Ming RenBroker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage
☎ 647-779-9186

Selling a Home

Interviewing Listing Agents? Watch for These Red Flags

By , Broker, RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc. (About Ming) · Published

Ming Ren · Broker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage

← All articles · Selling a Home · Category guide

I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.

Here is the conclusion first: do not hire the agent who quotes the highest price and talks the biggest game. An agent who crosses a line at the first meeting will very likely cross more lines later. There are three main ones: guaranteeing a price before properly viewing the home and doing the comparable work; winning your signature by disparaging competitors and predicting where the market is headed; and telling you other clients' private business as conversation. If any one of the three shows up, stop and ask a few more questions before you sign anything.

Selling is something most people do once in many years. You may get an hour or two to interview each agent, the information is uneven, and it is easy to be carried along by whoever sounds best. So keep the test narrow: ignore the polish and the pitch, and watch whether these three lines get crossed. Everything inside the lines — the price, the commission, the service list — can be negotiated calmly at the table. The lines themselves are not negotiable.

This is not just my personal preference. Ontario registrants are bound by the Code of Ethics (O. Reg. 365/22) under the Trust in Real Estate Services Act, 2002: act with courtesy, honesty, good faith and integrity toward everyone (s. 1); make best efforts to ensure representations are accurate and not misleading (s. 5); provide service with reasonable knowledge, skill, judgment and competence (s. 9); and do not disclose a client's confidential information to a third party without the client's written consent (s. 12). Whether what you hear in the meeting lines up with those sections is the readiest test you have.

Red flag one: the price is guaranteed before the home is understood

The most common scene: the agent walks through once — or only talks to you on the phone — and promises, "Your place will get at least this much, leave it to me." It sounds great, but ask where the number came from and there is nothing under it: no recent comparable sales in your pocket, no property-by-property adjustments for size, floor, finishes and condition, and no distinction between the list price and the price the home will actually sell for.

Here is an illustrative example I made up, so you can see the difference between two ways of talking. Agent A says, "I guarantee $1.5 million." Agent B says, "After adjusting the recent comparable sales, my range is $1.38 to $1.43 million. Here is the listing strategy I would recommend, and here is what listing higher would likely do to showing traffic." These figures are illustrative only — they are not a valuation of any real home. The point is that every number Agent B gives has a source you can question and check, while Agent A's number has exactly one job: getting you to sign on the spot. The industry has a name for that — buying the listing with a high price. The listing gets signed, the home sits, and in the end it is the seller who pays for the price cuts and the extra time on market.

A careful agent says it the other way around: the price comes after the walk-through and the comparative analysis, it comes as a range rather than a guarantee, and the agent will tell you up front what listing high and listing low each tend to do. The moment a price is stated as a guarantee, it no longer fits s. 5's requirement that representations be accurate and not misleading.

Watch the order of the conversation, too. A solid agent asks first — why are you selling, how tight is your timing, where are you going next — and only then talks price and strategy, because the right pricing approach for a home that must sell quickly is not the same as for one that can wait. An agent who leads with a number and pushes for a signature is usually focused on locking up the listing, not on how your home should be sold. Section 8 requires a registrant who represents a client to promote and protect that client's best interests — and those interests can only be identified by asking about your situation first.

Red flag two: winning you over by tearing others down and calling the market

The second type of talk aims not at the price but at people. One version disparages competitors: "Those discount shops are all a trap," or "That agent down the street botched someone's sale." Another scares you with the market: "Prices are about to jump, you need to decide now," or "Sell before it drops." A third is quieter: criticizing your home's taste to your face — the wall colour is dated, the kitchen is tired, the furniture does not work — until you feel that without this agent, the home simply will not sell.

These lines share one thing: none of them is about the facts of your home. All of them work on your emotions. Disparaging competitors sits poorly with s. 1's honesty and courtesy and with s. 2, which bars conduct that would reasonably be regarded as unprofessional. Stating where the market will go as a certainty is, in substance, presenting something nobody can guarantee as though it were guaranteed — misleading again. As for the renovations, the professional version is a short, optional pre-listing list: which items, roughly what each costs, and the decision left with you. Criticizing taste costs the agent nothing and takes ten seconds; a proper list means actually looking at the home and doing the arithmetic. You can hear which one is work.

There is a common variation aimed at commission: "Anyone who charges less than I do must be cutting corners." There is no necessary link between a lower fee and poorer service, and the agent offers no evidence for the claim. If you want to compare, compare the same service list — who does more, who puts it in writing — rather than who speaks worst of a competitor. Turning a commission discussion into an attack on rivals is still the same move: steer around your home and around the agent's own record, and let emotion make your decision for you.

The test is simple: make the agent talk only about himself — what his service list is, whether his recent results can be checked against public sold data, and what his pricing is based on. An agent who sticks to his own record and survives checking is on the right track. An agent who stands by stepping on others will talk about you the same way, to the next seller, if your sale runs into trouble.

