I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
Here is the plain conclusion first: in this situation the landlord does not answer to just one person — you are standing between two tenancies at the same time. To the incoming tenant, you signed a lease and took their money, so you owe them a unit they can actually move into; if you cannot deliver it, that breach sits with you first. To the outgoing tenant, even if they are staying past the date they were supposed to leave, you cannot remove them yourself — removal runs through an order of the Landlord and Tenant Board (LTB) and then the sheriff. Whether those costs can ultimately be passed back to the holdover tenant depends on you applying promptly and keeping evidence, not on how angry you get on move-in day. Get the order of steps wrong, and a landlord who started as the wronged party can end up owing money on both sides.
First: the new tenant is already your tenant, even though they never moved in
Many people assume that if nobody crossed the threshold and no keys changed hands, the tenancy has not really started and this is just an ordinary broken contract. In Ontario that assumption is wrong.
Section 13 of the Residential Tenancies Act, 2006 (the RTA) is clear: the term of a tenancy begins on the day the tenant is entitled to occupy the unit, and the tenancy agreement takes effect when the tenant is entitled to occupy it, whether or not the tenant actually occupies it. So on the agreed move-in date, your incoming tenant is already your tenant in law — and being unable to hand over a vacant unit means you have failed the most basic obligation in the deal: delivering possession.
What the landlord faces on this side is best understood in three layers. First, contract: you promised possession on a date and could not deliver, so the new tenant's reasonable costs — a hotel, a rescheduled moving truck, storage — may be claimed against you. Second, the RTA: section 22 says a landlord shall not substantially interfere with a tenant's reasonable enjoyment, and section 29 gives tenants a route to apply to the LTB (the tenant form is the T2). To be honest about the limit here, section 22 is written around the period of a tenant's occupancy, so whether it squarely covers a tenant who could never move in, and whether the Board will take that application, is a fact-specific question I will not guarantee. Third, section 16: the duty to take reasonable steps to minimize losses runs both ways. The new tenant cannot simply sit back and let the bill grow, and you cannot do nothing and expect someone else to absorb it all. The earlier you notify them in writing and help with a temporary arrangement, the stronger your position when responsibility is sorted out.
Second: against the tenant who won't leave, you have no self-help rights
Now the other end. Section 37 says a tenancy may be terminated only in accordance with the RTA, and section 38 says that if a fixed term ends without the tenancy being renewed or terminated, it is deemed to continue as a monthly tenancy. So "the lease expired" does not mean "the person must be out that day," and it certainly does not mean the landlord can act.
Section 39 closes the door: a landlord shall not recover possession of a unit unless the tenant has vacated or abandoned it, or a Board order evicting the tenant has authorized the possession. Changing the locks, cutting off water or power, moving their belongings out, or showing up to "ask" them to leave does not solve the problem — it adds a liability of your own, because the holdover tenant can turn around and file a T2 against you for unlawful recovery and interference.
There is only one lawful road: file the right landlord application on the right papers. If the outgoing tenant gave a notice of termination (such as an N9) or signed an agreement to terminate (an N11) and then stayed, the landlord applies to the LTB — commonly on Form L2, depending on the type of notice or agreement — for an order terminating the tenancy and evicting the tenant. If the tenant still does not leave after the order takes effect, the order goes to the sheriff with jurisdiction, and only the sheriff can lawfully clear the unit. Watch one deadline in particular: under section 46, a notice of termination becomes void 30 days after the termination date in the notice unless the tenant vacates or the landlord applies before then. Miss that window and the notice dies, and the work starts over.
An illustrative example of my own, dates only to show the sequence: suppose the old tenant was to leave June 30 and holds over, and the new tenant is to move in July 1 (illustrative dates). The lawful moves available to the landlord on July 1 are to notify the new tenant in writing, negotiate a temporary arrangement and keep records, and start the LTB application against the holdover tenant immediately — not to change a lock that afternoon. The first set of actions is mitigation; the second creates a second dispute.
Third: the money is three separate accounts, not one
Once the situation is stable, talk money. There are really three independent accounts here, and mixing them together guarantees a muddle.
Account one: what the holdover tenant owes the landlord. Section 86 entitles a landlord to compensation for the use and occupation of a unit by a tenant who does not vacate after the tenancy has been terminated by order, notice or agreement, and section 87(3) gives the landlord a route to apply to the Board for that compensation, calculated for each extra day of occupation. Note the precondition: the tenancy must first have been properly terminated. If the termination paperwork itself is defective, the foundation of this account is shaky.
