I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
The plain conclusion first: an amendment does not launder an illegal deposit into a legal one. Section 4 of Ontario's Residential Tenancies Act, 2006 (the RTA) says a provision in a tenancy agreement that is inconsistent with the Act is void. On deposits, the Act leaves only a narrow opening: one rent deposit, plus a refundable key deposit charged at actual cost. Everything else — "credit deposit," "damage deposit," "pet deposit," "cleaning deposit" — is the same whatever it is called: it should not be collected, and if it has been, the tenant can apply to the Landlord and Tenant Board (LTB) to get it back.
First: changing a lease and adding an illegal clause are two different things
A lease can be changed. Term, move-in arrangements and similar matters can be adjusted by a written amendment both sides genuinely agree to. But an amendment has two gates it cannot pass.
First, it needs both parties' agreement. Once the lease is signed, an amendment the landlord sends you demanding more money is only a new proposal. You may decline it, and the original lease continues as it was. A landlord cannot use "sign or you do not get the keys" to force acceptance of a clause that is unlawful to begin with.
Second, it cannot conflict with the RTA. Section 4's rule is that a term inconsistent with the Act or its regulations is void. So even if you signed under pressure at the time, the illegal clause does not become enforceable because of your signature. That matters: signing does not mean you agreed the money is gone, and it does not mean you cannot recover it.
So when an amendment adding a deposit lands in front of you, do not start from "sign or lose the home." Start from the legal checklist: is this money the law allows the landlord to collect at all?
Second: run the deposit list — this is all that may be collected
Sections 105 to 110 of the RTA set out the rent and deposit rules in detail. The parts that touch deposits are in this table:
| Item | Allowed? | The rule |
|---|---|---|
| Rent deposit (last month's rent) | Yes | Section 105: this is the only security deposit permitted. Section 106: no more than the lesser of one rent period and one month's rent, and collectable only on or before entering into the tenancy agreement |
| Interest on the deposit | The landlord owes it | Section 106: the landlord pays interest on the rent deposit annually at the guideline rate in effect when it is due; the deposit may be topped up as prescribed when rent lawfully increases |
| Deposit where the unit is never given | Must be repaid | Section 107: if a rent deposit was paid but vacant possession is not given to the prospective tenant, the deposit must be repaid |
| Key / access-card deposit | Yes, with limits | O. Reg. 516/06, s.17: it must be refundable and no greater than the expected direct replacement cost of the key, remote or card |
| Deposits labelled damage, pet, cleaning, credit, etc. | No | Section 105 permits only a rent deposit as security; section 134 also prohibits additional charges the Act does not allow |
| Post-dated cheques or automatic debit | Cannot be required | Section 108: neither a landlord nor a tenancy agreement may require post-dated cheques, or automatic debiting or card charging for rent |
| Receipts | Free on request | Section 109: on request, the landlord must provide a receipt for rent, the deposit and other amounts, free of charge |
An illustrative example (my own assumed numbers): rent is $2,400 a month, and after signing the landlord asks for a "10% credit deposit" of $240 plus a $300 "cleaning deposit." Neither appears anywhere in the permitted column above; written into an amendment or agreed verbally, both are money that should not have been collected. A key deposit is different: if replacing the key or fob genuinely costs that amount, a refundable key deposit is permitted — and it is refunded when the keys are returned.
One point that is often missed: under section 106 the rent deposit may be applied only to the last rent period of the tenancy. It cannot be held against damage or cleaning. If there is real damage, the landlord's proper route is an application to the LTB for compensation, not keeping the deposit.
Third: if you have already paid, here is how the money comes back
If the money is already out of your hands, work in this order.
Ask in writing first. Send the landlord a short written notice (email is fine) stating which payment you made, how much, and that under sections 105 and 106 of the RTA the deposit is not permitted, and ask for repayment by a stated date. Keep it calm, but keep it in writing — what was said out loud is hard to prove later.
If the landlord will not repay, go to the LTB. Under section 135 of the RTA, a tenant (including a former tenant) may apply for an order for money collected or retained in contravention of the Act. In practice the form is Form T1, Tenant Application for a Rebate of Money the Landlord Owes, which has a specific reason covering an illegal charge. The LTB's T1 instructions confirm that current and former tenants may apply — and, for the illegal-charge reason, a prospective tenant who never moved in may apply as well.
Mind the clock: under section 135, this kind of application must be brought within one year of the payment. Wait longer and even a clearly illegal charge may be out of reach. So do not leave an extra deposit until move-out day. Keep the lease, the amendment, proof of payment and the correspondence from the very beginning.
A word to landlords, too: using an extra deposit to offset a worry about a tenant's credit is aiming at the wrong point in the process. The lawful tools sit before signing — screening within what the human rights rules permit, collecting the lawful rent deposit, and documenting the move-in condition. An extra deposit collected after signing comes back with a process attached.
Three common misunderstandings
"I offered to pay extra voluntarily, so it cannot be illegal." It does not work that way. Section 105 limits what a landlord may collect, not what a tenant is willing to pay. If the landlord takes it, the excess is still collected illegally and can still be recovered.
"I signed the amendment, so I have to live with it." No. Section 4 makes a term that conflicts with the RTA void; a signature does not cure the illegality. Money that should not have been collected can be claimed back through section 135 and the T1 process even if you signed.
"A key deposit is a deposit too, so it must be banned as well." The key deposit is an express exception, on narrow conditions: refundable, and no more than the expected direct replacement cost. Set it at several hundred dollars, or refuse to refund it when the keys come back, and it crosses the line again.
If an amendment like this is in front of you now, do these five things in order
- Do not sign or pay in a hurry: put the amendment beside the original lease and check each charge against the deposit list above, marking anything outside it.
- Reply in writing: say you will perform the original lease, but that under sections 105 and 106 of the RTA the extra deposit is not permitted, and ask the landlord to withdraw or correct that clause.
- If you have already paid, demand repayment in writing, stating the amount, the payment date and the legal basis, and keep proof of delivery.
- If the landlord refuses, file Form T1 with the LTB within one year of the payment, attaching the lease, the amendment, proof of payment and your correspondence.
- If the clause is unclear or the amount is large, get advice from an Ontario lawyer or a community legal clinic before you sign — not under deadline pressure at the door.
Trust Professional, Diligent Work. I am Ming Ren. On leases and deposits, check the clause against the Act first — then we can talk, item by item.
This article is general information only, not legal advice. Your timeline, payment records and the text of your lease can change the conclusion. Consult an Ontario lawyer or a community legal clinic before acting.
Primary sources: Residential Tenancies Act, 2006, S.O. 2006, c.17, ss.4, 105, 106, 107, 108, 109, 110, 134, 135; O. Reg. 516/06, s.17; LTB Form T1 Instructions (Tribunals Ontario) (Ontario e-Laws and Tribunals Ontario, consulted November 2026). The $2,400 monthly rent figure is illustrative only, not a real case.
Frequently asked questions
If I voluntarily offered to pay an extra deposit, can it still be illegal?
It does not work that way. Section 105 limits what a landlord may *collect*, not what a tenant is willing to pay. If the landlord takes it, the excess is still collected illegally and can still be recovered.
I signed the amendment — do I have to live with the extra deposit?
No. Section 4 makes a term that conflicts with the RTA void; a signature does not cure the illegality. Money that should not have been collected can be claimed back through section 135 and the T1 process even if you signed.
Is a key deposit banned too, since it is also a deposit?
The key deposit is an express exception, on narrow conditions: refundable, and no more than the expected direct replacement cost. Set it at several hundred dollars, or refuse to refund it when the keys come back, and it crosses the line again.