Red flag three: other clients' business used as a story

The third line is the easiest to miss. To sound experienced, some agents tell it in detail: "I just sold a family's home last month for such-and-such — they were in a hurry to move because…" Family circumstances, reasons for selling, the price they would have settled for — all of it laid out. In the moment you may think this agent is well connected and well informed. Look at it from the other side: today he tells you the last client's private business; tomorrow he will tell the next seller yours.

The careful way to talk sounds different: totals, not people. "I have sold a few homes in this neighbourhood recently; on average they took about this long, and sold at roughly this proportion of asking" — numbers you can check, with no names attached. And if an agent wants to use a client's case as a showcase, that takes the client's agreement first. Aggregates versus anecdotes is a small difference in wording and a large one in professional conduct.

Section 12 is plain about it: a client's confidential information is not to be disclosed to a third party without written consent. A seller's bottom line, reasons for moving and time pressure are precisely the most valuable information at a negotiating table. An agent who cannot keep other people's confidences at the interview stage is hard to trust with yours during the transaction. So when you hear stories like that, do not take them as entertainment — take them as a warning. The agent who speaks only in aggregate numbers, without naming names or telling tales, is the one who takes the rules seriously.

Common misunderstandings

Misunderstanding one: "Whoever quotes the highest price is the most capable." A high quote only proves the agent is willing to say it. A capable quote can be opened up in front of you: which sales were used, how they differ, how each was adjusted. The highest number with no workings behind it is often just the starting point of a future price cut.

Misunderstanding two: "An agent who tells me to my face that my renovations are no good is being straight with me — that is professionalism." Being straight and being professional are two different things. Professional means turning a problem into a list, attaching a cost to each item, and leaving the decision with you. Criticism with no plan attached is not straight talk; it is talk with no accountability.

Misunderstanding three: "He shares other deals' inside details with me, so he is well informed and treats me like an insider." That is not insider treatment; that is a confidentiality problem. What he can say about others, he can say about you. Handing your bottom line and your reasons for selling to someone like that is the same as placing them on the negotiating table in advance.

If you are interviewing agents, I suggest you do it in this order

  1. Meet at least two or three agents before deciding, and do not sign at the first meeting while the pitch is still warm.
  2. Make each agent show the pricing work: which recent sales were used, how each was adjusted, and whether the answer is a range or a single number. If the work cannot be shown, do not rely on the quote, however high it is.
  3. Ask directly: "If there is no movement in the first two or three weeks, what is your next step?" Listen for a real plan, not just "we wait."
  4. Ask for the service list — photography, cleaning, small fixes, showing arrangements, weekly updates — what is included, what costs extra, and get it in writing before you sign.
  5. Notice how the agent talks about competitors and the market. Someone who sticks to his own data, makes no market predictions and does not run others down goes to the front of the line; the opposite comes off it.
  6. Notice whether the agent tells stories about other clients. The more detail, the stronger the reason not to hire him — and remind yourself not to hand over your own bottom line and private circumstances all at once before you sign, either.
  7. Before signing, read the listing agreement line by line — the term, the commission structure, the termination provisions — and if anything is unclear, ask a lawyer or someone you trust first. Do not worry about taking up the agent's time.

I do my work the plain way: honestly, and one careful step at a time. I am Ming Ren — if you are choosing a listing agent, lay the pricing work from each of them side by side, and you will see at a glance who is talking data and who is telling stories.

— Ming Ren, Broker, RE/MAX Realtron


This article is general information, not legal advice. Whether a registrant's conduct breaches the Code of Ethics in a given case is for RECO to determine on the facts; your rights and obligations are governed by the agreement you sign and the legislation in force at the time.

Primary sources checked: O. Reg. 365/22, Code of Ethics under the Trust in Real Estate Services Act, 2002, ss. 1, 2, 5, 8, 9 and 12 (Ontario e-Laws, consulted November 2026). The figures $1.5 million and $1.38–1.43 million are an illustrative example, not a real transaction or valuation.

Frequently asked questions

Whoever quotes the highest price is the most capable, right?

A high quote only proves the agent is willing to say it. A capable quote can be opened up in front of you: which sales were used, how they differ, how each was adjusted. A top price with no shown basis is often the starting point of later reductions.

Is an agent who tells me to my face that my renovations are no good being professional?

Being straight and being professional are two different things. Professional means turning a problem into a list, attaching a cost to each item, and leaving the decision with you.

He shares other deals' inside details with me, so is he well informed and treating me like an insider?

That is not insider treatment; that is a confidentiality problem. What he can say about others, he can say about you — your bottom line and reasons for selling would be on the negotiating table early.

This article in other languages: 中文فارسی

Want to talk about your home?

You can also call directly, or scan the code to add Ming on WeChat.

Ming’s WeChat QR code
Scan to add on WeChat

Community guides by city

All cities →
☎ Call MingFree Evaluation