Account two: what the incoming tenant claims from the landlord. This one lands on the landlord first, because the duty to deliver the unit was yours. The amount turns on the tenant's actual reasonable expenses and on whether a substitute arrangement was negotiated, and it is shaped by the section 16 duty to minimize losses — a tenant who refuses every reasonable temporary option and lets a hotel bill balloon will see their claim narrowed, just as a landlord who knew the unit would not be ready but waited until the day before move-in to say so will have a hard time shifting blame.
Account three: whether the landlord can pass account two back to the holdover tenant. In direction, yes — the holdover is what caused the whole chain, and a landlord can seek losses caused by the overholding in the Board process. But how much is actually recoverable depends on the evidence and on how the Board assesses it; it is not automatic just because you hand over the new tenant's bills. So keep the three accounts separate from day one: the days of overholding, every reasonable receipt from the new tenant, and every written communication with both sides, filed apart. Whether it ends in negotiation or a hearing, that is what you will be asked for.
Three common misunderstandings
Misunderstanding one: "The lease ended, so staying on is illegal occupation and changing the locks is only fair." No. Staying past the termination date is overholding, and the channel for it is an LTB order plus sheriff enforcement. Section 39 expressly prohibits self-help recovery, and changing locks without giving replacement keys also offends section 24 — you can end up liable to the very tenant who caused the problem.
Misunderstanding two: "The new tenant never lived there a single day, so the lease doesn't count — refund the deposit and we're even." No. Under section 13 the tenancy took effect on the day they were entitled to occupy. A deposit refund or rent relief can be part of a negotiated settlement, but it has to be agreed in writing by both sides; a landlord cannot unilaterally declare that the tenancy never existed.
Misunderstanding three: "The holdover tenant pays for everything in the end, so I don't need to do anything now." The opposite is true. Section 16 requires the person entitled to claim an amount to take reasonable steps to minimize their own losses. Fail to apply on time, fail to notify the new tenant, fail to keep evidence — and you recover less, not more.
If this lands on you, I suggest working in this order
- Notify the incoming tenant in writing the same day: explain that the outgoing tenant has not vacated, what process you are running, the expected timeline, and a proposed temporary arrangement or settlement. Keep everything in writing, not just phone calls.
- Audit the termination paperwork on the outgoing side: was it a tenant's notice, a mutual agreement, or a landlord's notice? What is the termination date, and is your proof of service complete? If anything looks defective, have an Ontario lawyer or licensed paralegal review it before you file.
- File the matching LTB landlord application before the notice goes void under section 46 — within 30 days after the termination date — using the L2 or the form that fits your notice or agreement. Do not rely on oral promises of "a few more days."
- After you get an eviction order, stay on top of enforcement: file it with the sheriff with jurisdiction promptly, and until the sheriff enforces it, do not touch the locks, the utilities, or anything inside the unit.
- Keep three separate files: the holdover days and the compensation calculation; the incoming tenant's reasonable expense receipts; and your record of notices and negotiations with both sides.
- For the next turnover, leave a buffer between the confirmed vacancy date and the next move-in date. Never stake a possession date on the single assumption that the outgoing tenant will leave on time — a small gap between tenancies is the cheapest insurance against this entire dispute.
I am Ming Ren. When a landlord is squeezed from both sides, get the procedure right first and keep the accounts separate — and work through the documents one by one.
This article is general information, not legal advice. Whether a notice of termination is valid, which application form fits, and what remedies a tenant who could not move in can claim all depend on the documents and facts of the individual case. Consult an Ontario lawyer or licensed paralegal before acting.
Primary sources: Residential Tenancies Act, 2006, S.O. 2006, c.17, ss.13, 16, 17, 22, 29, 37, 38, 39, 44, 46, 86, 87(3) (Ontario e-Laws, reviewed November 2026); LTB landlord Form L2 and tenant Form T2 instructions (Tribunals Ontario). The June 30 and July 1 dates are illustrative only, not a real case.
Frequently asked questions
If a tenant stays past the end of the lease, can the landlord change the locks?
No. Staying past the termination date is overholding, and the channel for it is an LTB order plus sheriff enforcement. Section 39 expressly prohibits self-help recovery, and changing locks without giving replacement keys also offends section 24 — you can end up liable to the very tenant who caused the problem.
If the new tenant never moves in because the old tenant held over, is their lease void and is a deposit refund enough?
No. Under section 13 the tenancy took effect on the day they were entitled to occupy. A deposit refund or rent relief can be part of a negotiated settlement, but it has to be agreed in writing by both sides; a landlord cannot unilaterally declare that the tenancy never existed.
Can the landlord just wait and let the holdover tenant pay for everything?
The opposite is true. Section 16 requires the person entitled to claim an amount to take reasonable steps to minimize their own losses. Fail to apply on time, fail to notify the new tenant, fail to keep evidence — and you recover less, not more.


