Ming RenBroker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage
☎ 647-779-9186

Buying a Home

Legal Non-Conforming Use in Ontario: Can You Buy It, Keep It, and Rebuild on It?

By , Broker, RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc. (About Ming) · Published

Ming Ren · Broker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage

← All articles · Buying a Home · Category guide

I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.

The plain conclusion first: a property that does not comply with the current zoning by-law is not necessarily an illegal property. Everything turns on which category it falls into. A use that was lawful when it was established and was later overtaken by a zoning change is a legal non-conforming use, protected by section 34(9) of the Planning Act — it may continue. A use that was never lawful in the first place is simply illegal, and no such protection applies. The two labels sound similar; for rental income, for how you may use the building, and for any future enlargement, they produce opposite answers. Three things to work through before you buy.

1. Where the protection comes from: the two conditions in section 34(9)

Municipal zoning by-laws change as cities re-plan. A neighbourhood that once allowed multi-unit housing may be rezoned to single-family only. Overnight, a long-standing triplex, a house with a rental unit, or a corner store becomes "non-conforming" with the new rules.

Why can it carry on? Section 34(9)(a) of the Planning Act says it directly: a new zoning by-law does not apply to prevent the use of any land, building or structure for a purpose the by-law prohibits, if that property was lawfully used for that purpose on the day the by-law was passed, so long as it continues to be used for that purpose. This is the protection often nicknamed "grandfathering," and the right runs with the land — a new owner can continue the use.

But note the two conditions, and both must hold:

  • Lawful at the start: on the day the new by-law passed, the use must already have been lawful. A use that was illegal from day one is outside this protection entirely.
  • Continued ever since: the use must have continued. If it was discontinued or changed to something else, the protection may be lost.

There is a practical point on proof: the party claiming the protection has to establish it. Municipal practice — Hamilton's zoning compliance review process is one published example — puts the onus on the owner to produce evidence that the use was lawful when the by-law passed and has continued: old leases, historical advertisements, permit records, affidavits and similar documents are typical proof. "It must be grandfathered" is a guess, not a status. The paper trail has to line up.

2. Sort the property into the right category before you talk price

When a listing talks about a rental unit or an older converted building, place it against this table first:

Status What it means Consequence
Legal Use and structure comply with current zoning Normal use, rental, and resale
Legal non-conforming Lawfully established, then zoning changed around it Protected continuation under s.34(9); enlargement or a change of use needs a separate process
Illegal Never obtained the required approvals, or never complied No protection; the municipality can order remediation or removal, and rental income can disappear

Three scenarios account for most of what buyers meet: a multi-unit or basement rental unit lawfully established in what is now a single-family zone — the category closest to a buyer's wallet and the easiest to confuse with an illegal unit; a surviving commercial or mixed use in an older neighbourhood, such as a corner store in a now purely residential area; and structural non-conformity, where the use is fine but setbacks, lot coverage, or height no longer meet current standards.

One principle governs the sorting: a seller's or a listing's statement that a unit is "legal" is not a municipal determination. If you are buying on rental cash flow, which category that unit falls into decides whether your arithmetic holds at all.

3. Verify through the municipality in writing — and treat enlargement as a separate application

There is one reliable source for verification: the municipality, in writing. Have your lawyer, or you directly, request a zoning compliance letter from the city's planning or zoning department (the name varies by municipality; some call it a zoning certificate) and ask it to answer in writing: is the current use legal, legal non-conforming, or illegal; are there any open permits or outstanding municipal orders; and what registration or compliance records exist for the rental unit you are counting on. The letter costs some time and a fee; measured against a purchase price in the hundreds of thousands, it is the cheapest check in the whole transaction.

On the contract side, turn the verification into a condition of your offer: closing depends on the buyer being satisfied with the zoning compliance response and on the lawyer's title and municipal checks. If the answer comes back wrong, you have a proper exit — instead of discovering after closing that the unit cannot lawfully be rented.

Finally, draw the enlargement line clearly. Section 34(9) protection covers continuing the existing use as it is — not expanding it at will. Section 34(10) contemplates a council amending its by-law to permit an extension or enlargement of such a use, and section 45(2) gives the Committee of Adjustment the power to permit an enlargement or extension of a legal non-conforming use, or a change to a similar use. Both routes are "apply and be approved" — neither is an automatic owner right. If your plan is to buy and then build out or add units, price in the time and uncertainty of that application before you offer. Lenders and insurers also treat these properties differently in some cases; ask your mortgage broker and insurance broker about their requirements before you commit, not at the approval stage.

Three common misunderstandings

"The seller says the rental unit is legal, so it must be fine." Verbal assurances and listing language are not a determination. Legal, legal non-conforming, or illegal is settled by the municipality's written response and your lawyer's verification.

"It's legal non-conforming, so I can enlarge it or add units as I like." The protection covers continuing the existing use as it stands. Enlarging, extending, or changing the use requires a Committee of Adjustment application and approval under s.45(2), or a zoning amendment — it is not an automatic right.

"The use was paused for a while — the right is still there." Section 34(9) protection is expressly conditional on the use continuing. A discontinued or changed use can lose the protection, which is exactly why the verification chases historical evidence of continuous use.

If you are looking at a property with a rental unit or an older structure, do these in order

  1. Do not run the rental numbers first. Classify first: have your agent frame the use status as one explicit question — legal, legal non-conforming, or illegal — and only then talk price.
  2. Through your lawyer, request a zoning compliance letter from the municipality asking for written confirmation of the use status, together with open permits and outstanding orders.
  3. Assemble the continuous-use evidence: past leases, historical listings or advertisements, permit records — enough to show both section 34(9) conditions hold.
  4. Put a condition in the offer making closing depend on satisfactory verification results, so a failed check gives you a contractual exit.
  5. If you plan to enlarge or change the use, price that plan only after understanding the Committee of Adjustment process, timing, and likelihood — and confirm lending and insurance requirements for this property type with your mortgage and insurance brokers.

Trust Professional, Diligent Work. I am Ming Ren. These properties are not unbuyable — but the status has to be verified and the evidence assembled first, and only then do we talk price on real numbers.


This article is general information only, not legal advice. Every property's use history and municipal record is different; the conclusion rests on your real estate lawyer and the municipality's written response. Consult an Ontario lawyer before acting.

Primary source: Planning Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. P.13, ss.34(9), 34(10), 45(2) (Ontario e-Laws, consulted November 2026).

Frequently asked questions

The seller says the rental unit is legal, so it must be fine?

Verbal assurances and listing language are not a determination. Legal, legal non-conforming, or illegal is settled by the municipality's written response and your lawyer's verification.

It is legal non-conforming, so can I enlarge it or add units as I like?

The protection covers continuing the existing use as it stands. Enlarging, extending, or changing the use requires a Committee of Adjustment application and approval under s.45(2), or a zoning amendment — it is not an automatic right.

The use was paused for a while — is the right still there?

Section 34(9) protection is expressly conditional on the use continuing. A discontinued or changed use can lose the protection, which is exactly why the verification chases historical evidence of continuous use.

This article in other languages: 中文فارسی

Want to talk about your home?

You can also call directly, or scan the code to add Ming on WeChat.

Ming’s WeChat QR code
Scan to add on WeChat

Community guides by city

All cities →
☎ Call MingFree Evaluation