I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
Here is the plain conclusion first: the tenant who pulls the battery has broken the law — and your duty as landlord has not shrunk by one inch. Ontario's fire rules run on two parallel lines. Whether the alarm keeps working is, in law, the landlord's problem. And nobody, tenant included, is allowed to disable one. If there is ever a fire, investigators will not let you off because "the tenant did it." They will ask the next question: where are your testing and maintenance records?
So the real work is not arguing after the fact. It is doing the required steps during the tenancy, and keeping the paper trail. Three parts follow.
1. Maintenance is the landlord's job — the Code says so, by name
The Ontario Fire Code (O. Reg. 213/07) is unusually direct. Article 6.3.3.2 provides that in a rental unit, only the landlord is considered to be the "owner" of the smoke alarms, and its definition of "landlord" expressly states that it does not include the tenant. Carbon monoxide alarms carry the same rule in Article 6.3.4.2.
In practice, the landlord carries these duties:
| Duty | Fire Code reference | What it means |
|---|---|---|
| Install correctly | 2.13.2.1 (smoke), 2.16.2.1 (CO) | Required locations, power supply and standard |
| Keep in operating condition | 6.3.3.3, 6.3.4.3 | The alarm, and its primary and backup power, must stay in operating condition |
| Give the tenant the instructions | 6.3.3.4, 6.3.4.4 | Provide a copy of the manufacturer's maintenance instructions to the tenant |
| Test on schedule | 6.3.3.8, 6.3.4.8 | Test annually and after every change in tenancy; CO alarms also after a change of residents |
| Respond when told | Duty arising from 6.3.3.5 | When the tenant reports an alarm disconnected, not operating or impaired, repair or replace it promptly |
Notice what kind of duty this is: it runs for the whole tenancy. A perfect installation on move-in day, followed by three years without a single test, does not satisfy it. And a lease clause saying "tenant maintains the alarms and changes the batteries" does not move it — the Code assigns the "owner" role to the landlord by law, and a private contract cannot rewrite that.
2. The tenant broke the law. That does not end your exposure.
Article 6.3.3.6 is one short sentence: no person shall disable a smoke alarm. Article 6.3.4.6 says the same for CO alarms. Pulling the battery or taking the alarm down is the textbook case of disabling one.
Contravening the Fire Code is an offence under section 28 of the Fire Protection and Prevention Act, 1997. For an individual, the penalty on a first offence is a fine of up to $50,000, up to $100,000 for a subsequent offence, or up to one year in jail, or both. Those are the statutory maximums, and they apply to the tenant who pulled the battery just as they apply to a landlord who never installed one.
But here is the point landlords most often get wrong: the tenant's offence does not cancel the landlord's duty. The two lines are assessed separately. A fire investigation, and an insurance claim, will look at both questions at once — did the tenant disable the alarm, and did the landlord install, hand over the instructions, test on schedule, and respond to reports? Winning the first question does not answer the second. What actually protects you is a dated record: which unit, which date, what result, who tested. Without it, "the tenant pulled the battery" carries very little weight.
The tenant also carries a duty of their own. Under Article 6.3.3.5, a tenant who becomes aware that an alarm is disconnected, not operating or impaired must notify the landlord as soon as possible. A tenant who stays silent — or worse, creates the problem — is in a poor position when responsibility is divided.
3. A tenant who keeps doing it: the landlord's tools under the RTA
The Fire Code handles safety and prosecution. The tenancy itself is governed by the Residential Tenancies Act, 2006 (RTA) — and which tool fits depends on exactly what the tenant did. Choosing the wrong one is a common and avoidable error.
- Battery pulled, nothing damaged: That is usually not "undue damage." The closer fit is section 64 — the tenant's conduct substantially interferes with a lawful right or interest of the landlord, because the landlord has a statutory duty to keep the alarm working and the tenant's act directly obstructs it. A section 64 notice gives a termination date no earlier than the 20th day after it is given, and a 7-day window to correct the conduct; if the tenant corrects it, the notice is void.
