I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
Here is the plain conclusion first: an Ontario landlord cannot use a "no pets" line in a lease to keep an animal out, and cannot insist on a diagnosis before discussing a service animal. Ordinary pets, service animals, and what people call emotional support animals do not travel on the same legal track in Ontario, but every dispute should start with two questions in order: is the lease clause itself valid, and is the animal meeting a disability-related need?
Most arguments start at the wrong end. Both sides debate whether an animal "counts" as a service animal, when the proper sequence is the Residential Tenancies Act, 2006 first, the Human Rights Code second, and the behaviour of the specific animal third.
1. A no-pets clause is void — and s.14 does not itself create the right
Section 14 of the Residential Tenancies Act, 2006 provides that a provision in a tenancy agreement prohibiting the presence of animals in or about the residential complex is void. Signing it, bolding it, or initialling it does not change that. A landlord cannot serve a termination notice on the strength of that clause, and a tenant does not breach the lease by keeping an animal despite it.
Read s.14 precisely, though. It voids the clause; it does not, on its own, create a freestanding right to keep any animal in any way, and it is not the source of service-animal rights. For an ordinary pet, the protection is that the ban is void. Where disability is involved, the right and the analysis come from the Human Rights Code. That distinction matters in practice, because it decides what a landlord may ask and how the request must be handled.
One separate boundary: if the unit is a condominium, the corporation's declaration, by-laws and rules may restrict animals. Those are condominium documents, not a lease clause, and they need to be checked on their own terms before anyone assumes s.14 settles the question.
2. In housing, the Human Rights Code governs — not the AODA customer-service list
Section 2 of the Human Rights Code protects equal treatment without discrimination in the occupancy of accommodation, and disability is a protected ground. Section 10 defines disability broadly, covering physical, mental and learning conditions among others. Under s.17 and the policies of the Ontario Human Rights Commission (OHRC), a housing provider has a duty to accommodate a disability-related need to the point of undue hardship, assessed on factors such as cost, outside sources of funding, and health and safety.
So when a tenant says an animal is connected to their disability, the landlord's job is not to label the animal first. It is to work through accommodation: is there a disability-related need, how does the animal respond to that need, and would accommodating it cause genuine undue hardship? A guide dog is the easiest illustration, but the duty is not limited to guide dogs or to disabilities that are visible.
The definition most people find online comes from s.80.45 of O. Reg. 191/11, the Integrated Accessibility Standards under the Accessibility for Ontarians with Disabilities Act, 2005: an animal identifiable by a vest, harness or similar visual indicator, or documentation from a listed regulated health professional confirming the person requires the animal for reasons relating to disability. Note where that definition lives. It is in the Customer Service Standards, and s.80.45 says those standards apply to providers of goods, services or facilities — shops, restaurants and service premises, not a residential landlord. Importing that list into a tenancy and demanding a letter from one particular profession is using the wrong law for housing.
Emotional support animals need the clearest statement of all: Ontario has no separate statutory ESA category, no provincial registry, and no official certificate, vest or card that turns an animal into a protected one. A registration or certificate bought online creates no Ontario legal right, and Ontario does not use a U.S.-style letter regime to establish status. An ESA request is assessed under the Human Rights Code like any other accommodation request — on disability-related need and on how the animal's presence responds to that need.
For a clearly-labelled illustrative example only: a tenant says a cat's companionship responds to a disability-related need. The landlord should neither reply "the lease bans pets" nor tell the tenant to buy an ESA certificate online. The proper step is to request information about the need and the connection to the animal, then assess accommodation. This example illustrates process only; it is not a real case.
3. A landlord may ask about need, not demand a medical file — and real problems go through the Board
Accommodation does not mean no questions. Under OHRC policy on disability and accommodation, a landlord may request reasonable information related to the request: confirmation that there is a disability-related need, the limitations that need creates, how the animal responds to it, and what accommodation is being sought. Where the animal's role is not obvious, a letter from a physician or another qualified health professional explaining the need and the connection will generally fall within that scope.
