I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
Here is the plain conclusion first: there is no universal offer formula. When a home is in demand, you are competing on how clean and certain your offer is. When nobody is competing, you are competing on how well you keep your protections and negotiate the details. Price is only one part — conditions, deposit, closing date and the irrevocable period together are what the seller actually sees.
This article covers three things: how to tell which market you are really in, how the approach changes across the three market types, and what Ontario's TRESA rules actually guarantee you will know in a competing-offer situation.
1. Identify the market before you set a price
Do not start with "how much should we offer?" Start with what has actually happened to similar homes in that neighbourhood and property type: how long they took to sell, what they finally sold for, whether they were reduced, and how many similar listings are available now. The list price is the seller's asking signal, not the market value. Recent comparable sales are the useful reference.
Separate the wider market from this one property. In the same city, a detached home on one street can draw several buyers while a townhouse a few streets away sits for a long time. A headline calling the whole city a buyer's or seller's market helps very little with your one offer. Judge the specific property: is its price close to recent sales, how strong is showing interest, and has the seller set a date to review offers? Settle those three points before you price anything.
2. Three markets, three different approaches
Seller's market: compete on certainty. When similar homes are scarce and buyers are plentiful, what a seller fears most is not a slightly lower price — it is a deal that falls apart. A competitive offer in this setting usually shows clear financing readiness, a definite deposit arrangement, a closing date that works for the seller, and only the conditions you genuinely need. Some buyers do a pre-inspection before deciding whether to shorten or waive an inspection condition, but that only makes sense once you understand the risk — not as a reflex that strips away every protection. An illustrative example: on a home listed at $1,000,000 (illustrative figure only), a slightly higher price can still lose if it carries many conditions and a closing date that does not work, while a close offer with cleaner terms wins.
Buyer's market: keep protections, negotiate details. When there is plenty of choice and homes take longer to sell, your time has value. Financing and home inspection conditions deserve serious consideration here; they are not obstacles, they are your exit if the loan or the property's condition turns out to be a problem. On price, work from recent sales rather than the list price, and negotiate beyond price as well: included appliances and fixtures, repair items, and flexibility on closing. Being able to walk away is leverage, but only if your limits were set before the offer, not worked out mid-negotiation.
Balanced market: judge it property by property. When supply and demand are neither extreme, formulas fail fastest. In one neighbourhood, a fairly priced home can draw an offer quickly while an overpriced one sits through reductions. Look at each property on its own: its comparable sales, why the seller is selling, and how tight their timing is. Then adjust offer by offer — move quickly when you should, and do not give up conditions just to look sincere when you have room to keep them.
One thing does not change by market type: under the standard OREA Agreement of Purchase and Sale, a deposit stated as payable "upon acceptance" must be delivered to the deposit holder within 24 hours of acceptance, to be held in trust, and once the irrevocability time passes without acceptance, the offer is void. Get the timing wrong and the right price does not matter.
3. In competing offers, TRESA guarantees you exactly one fact
Since Phase 2 of TRESA took effect on December 1, 2023, the competing-offer rules in section 22.7 of O. Reg. 567/05 are clear:
- The number must be disclosed: If the seller's brokerage receives a competing written offer, it must communicate the number of competing written offers to every person who has made one. A verbal expression of interest is not a written offer.
- Content is shared only if the seller directs it: Only on the seller's written direction may the brokerage share the substance of competing offers — for example price or conditions — and then it must share it with every person who made an offer. The seller may direct that only part of the substance be shared.
- Identity is never shared: Personal information that would identify a person making an offer must never be disclosed.
So in a multiple-offer situation, the one fact you can count on is how many offers there are — not what anyone else offered. Unless the seller chooses an open process, do not expect to learn a rival price, and do not bid against a guess. Set your ceiling beforehand, from comparable sales and your own financing capacity, and adjust terms within that ceiling rather than breaking it on the spot.
Three misunderstandings I hear most often
"The highest price always wins." Not necessarily. A seller reads the whole offer: price, how many conditions, the deposit, and whether the closing date works. A slightly lower offer with clean conditions and a workable closing can beat a higher offer full of uncertainty.
"In a buyer's market you must offer 5 to 10 percent under list, and in a seller's market you must bid over." There is no fixed percentage. How far under or over only makes sense against the gap between this list price and recent comparable sales. Cut an already underpriced listing and you are simply out; chase an overpriced one just because the market is hot and you may overpay.
"Fewer conditions always looks better, so waiving them all is safest." Conditions are protection, not a show of sincerity. Waiving a financing condition before financing is in place, or an inspection condition before you understand the home's condition, puts your deposit and default risk on the line. A pre-inspection and a mortgage pre-approval exist so you can shorten conditions on evidence — not remove them blindly.
Before you submit an offer, do these things in order
- Pull recent real sales for the same neighbourhood and property type, and judge whether this list price is high, in line, or low. Do not price off the list price alone.
- Set three limits in writing: your maximum total price, the latest closing date you can accept, and the conditions you will not give up. Do not change them mid-stream.
- Confirm your mortgage pre-approval, deposit funds and closing timing in advance, and check the deposit delivery time and irrevocability wording in the agreement word by word.
- Establish the competition: is there a set offer date, and how many written offers are there? Under TRESA you are entitled to know the number — do not guess.
- In a buyer's or balanced market, list every detail you want to negotiate in one go: inclusions, repairs, and closing date. Do not add items one by one after submitting.
- In any market, have your Ontario real estate lawyer review the conditions and deadlines before you sign, especially the expiry dates for financing, inspection and, where it applies, status certificate review.
Trust Professional, Diligent Work. I am Ming Ren. If you are working through an offer, bring the comparable sales and your limits, and we will go through the numbers and the paperwork, item by item.
This article is general information only, not legal advice and not mortgage advice. The terms, condition deadlines and financing arrangements in your own case can change the conclusion. Consult an Ontario lawyer and your mortgage professional before acting.
Primary sources: Trust in Real Estate Services Act, 2002 and O. Reg. 567/05, s.22.7 (Ontario e-Laws); RECO guidance on competing offers and the open offer process; OREA Form 100 Agreement of Purchase and Sale, standard deposit and irrevocability wording (consulted November 2026). The $1,000,000 figure is illustrative only, not a real transaction.
Frequently asked questions
Does the highest price always win?
Not necessarily. A seller reads the whole offer: price, how many conditions, the deposit and whether the closing date works. A slightly lower offer with clean conditions can beat a higher offer full of uncertainty.
In a buyer's market must you offer 5 to 10 percent under list, and in a seller's market must you bid over?
There is no fixed percentage. How far under or over only makes sense against the gap between this list price and recent comparable sales.
Do fewer conditions always look better, so is waiving them all safest?
Conditions are protection, not a show of sincerity. Waiving financing or inspection before those are in place puts your deposit and default risk on the line; shorten conditions on evidence, not blindly.


