I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.
Here is the conclusion first: saying "I only wanted one of them" does not release you from two contracts that have already been formed. In Ontario, if the irrevocable periods on two offers overlap, both sellers may accept within their own deadlines, and you may end up obliged to buy two homes. The danger is not submitting two offers. The danger is having two of them alive at the same time.
This article covers three things only: who the irrevocable period actually binds, the moment a contract is formed, and how the money and the liability work if both sides do accept.
1. The irrevocable period binds the party who submitted the offer
Clause 1 of OREA Form 100, the Agreement of Purchase and Sale commonly used for Ontario resale homes, is headed Irrevocability. The form asks you to fill in which party — Seller or Buyer — the offer is irrevocable by, and the date and time it runs to. After that time, if the offer has not been accepted, it is null and void and the deposit is to be returned to the buyer in full, without interest.
When you sign and submit an offer as the buyer, you are the bound party until the time you wrote in. You cannot unilaterally pull the offer back during that window; the seller can use the time to consider it, accept it, or change the terms and sign it back. If the seller changes terms and signs back, that is a new offer and the roles reverse: now the seller is the bound party, a new irrevocable time on the sign-back runs, and you decide whether to accept before that time.
So judge the risk by the paper, not by the properties. Look at the two times on the two documents: has the first irrevocable time passed, and when does the second one expire? If the two windows overlap at all, the risk already exists. You do not need a mishap to make it real.
2. The contract forms when acceptance is delivered, not when you change your mind
Clause 13 of Form 100 puts it directly: upon acceptance of the offer, there is a binding agreement of purchase and sale between buyer and seller. The Confirmation of Acceptance at the end of the form records that event: the last party to sign confirms that the agreement, with all changes both typed and written, was finally accepted by all parties at a stated date and time.
That step matters because many later clocks run from acceptance. If the deposit is written as "Upon Acceptance," the form defines that as the buyer delivering the deposit to the Deposit Holder within 24 hours of acceptance.
Apply that logic to two offers and the picture is clear. Seller A signs an acceptance within your irrevocable period and delivers it as the form requires: contract one is formed. If your second offer is still inside its own irrevocable period, Seller B can sign, accept and deliver in the same way: contract two is formed. The two contracts do not sort themselves into first choice and second choice because that was the order in your head. There is no line on the form that says "I will buy only whichever one accepts first" — unless a lawyer has written such a condition into the documents for you in advance. That is a different arrangement; do not assume you have it.
One more caution: an accepted conditional offer still forms an agreement, one that is subject to its conditions, which must be fulfilled or waived within their time limits. A condition is not a free exit button, and it is not a reason to feel safe submitting two offers at once.
3. If both accept, getting out is not solved by saying "I don't want it"
If you can complete only one purchase, the other may put you in breach. The consequences follow that agreement and the actual loss, so here I will stay with the layers you can verify:
- Both deposits come due. Each accepted agreement runs on its own deposit terms, and a deposit written as Upon Acceptance is due within 24 hours of acceptance. An example with numbers I have invented for illustration only: a $30,000 deposit on House A and a $40,000 deposit on House B (illustrative figures, not a real transaction). If both are accepted, $70,000 in deposits is what you must produce in short order — before anyone talks about the purchase prices themselves.
- A brokerage does not simply award the deposit to one side. Under Form 100 the deposit goes to the Deposit Holder to be held in trust pending completion or other termination of the agreement, and is credited toward the price on completion. Under section 27 of the Trust in Real Estate Services Act, 2002, a brokerage must deposit trust money into a designated trust account, keep it separate from its own money, and disburse it only in accordance with the terms of the trust. So "breach means automatic forfeiture" is said too quickly: who ultimately gets the money turns on the agreement's terms, a mutual release signed by both parties, or a court decision — not on a phone call from either side.
- The seller's loss may exceed the deposit. On the home you cannot complete, the price the seller gets on a resale and the costs carried in the meantime may both form part of a claim. How much is a question for a lawyer on the facts and the evidence of your case; this article gives no figure, and you should not borrow a number from someone else's case online.
In short, the risk runs in this order: first two contracts exist at once, then two deposits and the ability to pay for two homes, and only then a negotiation in which you ask the other side to release you — by which point the leverage is no longer yours.
Three misunderstandings I hear most often
"The irrevocable period passed, but a verbal withdrawal is the same thing." It is not. During the irrevocable period you cannot withdraw. Only when the time runs out without an acceptance does the offer become null and void under clause 1. Work from the date and time written on the document, not from memory or a chat thread.
"Both of my offers have conditions, so I must be safe." Not necessarily. Each condition has its own deadline and its own way of being satisfied. Once a condition is fulfilled or waived, that agreement can become a firm obligation. Holding two conditional agreements at once is not the same as holding no risk.
"Worst case, I lose one deposit and learn a lesson." The deposit is only the first layer. The other party's actual loss can go beyond it, and the deposit itself sits in trust: it moves only on an agreed release, a court order, or a similar arrangement. It is neither automatically the seller's because you backed out, nor automatically refunded because you regret it.
If you have two homes you want right now, do these five things in order
- Rank them, and name one first target only. Let only one offer sit inside its irrevocable period at a time. That is the cheapest line of defence in this whole subject.
- Keep the irrevocable time on the first offer reasonably short, and check the written date and time carefully. Agree up front how long the seller needs to consider it; do not casually write in a long deadline.
- Do not sign the second offer until the first time has truly passed and you have confirmed there was no acceptance. If the first offer comes back signed back, that is a new offer — judge it by the new time on the sign-back, not the old one.
- After every signing, check that the Confirmation of Acceptance shows a date and time, and that they are correct. If the deposit is Upon Acceptance, the 24-hour delivery clock runs from that acceptance.
- If two offers have already gone out with overlapping times, do not send either side a "I don't want it anymore" message on your own. Take both complete files to an Ontario real estate lawyer at once, establish which agreement was formed and where each condition stands, and only then decide how to communicate.
Trust Professional, Diligent Work. I am Ming Ren. Before you submit an offer, lay the times on both documents side by side and read them clearly — we will go through the paperwork item by item.
This article is general information only, not legal advice. The terms of your offers, your condition deadlines, and the timeline of your case can change the conclusion. Consult an Ontario lawyer before acting.
Primary sources: OREA Form 100, Agreement of Purchase and Sale, clause 1 (Irrevocability), clause 13, the deposit clause and the Confirmation of Acceptance (public version, consulted November 2026); Trust in Real Estate Services Act, 2002, S.O. 2002, c.30, Sched. C, s.27 (Ontario e-Laws, consulted November 2026). The $30,000, $40,000 and $70,000 figures are illustrative only, not a real transaction.
Frequently asked questions
Is a verbal withdrawal the same once the irrevocable period has passed?
No, during the irrevocable period you cannot withdraw, and only when the time runs out without an acceptance does the offer become null and void under clause 1. Work from the date and time written on the document, not from memory.
If both of my offers have conditions, am I safe?
Not necessarily, because each condition has its own deadline and way of being satisfied. Once a condition is fulfilled or waived, that agreement can become a firm obligation, so two conditional agreements are not the same as no risk.
Is the worst case just losing one deposit?
The deposit is only the first layer, and the other party's actual loss can go beyond it. The deposit sits in trust and moves only on an agreed release, a court order, or a similar arrangement.