The limit is equally clear. A landlord generally may not demand the specific diagnosis, the name of the condition, its cause, symptom details, or a full treatment history, and may not expand the inquiry into private information unrelated to the request. The landlord is entitled to understand what accommodation is needed and why — not to review the tenant's medical file as a screening document. Setting the bar at "produce a diagnosis first" can itself create discrimination risk.
Accommodation is also not immunity. If a specific animal substantially interferes with reasonable enjoyment, causes a serious allergic reaction for the landlord or another tenant, or the species or breed is inherently dangerous to safety, s.76 of the Residential Tenancies Act provides the route: after a termination notice under provisions such as ss.64, 65 or 66, and on an application to the Landlord and Tenant Board, the Board considers whether the tenant is in fact keeping the animal and whether a s.76 ground is made out, looking at that individual animal rather than a general assumption about a species. Where another tenant has a serious allergy, the landlord may owe accommodation duties on both sides and must look for a balanced solution rather than simply preferring one need over the other.
Common misunderstandings
"The tenant signed the no-pets clause, so keeping an animal is a breach." No. Section 14 makes that kind of clause void; a signature does not revive it.
"Section 14 is what gives service animals their rights." No. Section 14 voids no-pets clauses for pets and service animals alike. Disability-related rights and the duty to accommodate come from the Human Rights Code.
"Meeting the AODA s.80.45 list settles a rental request." That definition governs providers of goods, services or facilities in customer service. A housing request is assessed under the Human Rights Code.
"An ESA registration or certificate creates legal status in Ontario." Ontario has no ESA registry or certification regime. A purchased card or certificate creates no right, and a landlord should not require a tenant to buy one.
"Once an animal is called a service animal, nothing can ever be done." No. Where the specific animal causes substantial interference, a serious allergic reaction, or a safety risk, a landlord may follow the s.76 process at the Board, while still taking the duty to accommodate into account.
Action checklist
- Put the lease's no-pets wording aside and do not decide on it. For a condominium, obtain and read the declaration, by-laws and rules as well.
- Identify what is actually being asked: ordinary pet keeping, or a disability-related accommodation request. If disability is involved, handle it under the Human Rights Code, not the AODA s.80.45 customer-service list.
- Request only need-related information: whether there is a disability-related need, what it is, and how the animal responds to it. If written support is needed, ask for a professional letter explaining need and connection — not a diagnosis or medical records.
- Do not require, and do not treat as proof, an online ESA registration, certificate or card. Ontario has no such regime.
- Keep a record of the accommodation process: what was asked, what was provided, what options were considered, and, if you refuse, what undue hardship is shown on cost, health or safety grounds.
- If interference, allergy or safety problems arise, document the specific animal's conduct with dates, get advice from an Ontario lawyer, and consider a notice under ss.64–66 and a s.76 application to the Board. Do not change locks, cut services, or remove an animal yourself.
I am Ming Ren. When a service animal or support animal request arrives, separate the lease question from the human rights question first, and work through the documents and the need one step at a time.
This article is general information, not legal advice. The disability-related need, condominium documents, and the actual impact of a specific animal can change the result in an individual case. Get advice from an Ontario lawyer before acting.
Primary sources: Residential Tenancies Act, 2006, ss.14, 76; Human Rights Code, ss.2, 10, 17; O. Reg. 191/11 (Integrated Accessibility Standards), s.80.45; OHRC Policy on ableism and discrimination based on disability and Policy on human rights and rental housing (Ontario e-Laws / OHRC, checked November 2026). The tenant-and-cat example above is illustrative only, not a real case.
Frequently asked questions
The tenant signed the no-pets clause, so is keeping an animal a breach?
No. Section 14 makes that kind of clause void, and a signature does not revive it.
Is section 14 what gives service animals their rights?
No. Section 14 voids no-pets clauses for pets and service animals alike, while disability-related rights and the duty to accommodate come from the Human Rights Code.
Does an ESA registration or certificate create legal status in Ontario?
Ontario has no ESA registry or certification regime. A purchased card or certificate creates no right, and a landlord should not require a tenant to buy one.
Once an animal is called a service animal, can nothing ever be done?
No. Where the specific animal causes substantial interference, a serious allergic reaction, or a safety risk, a landlord may follow the section 76 process at the Board, while still taking the duty to accommodate into account.


