Ming RenBroker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage
☎ 647-779-9186

Tax

Do Two Wills Really Cut Ontario Probate Tax? The Multiple-Wills Math, Done Honestly

By , Broker, RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc. (About Ming) · Published

Ming Ren · Broker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage

← All articles · Tax · Category guide

I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.

The plain conclusion first: the multiple-wills strategy is real, and an Ontario court accepted it back in 1998 in the Granovsky case. But what it saves is narrow. It saves Estate Administration Tax (EAT) — Ontario's probate tax — and only on assets that can change hands without a court certificate. For someone whose estate is a house and some bank accounts, a second will saves close to nothing and adds a layer of risk. Here is the math, so you can judge for yourself.

1. How the tax is actually charged

EAT is charged under the Estate Administration Tax Act, 1998 when the court issues an estate certificate — the document most people still call probate. No certificate, no tax. If a certificate is issued, the tax is calculated on the value of the estate covered by the will that was probated.

The current calculation (for certificates applied for on or after January 1, 2020): the estate value is rounded up to the nearest $1,000, the first $50,000 is tax-free, and the rest is charged at $15 per $1,000 — about 1.5%.

What counts in the value? Ontario real estate (at its date-of-death appraised value, less mortgages and other encumbrances registered on it), bank accounts including foreign ones, investments, vehicles and boats, business interests, property held in another person's name, and insurance payable to the estate. What stays out: insurance paid to a named beneficiary, RRSPs, RRIFs and TFSAs with a beneficiary designation, jointly held assets that pass automatically to a survivor, real estate outside Ontario, and the CPP death benefit. One detail matters: ordinary debts do not reduce the value — only encumbrances on Ontario real estate come off.

One follow-up duty is often missed: within 180 days after the certificate is issued, the estate representative must file an Estate Information Return with the Ministry of Finance — even if the estate value works out to zero. That is a requirement under O. Reg. 310/14, not an option.

An invented example, only to show the arithmetic: an estate consisting of a mortgage-free house worth $900,000 and $100,000 in bank accounts totals $1,000,000. Probated under one will, the EAT is ($1,000,000 − $50,000) × 1.5% = $14,250. That is the whole tax. Where a second will enters the picture is the next section.

2. How the two wills divide the work

The strategy uses two wills signed on the same day, usually with the same trustees:

  • Primary will: holds only the assets a third party will not release without a court certificate — Ontario real estate being transferred, most bank and investment accounts. This will is probated, and EAT is charged only on the assets under it.
  • Secondary will: holds assets that can be administered without a certificate — most typically shares of a private corporation and shareholder loans, plus personal effects and similar property. This will is not probated, so it attracts no EAT.

The saving is simply that tax follows the probated will. Using invented numbers again: if the same person also held private-company shares worth $2,000,000, a single will would put $3,000,000 through probate and cost about $44,250 in EAT. With the shares in a secondary will, the primary will stays at $1,000,000 and the tax at about $14,250 — a difference of roughly $30,000. The bigger the private-company holding, the bigger the gap. With no such assets, the gap is roughly zero.

A cold splash of water in the other direction: your home cannot ride in the secondary will to dodge the tax. Transferring real estate almost always requires a certificate, so the house belongs in the primary will by nature. "Put the house in the second will" does not work.

3. Where the real risks are

First, the drafting has to be meticulous. The two wills are signed the same day and must dovetail: each must say clearly which assets it governs, and neither may contain a stray revocation clause that accidentally cancels the other — the standard "I revoke all former wills" line, placed carelessly, can blow up the whole structure.

Second, the dividing line itself has been litigated. Lawyers commonly use an allocation (or "basket") clause letting the trustees decide which assets need a certificate and which will governs them. In Milne Estate (2018), a court held such a clause made the primary will invalid for uncertainty — a decision that caused real alarm. It was reversed on appeal, and Panda Estate, decided shortly after, reached the opposite conclusion. The strategy stands and is in everyday use, but it demands careful drafting by an experienced estates lawyer. It is not a template exercise.

Third, cost and upkeep. A second will means more legal fees, and every change in your asset picture — selling the company, buying a property, consolidating accounts — requires both wills to be re-checked together. If the tax saved is only a few thousand dollars, it may not cover the extra cost and attention over the years.

Fourth, this saves EAT and nothing else. The deemed disposition income tax at death, and the tax on registered accounts, are completely unaffected by how many wills you sign. Treating multiple wills as a general tax plan is doing the math in the wrong place.

Three misunderstandings I hear most often

"Two wills cut my estate tax in half." There is no "half." The saving depends entirely on how much value can lawfully sit in the unprobated secondary will. A typical house-and-savings estate has almost nothing movable, so the saving is almost nothing.

"The secondary will is never probated, so it can be written casually." The opposite is true. It is a formal will with the same signing and witnessing requirements. Sloppy wording sends your trustees to court for directions, and the legal bill can exceed the tax you saved.

"I'll just transfer the house to the kids now, or add them on title, and skip all this." That is a different plan with different bills: possible capital gains tax, land transfer tax questions, and exposing the home to a child's creditors or marriage breakdown. It should never be done first and analyzed later.

If you are considering this, do these five things in order

  1. List your assets in three groups: assets that need a certificate to transfer (real estate, most bank and investment accounts); assets that usually do not (private-company shares, shareholder loans, personal effects); and assets that already pass outside the estate value (named-beneficiary plans and insurance, true joint holdings).
  2. Run the numbers on that list. If everything you own is in the first group, multiple wills do nothing for you — one well-drafted will is enough.
  3. If the second group is substantial — say, company shares worth several hundred thousand dollars or more — take the list to an Ontario estates lawyer and ask for two figures side by side: the EAT saved and the drafting cost. Decide with both numbers on the table.
  4. If you already have two wills, review them together after every property purchase or sale, company share change, or major account move. Never amend one without checking the other.
  5. While you are at it, review your beneficiary designations. Whether an RRSP, TFSA or insurance policy names a person or "the estate" changes the EAT bill immediately — and it is far cheaper to fix than a will.

Trust Professional, Diligent Work. I am Ming Ren. When an estate includes real estate, bring the asset list and the documents, and we will go through the numbers item by item.


This article is general information only, not legal or tax advice. Will drafting, probate, and how your particular assets divide between wills can change the conclusion. Consult an Ontario estates lawyer and an accountant before acting.

Primary sources: Estate Administration Tax Act, 1998, S.O. 1998, c.34, Sched., s.2 (Ontario e-Laws); Ontario Ministry of Finance, Estate Administration Tax page (ontario.ca) on assets included and excluded; O. Reg. 310/14 (180-day Estate Information Return); Granovsky Estate (1998), Milne Estate (Re) (2018, reversed on appeal), Panda Estate (Re) (2018) (consulted November 2026). The $900,000 and $2,000,000 figures are illustrative only, not a real case.

This article in other languages: 中文فارسی

Want to talk about your home?

You can also call directly, or scan the code to add Ming on WeChat.

Ming’s WeChat QR code
Scan to add on WeChat

Community guides by city

All cities →
☎ Call MingFree Evaluation