Ming RenBroker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage
☎ 647-779-9186

Buying a Home

Your Agent Handed You a CMA. How Do You Read It — and Check It?

By , Broker, RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc. (About Ming) · Published

Ming Ren · Broker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage

← All articles · Buying a Home · Category guide

I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.

The plain version first: a CMA (Comparative Market Analysis) is a pricing tool your agent prepares to help set a list price or an offer price. It is not a formal appraisal, and no lender will lend against it. When a CMA lands in front of you, do not start with the final number. Start with how it was built — which properties were chosen, and what adjustments were made. If those two things hold up to questions, the conclusion is worth using.

First, separate the three "value" numbers

Three different numbers circulate in an Ontario transaction, and they are routinely confused. Each does its own job:

Number Who produces it What it is for Will a lender use it?
CMA Your real estate agent A reference for pricing and offer strategy No
Formal appraisal An appraiser designated by the Appraisal Institute of Canada (AACI or CRA), working to the CUSPAP standards Mortgage approvals, estates, divorce settlements and other formal purposes Yes — this is the one lenders rely on
MPAC assessment The Municipal Property Assessment Corporation Calculating property tax No

The MPAC number deserves one extra line. According to MPAC, Ontario property assessments still use a valuation date of January 1, 2016, because the 2020 province-wide reassessment was postponed. In other words, your MPAC figure describes your home's value on a ten-year-old basis, for tax purposes. It says very little about what the home would sell for today. Using an MPAC number to negotiate price, or a CMA to support a mortgage application, is using the wrong tool for the job.

1. Look at how the comparables were chosen

Almost all of a CMA's credibility sits in the comparable selection. When I review one, I check which of the three categories appear:

  • Recent sales: The hardest evidence. The closer to today, the better; in a fast-moving market, a sale from many months ago carries less weight.
  • Active listings: These show what sellers are asking, not what buyers are paying. They are a ceiling check, not evidence of value.
  • Expired or terminated listings: Homes the market said no to, at that price. A CMA with sales but no expired listings is telling only half the story.

Then check each comparable on its own merits: same or immediately adjacent neighbourhood, same property type (detached against detached, condo against condo), broadly similar size and age, similar bedroom and bathroom counts. If one comparable is far away, a different type, or an old sale, ask the agent directly why it is in — and why a closer match is not.

2. Look at whether the adjustments run in both directions

No two homes are identical, so a CMA converts the differences between each comparable and your home into dollars, added or subtracted. Common adjustments cover living area, parking, a finished versus unfinished basement, kitchen and bathroom condition, the age of the furnace and roof, and — for condos — floor, exposure and maintenance fees.

My rule for reading adjustments is simple: they must be symmetrical. A difference that favours your home adjusts one way; a difference that works against it must adjust back. If every adjustment in a CMA points the same direction — all up, or all down — that is not analysis; that is a conclusion looking for support. Ask the agent to walk through each figure and the sales data behind it.

An invented example, purely to show the arithmetic: one comparable has an extra parking space and is adjusted down by $30,000; another has one fewer space and is adjusted up by only $10,000. Same item, two directions, two different standards — that report deserves questions on the spot.

3. Look for the market temperature

Pricing is not only "what did similar homes sell for" but also "how fast are they selling now." A complete CMA should show roughly how long the comparables took to sell, and roughly what share of the asking price they achieved. You do not need to memorize market statistics; you only need to check that those figures come from the same period as the comparables themselves. Applying last year's hot-market ratios to today's pricing skews the answer.

Three misunderstandings I hear most often

"The CMA price is the value the bank will accept." No. Lenders rely on a formal appraisal by an AIC-designated appraiser working to CUSPAP. A CMA carries no weight in a mortgage approval — and if the appraisal comes in below your purchase price, the shortfall is yours to cover. Know that before you offer, not after.

"My MPAC assessment is low, so I overpaid." The MPAC figure is a tax number on a January 1, 2016 valuation basis. It is not comparable to today's market price in either direction.

"A CMA from an agent is automatically objective." A CMA is built by a person choosing properties and setting adjustments. Different choices produce noticeably different conclusions. It can be careful analysis, or it can be steered — the difference is whether you ask the questions above.

When a CMA lands in front of you, ask these in order

  1. How many sold, active and expired comparables are in here? Why these ones — and which nearby sales were left out?
  2. How was each adjustment amount set? Are size, parking and renovation treated the same way in both directions?
  3. How recent are these sales, and which period do the market-temperature figures (days to sell, share of asking price achieved) come from?
  4. What happens at the low end of the range versus the high end — how would the home be marketed, and how long might each take?
  5. If financing, an estate or a separation is involved, ask early whether a formal appraisal will be required, so the CMA is not asked to do a job it cannot do.

Trust Professional, Diligent Work. I am Ming Ren. When you receive a CMA, do not stop at the price on the last page — pull out the comparables and the adjustments, and we will go through the sales one by one.


This article is general information only, not legal advice and not a formal appraisal. Pricing and offer decisions should be based on current sales data and your own circumstances; where a formal valuation is required, engage an AIC-designated appraiser.

Primary sources: MPAC guidance on property assessment and the January 1, 2016 valuation date (mpac.ca, consulted November 2026); Appraisal Institute of Canada material on the AACI and CRA designations and the CUSPAP standards. The $30,000 and $10,000 parking adjustments are illustrative only, not a real transaction.

Frequently asked questions

Is the CMA price the value the bank will accept?

No. Lenders rely on a formal appraisal by an AIC-designated appraiser working to CUSPAP, and a CMA carries no weight in a mortgage approval. If the appraisal comes in below your purchase price, the shortfall is yours to cover.

If my MPAC assessment is low, does that mean I overpaid?

No. The MPAC figure is a tax number on a January 1, 2016 valuation basis and is not comparable to today's market price in either direction.

Is a CMA from an agent automatically objective?

No. A CMA is built by a person choosing properties and setting adjustments, and different choices produce noticeably different conclusions. It can be careful analysis or it can be steered, depending on whether you ask the checking questions.

This article in other languages: 中文فارسی

Want to talk about your home?

You can also call directly, or scan the code to add Ming on WeChat.

Ming’s WeChat QR code
Scan to add on WeChat

Community guides by city

All cities →
☎ Call MingFree Evaluation