I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
The short answer first: a landlord with one meter and one bill can share the cost with tenants, but cannot invent the percentage or pick the start date at will. Section 138 of Ontario's Residential Tenancies Act, 2006 (the RTA) and its regulation, O. Reg. 394/10, set the whole framework: the building must contain not more than six rental units, the landlord must supply the utility, the tenant must consent in writing, written notice must be given at least 30 days ahead, the rent must be reduced at the same time, and there are only two permitted methods — an equal split by number of residential units, or a split by floor area. Miss a step and the charge is on shaky ground; section 134 closes the side door by prohibiting extra charges the Act and regulations do not allow, so a landlord cannot dodge this process by inventing a separate "utility fee."
Three things follow: whether your house qualifies, how the percentage is actually calculated, and the order in which the paperwork has to happen before any money changes hands.
First: the thresholds — does your house qualify?
Section 138 is not for every rental. Three gates come first:
- Unit count and supply. The building contains not more than six rental units, and the landlord supplies the utility to each of them. One meter, the account in the landlord's name, the landlord paying the bill and then collecting shares — that is the classic landlord-supplied setup.
- Which utilities count. Section 2(1) of the RTA defines "utilities" narrowly: heat, electricity and water. Treat a gas bill with care: the part that runs the furnace is heat, but the same bill may also cover a water heater or a gas stove, and the definition does not name gas as a whole. If you plan to apportion a gas bill, identify exactly which bill and which utility you are dealing with in writing; if you are unsure, ask a lawyer first rather than writing "utilities split by percentage" in general terms.
- Whether the RTA applies at all. If the tenant must share a kitchen or bathroom with the owner (or the owner's spouse, child or parent) who lives in the same building, section 5(i) takes the tenancy outside the Act entirely, and section 138 never comes into play. Self-contained upstairs and basement units, rented separately, are the situation this article is about.
One related route is often confused with this one: installing a suite meter for each unit is governed by section 137, a separate process that also requires the tenant's written consent (on the Board-approved form), notice and a rent reduction. Apportioning one bill and metering each unit are two different things; do not blend the procedures.
Second: only two methods produce a lawful percentage
Section 13 of O. Reg. 394/10 lists exactly two methods, and where the cost is shared among more than one unit, every unit must use the same one:
| Method | How it is calculated | Result with two units |
|---|---|---|
| Equal split by units | Total cost for each billing period ÷ number of residential units in the building | Half each |
| By floor area | Total cost for each billing period ÷ total floor area of all residential units × the area of the tenant's unit | Split in proportion to the two areas |
Two details are easy to miss. First, the total cost covers all residential units plus the related common areas, but excludes late-payment penalties and charges (s.13(4)). Second, the equal-split divisor is the number of residential units — if you live on one floor yourself, whether your own unit counts in the divisor has to be checked against the wording of the regulation, not assumed.
Here is an illustrative example I made up, with figures used only to show the arithmetic, not taken from any real house: a detached house divided into an upstairs and a basement residential unit; total electricity cost for the whole house over the most recent 12 months of $2,400 (late charges excluded); upstairs 1,200 square feet, basement 800 square feet. Under the equal split, each household bears half of each bill. Under the floor-area method, the basement's share is 800 ÷ 2,000 = 40% and the upstairs share is 60%. Notice what that means: a "60/40 upstairs/downstairs" split is defensible only when it comes out of the floor-area calculation. A percentage based on headcount, on how many appliances someone owns, or on what the parties "agreed feels fair" has no footing in the regulation.
Third: the paperwork order — consent, notice, rent reduction, then charging
Sequence is where this most often goes wrong. Under sections 14 and 15 of the regulation, the steps run like this:
- Written consent first. Section 138(1) requires the tenant's written consent. A verbal yes is not enough; without this step, nothing after it holds together.
- Written notice at least 30 days ahead. The notice must reach the tenant at least 30 days before charging begins and must state the amount of the rent reduction, its effective date, the method used to determine the tenant's share, and how the rent reduction is calculated. "Utilities will be split by percentage starting next month" does not meet that standard.
- The rent reduction cannot lag behind the charge. The reduction takes effect on the first day of a rental period that begins no later than the first day the tenant is charged. You cannot collect shares for a few months and reduce the rent afterwards. The minimum reduction follows a formula: under the equal split, (total cost for the most recent 12 months ÷ number of residential units) ÷ number of rental periods in 12 months; under the floor-area method, the unit's annual share is (total cost × unit area ÷ total area), divided by the number of rental periods. On the illustrative figures above, the equal split gives each unit a $100 monthly reduction; the floor-area method gives $120 for the upstairs and $80 for the basement (all illustrative amounts calculated from the formula).
