Ming RenBroker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage
☎ 647-779-9186

Buying a Home

How Much Is a Home Really Worth? How a Defensible Value Is Built in Ontario

By , Broker, RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc. (About Ming) · Published

Ming Ren · Broker · RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage

← All articles · Buying a Home · Category guide

I am Ming Ren, a Broker with RE/MAX Realtron.

The plain conclusion first: what a home is worth is not a number someone invents. It is a range built step by step from completed sales. The asking price is what the seller hopes for, and the MPAC assessment is a number built for property taxes — neither one is market value. A defensible estimate does only three things: pick the right comparable sales, adjust the differences one item at a time, and cross-check the result with other methods.

This article is about the method itself. Once you understand these three things, you can judge whether any valuation put in front of you holds up.

1. Choosing the right comparables decides most of the answer

A valuation rests on sales, not listings. A home can sit listed for three months with no takers; a sold price is what a real buyer and a real seller actually agreed on. The most commonly used route is the Direct Comparison Approach — one of the three approaches to value set out in the professional standards of the Appraisal Institute of Canada. It values the target home by comparing it with similar homes that have recently sold.

I hold comparables to four rules:

  • Recent: Start with sales from the last three months. If there are not enough, extend to six — and the further back you go, the more carefully you must account for how the market itself has moved in between.
  • Same area: The same street and the same neighbourhood first. Cross a major road or a school boundary and you may be in a different price world; do not borrow numbers across that line casually.
  • Same type: Detached against detached, townhouse against townhouse, with bedroom count and size as close as possible — living area within roughly ten to twenty percent.
  • Enough of them: At least three sold comparables as a floor, around five is better. With only one or two, what you have is a rough reference, not a valuation.

One more rule I repeat to clients: active listings and listings that expired unsold tell you about seller expectations and how cold or hot the market feels. They do not belong in the valuation itself. Treating hope as fact is the most common wrong starting point.

2. Adjust the differences item by item — never as a lump sum

No two homes are identical, so once the comparables are chosen, each difference between a comparable and the target home is converted into money and added or subtracted. The rule is one sentence: where the comparable is better than the target, subtract from its sold price; where it is worse, add. After adjustment, the comparables should pull together into a fairly narrow range.

An example with numbers I invented purely to show the logic — they are illustrative figures, not any neighbourhood's market data: suppose the target is a three-bedroom home with an unfinished basement. Comparable A sold for $1,000,000 (illustrative), but it has one more bedroom and a finished basement, so those two items come down — say $60,000 combined (illustrative) — for an adjusted figure of about $940,000. Comparable B sold for $960,000 (illustrative), but it is older and in a slightly weaker location, so it adjusts up — say $30,000 (illustrative) — to about $990,000. Adjust every comparable the same way, and if they land between $940,000 and $990,000, that range is the first draft of the value.

Two points matter here. First, every adjustment needs a basis: a size difference is converted using what sold homes in that area actually achieve per square foot, and items like parking, renovations, and age are priced by what buyers there demonstrably pay extra for them — not by feel. Second, price per square foot is only a supporting ruler. It works well for units of the same layout in the same building; for a detached house it is crude, because lot size, exposure, and finish are all crushed into one rate, and used alone it will mislead you.

3. Cross-check with the other two approaches

I will not price or offer on a number that comes from one method alone. Professional appraisal has two other approaches, and they exist precisely as checks:

  • Cost Approach: What is the land worth, plus what would it cost to rebuild the home today, less depreciation? If that total sits far from the comparison result, something in one of the calculations is wrong and needs finding. This approach is especially useful for newer homes and unusual properties.
  • Income Approach: If the home is held for rent, work backwards from the rent it can earn and the returns buyers of similar rental properties accept. For an investment purchase, this line often says more than the comparison approach does.

There is also one ready-made reference: the MPAC assessment. Be clear about what it is. MPAC is Ontario's property assessment body, and its values exist to support property taxation. Province-wide assessments are still based on a valuation date of January 1, 2016 — so that figure reflects a value point from years ago, not today's market. Use it to sanity-check the order of magnitude, never as the basis for an offer.

A value is defensible when the approaches land close to each other and the remaining gaps can be explained. When one line clearly runs off on its own, find out why — do not simply average the three and move on.

Three misunderstandings I hear most often

"The asking price is the market price; how much comes off is just negotiation." The asking price is a seller's strategy. Some list low to invite competing offers; some list high and wait. Market value is set by completed sales and has no necessary connection to the number on the listing.

"The MPAC assessment is below the sold prices, so this home is a bargain." No. MPAC works from a January 1, 2016 valuation date, for tax purposes. Today's sold prices reflect today's market. The two numbers disagreeing is normal, and judging a bargain by the assessment points you in the wrong direction entirely.

"The renovation cost that much, so the price should go up by that much." Money spent on a renovation is recovered only as far as buyers will pay for it. A kitchen that cost $200,000 to install might add $80,000 at sale — or nothing at all if the style is too personal. Value is what buyers pay, not what the seller spent. (Both figures here are illustrative.)

If you had to value a home today, do these five things in order

  1. Set the frame first: same area, same property type, sold within the last three months. Pull at least three comparables and lay out each one's sold price, sale date, size, and bedroom count in one table.
  2. Adjust item by item: convert every difference between each comparable and the target into a dollar figure — subtract where the comparable is better, add where it is worse — and write down the basis for each line. No lump sums, no round guesses.
  3. Check how tightly they converge: if the adjusted prices land in a narrow range, that range is your preliminary value. If they scatter widely, the comparables were chosen badly — go back and choose again instead of forcing an answer.
  4. Cross-check: run rental properties backwards from their rent, test newer or unusual homes with the cost approach, and glance at the MPAC assessment to confirm the order of magnitude is sane.
  5. State the conclusion as a range, not a single number, and record which sales it rests on and as of what date. When the market moves, refresh the sold sample first, then talk price.

Trust Professional, Diligent Work. I am Ming Ren. If you are pricing a home to sell or weighing what to offer, bring the address and the documents, and we will work through the sold data, item by item.


This article is general information only. It is not legal advice and it is not a formal appraisal; a formal appraisal must be prepared by a licensed appraiser under professional standards. A property's condition and the market at the time can change the conclusion, so consult a qualified professional before acting.

Primary sources: MPAC property assessment information (mpac.ca; valuation date January 1, 2016); Appraisal Institute of Canada, Canadian Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice — the Direct Comparison, Cost, and Income Approaches. The figures $1,000,000, $960,000, $60,000, $30,000, $940,000, $990,000, $200,000, and $80,000 are illustrative numbers invented for this article, not real transactions or market data.

Frequently asked questions

Is the asking price the market price, with the discount just a matter of negotiation?

No. The asking price is a seller's strategy; some list low to invite competing offers and some list high and wait. Market value is set by completed sales and has no necessary connection to the number on the listing.

If the MPAC assessment is below sold prices, is the home a bargain?

No. MPAC works from a January 1, 2016 valuation date, for tax purposes, while today's sold prices reflect today's market. The two numbers disagreeing is normal, and judging a bargain by the assessment points you in the wrong direction.

Should a home's price go up by whatever the renovation cost?

No. Money spent on a renovation is recovered only as far as buyers will pay for it, and a style that is too personal may add nothing at all. Value is what buyers pay, not what the seller spent.

This article in other languages: 中文فارسی

Want to talk about your home?

You can also call directly, or scan the code to add Ming on WeChat.

Ming’s WeChat QR code
Scan to add on WeChat

Community guides by city

All cities →
☎ Call MingFree Evaluation