- Alarm smashed or destroyed: Now it is damage. Section 34 makes the tenant responsible for repairing undue damage caused wilfully or negligently by the tenant, another occupant, or a guest. A section 62 notice sets a termination date no earlier than the 20th day and gives 7 days to repair or pay. If the damage was wilful, section 63 allows a termination date no earlier than the 10th day, with no 7-day cure window.
- Getting in to test or repair: You cannot force your way in. Under section 27 of the RTA, give the tenant at least 24 hours' written notice and enter between 8 a.m. and 8 p.m. for repair, replacement or inspection. Keep a copy of the notice — it is also evidence that you tried to fulfil your duty.
Put simply: decide first whether the tenant disabled the alarm or damaged it. If the facts do not match the section you cite, the application will not hold up at the Landlord and Tenant Board.
Three misunderstandings I hear most often
"The tenant pulled the battery, so a fire is not my problem." It is still your problem. The tenant's act breaches Article 6.3.3.6; your maintenance and testing duties are a separate line. They run in parallel and do not cancel each other out.
"My lease says the tenant maintains the alarms, so I am covered." You are not. Article 6.3.3.2 fixes the "owner" role on the landlord by law and excludes the tenant from the definition of landlord. The clause may describe a private arrangement between you and the tenant; it does not stop a prosecution under section 28 of the FPPA.
"It was compliant when installed, so it stays compliant." No. The Code requires the alarm to remain in operating condition for the entire tenancy: test annually, test at every turnover, respond when a fault is reported. Installation is only the first link in the chain.
If you found a missing battery today, do these five things in order
- Restore the alarm immediately — replace the battery or the alarm, press the test button to confirm it sounds, and record the date, the unit, what you did and the result, with a photo.
- Remind the tenant in writing of two things: no one may disable an alarm (Article 6.3.3.6), and a tenant must report a non-working alarm right away (Article 6.3.3.5). Send it by email so there is a record.
- Audit your own paper trail: when was the last annual test, were the manufacturer's instructions handed over, is there a sign-off? Fill the gaps now, not after an incident.
- If the tenant refuses entry for testing or repair, use section 27 of the RTA — at least 24 hours' written notice, entry between 8 a.m. and 8 p.m.
- If the tenant keeps disabling alarms and refuses to correct it, have an Ontario lawyer or licensed paralegal confirm whether section 64 or sections 62–63 fit your facts before you serve anything, and consider reporting the situation to the local fire department rather than letting it sit.
Trust Professional, Diligent Work. I am Ming Ren. In the rental business, safety is the one area with no shortcuts — a complete record is the best protection a landlord can buy, and it costs nothing but discipline.
This article is general information only, not legal advice. The facts of your case and local fire department enforcement practice can change the conclusion. Consult an Ontario lawyer or licensed paralegal before acting.
Primary sources: Ontario Fire Code, O. Reg. 213/07, ss.2.13, 2.16, 6.3.3.2–6.3.3.8, 6.3.4; Fire Protection and Prevention Act, 1997, S.O. 1997, c.4, s.28; Residential Tenancies Act, 2006, S.O. 2006, c.17, ss.27, 34, 62, 63, 64 (Ontario e-Laws, consulted November 2026).
Frequently asked questions
If the tenant pulled the battery, is a fire still the landlord's problem?
Yes. The tenant's act breaches Article 6.3.3.6, but your maintenance and testing duties are a separate line; they run in parallel and do not cancel each other out.
Does a lease clause making the tenant maintain the alarms cover the landlord?
No. Article 6.3.3.2 fixes the owner role on the landlord by law and excludes the tenant from the definition of landlord, so the clause does not stop a prosecution under section 28 of the FPPA.
If an alarm was compliant when installed, does it stay compliant?
No. The Code requires it to remain in operating condition for the entire tenancy: test annually, test at every turnover, and respond when a fault is reported.