- Disclosure to the next tenant. While you are charging shares, before signing with a prospective tenant you must disclose the percentage applicable to that unit, the total cost of the utility for the building for the most recent 12 months for which you have information, and whether any part of the building was vacant during that period, which part, and for how long (s.138(4); regulation s.16).
- An appliance rule if electricity is apportioned. Under section 17 of the regulation, refrigerators supplied by the landlord must have been manufactured on or after January 1, 1994, and replacement refrigerators on or after December 31, 2002. Check the plate on that basement fridge before you start splitting the hydro bill.
Finally, the consequence many landlords do not expect: a utility apportioned under section 138 is no longer part of the rent (s.138(2)). An unpaid share is not unpaid rent — the landlord cannot serve a notice of termination under section 59, or apply to the Landlord and Tenant Board under section 69 or 87, because a tenant did not pay the utility charge (s.138(3)). In the other direction, a tenant who says the landlord breached subsection 138(1) or (4) must apply within one year after the breach first occurred (regulation s.18), and where the Board finds a breach of subsection (1), it can order the landlord to take back the obligation to supply the utility and set a new rent. Changing the method or the percentage mid-stream has no unilateral route in the statute either — the careful path is fresh written consent, fresh notice, and a freshly calculated rent reduction.
Three common misunderstandings
Misunderstanding 1: "Four people upstairs, one downstairs — splitting by headcount is fairest." Fairness is not the test; the regulation is. It recognizes only the equal split and the floor-area split. If floor area tracks your house better, choose that method, measure the units properly, and put the numbers in the notice.
Misunderstanding 2: "The tenant agreed verbally, so I'll start charging and fix the rent reduction later." That stacks two errors: the consent must be in writing, and the reduction cannot start later than the charging. Collecting first and reducing later is exactly what section 15 of the regulation is written against, and the tenant has a year to apply to the Board about it.
Misunderstanding 3: "If the tenant won't pay their share, I'll treat it as rent arrears and start the eviction process." A charge collected under section 138 is not rent in law, and non-payment of it cannot ground a termination. The landlord's remedy is about the charge itself, not about ending the tenancy.
If you are about to start apportioning, I suggest this order
- Confirm the thresholds: no shared kitchen or bathroom with you or your close family; not more than six rental units; the meter account is in your name and you supply the utility.
- Pull the last 12 months of bills for that utility for the whole building, strip out late-payment charges, and total them; for a gas bill, separate out what is actually heat.
- Measure each residential unit, choose one method — equal split or floor area — use it for every unit, and calculate each unit's minimum rent reduction under section 15 of the regulation.
- Get each tenant's signed written consent, then serve the written notice at least 30 days ahead, stating the reduction amount, its effective date, the method, and how the reduction was calculated.
- Start charging only from the rental period in which the reduction takes effect; send each tenant the total bill and their share every period, and keep the bills and notices on file.
- If electricity is being apportioned, check the manufacture dates of landlord-supplied refrigerators against section 17 of the regulation; and for every future tenant, make the section 138(4) disclosure in writing before the agreement is signed.
I am Ming Ren. With rentals, as with sales, the numbers and the paperwork have to line up first — then the arrangement holds.
This article is general information, not legal advice. Your lease wording, unit layout and bill structure can change the answer, so consult an Ontario lawyer or licensed paralegal before acting.
Primary sources: Residential Tenancies Act, 2006, S.O. 2006, c.17, ss.2(1), 5(i), 134, 137, 138; O. Reg. 394/10 (Suite Meters and Apportionment of Utility Costs), ss.13–18 (Ontario e-Laws, reviewed November 2026). The $2,400 annual electricity figure, the 1,200 and 800 square feet, and the $100/$120/$80 monthly reductions are illustrative amounts worked from the prescribed formulas, not real bills.
Frequently asked questions
Is splitting utility costs by headcount the fairest method?
Fairness is not the test; the regulation is. It recognizes only the equal split and the floor-area split, so if floor area tracks your house better, choose that method, measure properly, and put the numbers in the notice.
Can I start charging after a verbal agreement and fix the rent reduction later?
No. The consent must be in writing, and the reduction cannot start later than the charging. Collecting first and reducing later is exactly what section 15 of the regulation is written against, and the tenant has a year to apply to the Board about it.
Can I treat an unpaid utility share as rent arrears and start eviction?
No. A charge collected under section 138 is not rent in law, and non-payment of it cannot ground a termination; the landlord's remedy is about the charge itself.


