and operating history, and it needs a tax professional — it is not calculated in this article.
A timing point is worth adding: status is assessed on the property's actual use and the full facts around the sale, not only on what the owner originally intended when buying it. An intention formed years ago does not replace the operating record at the time you sell.
Three misunderstandings I hear most often
"I used a short-term rental platform once, so I owe 13% on the sale." No. Both conditions must be met together — hotel-like premises, and all or substantially all arrangements for stays of less than 60 days. Occasional rentals are a long way from that line.
"90% is written in the law, so 89% is automatically safe." The 90% figure comes from CRA's administrative reading in Policy P-053. The statute itself says "all or substantially all." Near that line, the calculation method, the period examined and the overall way the property was operated all matter. Do not treat an administrative yardstick as a precise safe harbour you can plan to sit just under.
"60 days and one month are the same test — a stay of a month or more fixes everything." They are not the same. Less than 60 days is the test in this residential complex exclusion. Other parts of the tax rules use a one-month concept for different questions. Measuring with the wrong ruler produces the opposite answer.
If you are about to sell a property that was rented short-term, do these five things in order
- Lay out the property's use year by year: how much was personal use, long-term rental and short-term rental, and how long each short stay lasted, so you have a factual picture you can actually read.
- Keep the underlying records — platform booking details, check-in and check-out dates, long-term leases and payment records — not just annual summaries. The operating pattern is proved from those records.
- Gather whether you ever claimed an input tax credit for this property, and whether you registered for and filed GST/HST. That history directly affects whether the resale exemption is available.
- Before you set a list price, get a written opinion from an accountant or tax lawyer experienced in GST/HST on whether this property is still a residential complex, and ask whether any change-in-use history needs to be dealt with.
- Price and draft the agreement only after that opinion is in hand. If the sale may be taxable, how the price is negotiated, who bears the tax and what the agreement says all need to be settled before signing, not argued about at closing.
Trust Professional, Diligent Work. I am Ming Ren. If you are selling a property that was rented short-term, bring the use records and we will go through the facts item by item — and leave the tax conclusion to a tax professional, in writing.
This article is general information only, not tax or legal advice. Whether a property is a residential complex depends on its operating history, the structure of its arrangements and its filing record. Consult an accountant or lawyer experienced in GST/HST before acting.
Primary sources: Excise Tax Act, R.S.C. 1985, c. E-15, s.123(1) definition of residential complex and Schedule V, Part I, s.2 (laws-lois.justice.gc.ca, consulted November 2026); CRA GST/HST Policy Statement P-053 (90% administrative reading of all or substantially all) and P-099 (meaning of hotel and similar premises) (canada.ca). The $800,000 and $104,000 figures are illustrative only, not a real transaction.
Frequently asked questions
I used a short-term rental platform once — do I owe 13% HST on the sale?
No. Both conditions must be met together — hotel-like premises, and all or substantially all arrangements for stays of less than 60 days. Occasional rentals are a long way from that line.
90% is written in the law, so is 89% automatically safe?
The 90% figure comes from CRA's administrative reading in Policy P-053; the statute itself says 'all or substantially all.' Near that line, the calculation method, the period examined and the overall way the property was operated all matter, so do not treat the administrative yardstick as a precise safe harbour.
Are the 60-day test and the one-month test the same thing?
They are not the same. Less than 60 days is the test in this residential complex exclusion, while other parts of the tax rules use a one-month concept for different questions. Measuring with the wrong ruler produces the opposite answer.


